Is DC Studios on the Brink of Disaster with Their Uncertain Future?

by

During the last week of February 2025, the heads of DC Studios, James Gunn and Peter Safran, took a group of journalists to discuss future plans for the DC Universe. These plans will initially unfold on the big screen starting with July’s Superman movie. Although Gunn had revealed the titles for the DCU’s first phase, “Gods and Monsters,” back in October 2023, one might have anticipated fresh disclosures. However, this press event didn’t provide many new details about the DC Universe. Titles that were in development two years ago such as The Authority and The Brave and The Bold are still under consideration. No new casting announcements were made.

The ultimate destiny of the DC Universe will be revealed once Superman graces the big screen, allowing us to gauge the audience’s reaction. At present, though, I must admit that I have some concerns about the future of this franchise due to DC Studios’ current direction, as Gunn and Safran’s plans seem to be treading too close to the path of the DC Extended Universe, which is causing me unease.

A Scattershot DC Universe Future

Read moreDeadpool & Wolverine Director Reveals What Part of Making Sequel Was Most Fun

In January 2023, following the unveiling of the first-ever DC Universe projects, Gunn commented that the past ten years of DC Comics adaptations had been disorganized, saying they were “messed up.” For Gunn, these characters had been handled haphazardly, leading to various storylines such as the Arrowverse, disparate timelines within the DCEU based on different versions of Justice League, and more. “They treated their intellectual properties like party favors,” Gunn stated, implying they gave away these properties too casually to any creators who seemed friendly. Gunn expressed his desire for a more unified shared universe in future projects.

In approximately two years, certain aspirations for the DC Universe have begun to align with elements of the DCEU (DC Extended Universe) that Gunn previously criticized. Notably, there’s the solo Clayface movie on the horizon, suggesting a new wave of DC films focused on live-action solo movies featuring Batman villains, rather than developing lesser-known comic book characters. Initially, Gunn had no intention of making a Clayface feature, but a compelling script by Mike Flanagan convinced him to greenlight the project. Unlike Joker, Clayface will be part of a broader continuity, which may suggest that these properties are once again being treated like “party favors”.

In simpler terms, Gunn and Safran have stated that the initial lineup of DC Studios movies is currently on hold. Instead, unexpected projects such as “Sgt. Rock” and “Clayface” are now being focused on. This approach can be seen as a positive move because it means the DC Universe isn’t solely tied to release dates or press releases. It’s good that they’re not rushing out movies when they’re not ready. However, it feels like we’re back to the old way of things with live-action DC films, where new projects are being thrown around without a clear plan. Despite the changes, things seem to be repeating themselves.

The DCU Is In a Holding Pattern Until Superman

Read moreHunt: Showdown Permanently Gets Cheaper, but With a Catch

The main point that stands out from this gathering is that the DC Universe seems to be in an uncertain phase, waiting for the arrival of Superman. While series like Peacemaker, Creature Commandos, and Lanterns continue their production, films appear to be less consistent. At present, only Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow is being filmed, and beyond that Superman spinoff, there’s a vague outline (even Clayface doesn’t have a confirmed lead actor yet). This situation contrasts starkly with the enthusiasm expressed by Gunn when announcing DC Studios movies two years ago.

In January 2023, Warner Bros. hadn’t enjoyed four DCEU films that were financial flops for the studio, unlike Marvel Studios which hadn’t faced its major money drains like “Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania” and “The Marvels” yet. The current state of American superhero movies is precarious, with Gunn and his team taking a wait-and-see approach regarding whether Superman will follow in the footsteps of Deadpool and Wolverine or Captain America: Brave New World, before fully diving into a wave of cinematic DC productions. This strategy, however, has put DC Studios in a peculiar position reminiscent of the DC Extended Universe, where the future was often unpredictable or difficult to anticipate.

The reassurances by Gunn and Safran that the DC Universe is secure seem troubling, much like a suspicious person telling you they have nothing hidden when clearly they do. Just as their repeated “everything’s fine here now, how are you?” questions made you more uneasy, these constant assertions create doubt rather than allay it. It’s possible that Superman will become a sensational hit in just a few months, rendering such thoughts obsolete like the 1982 predictions about E.T.’s longevity. However, at this juncture, Gunn and Safran’s awkward press conference has sparked more apprehension about the DC Universe than anticipation, given that this franchise appears to be mirroring the saga it was intended to surpass.

Read More

2025-03-02 02:40