Is Disney Giving Up on Streaming and Threatening Star Wars Future?

In a surprising revelation, showrunner Tony Gilroy of Andor shares that Disney confided to him during the development of season 2 that “Streaming is obsolete.” This bold declaration from a heavyweight in the entertainment sector, made straight to the esteemed creator of Star Wars: Andor, has now cast a significant doubt over the future of Star Wars content on Disney+. The streaming service has played a crucial role in expanding the franchise, with hits like Star Wars: Ahsoka and The Mandalorian.

Despite the fact that Andor has been applauded for its sophisticated storytelling, intricate characters, and bold examination of rebellion against tyranny, a surprising stance from Disney hints at a shift in their content approach. This contrast – the artistic success of the Star Wars series like Andor clashing with Disney’s reservations about streaming platforms – poses important questions about the future of Star Wars productions and whether the distant galaxy may be facing turbulent times on television.

Disney’s Shifting Streaming Strategy Conflicts With Andor’s Success

According to a report from IndieWire at the ATX Television Festival, Gilroy stated that Disney appeared hesitant towards streaming during talks for Andor Season 2, which raises concerns about Disney+’s dedication to expensive television productions in the long run. In relation to the usage of the term “genocide” by Mon Mothma in Andor Season 2, Episode 9 – “Welcome to the Rebellion”, Gilroy commented:

Over the past couple weeks, I’ve been given permission to use the term ‘fascism’. It feels liberating. However, it shouldn’t come as a surprise or be overly complex for people to comprehend the path I must tread to accomplish this – to reach a wider audience and safeguard the courageous investment of a remarkable company. This is simply necessary.

Expanding on the topic, Gilroy went on to explain, “To Disney, it’s a $650 million investment. Throughout the 24 episodes, I didn’t take a single suggestion. In the first season, we dared to say ‘F-ck the Empire,’ and they asked us to tone it down. In the second season, they said streaming was no longer viable due to financial constraints, so we argued about money but they never made any changes. With such freedom comes obligations.

This acclaim arrives for Andor, despite its clear critical victory. The series has been applauded for its raw realism and complexity – in terms of both its characters and the heavy topics it addresses – a rarity within the Star Wars realm. Both critics and fans have commended Andor for breaking away from the frequently criticized fan service typical of other Star Wars projects, instead captivating audiences with a compelling narrative about the origins of the Rebellion. The series’ success stems from its bravery in challenging conventions, delving into themes such as fascism, occupation, and resistance with a sincerity that deeply resonates with modern viewers. Andor demonstrates the possibility for Star Wars to grow beyond its traditional magical elements into a more realistic, politically charged drama.

With a $650 million investment and creative liberty that Gilroy claims to have extensively enjoyed, Andor managed to attain a level of quality that made it stand out from other series. However, Disney’s statement about the streaming model being unsustainable indicates that the high cost of producing ambitious shows, even those that receive critical acclaim, might no longer fit within their budgets as they adapt to new financial realities. The skepticism towards streaming services underscores a larger trend in the industry where the economics of direct-to-consumer platforms are being reassessed, as these services have frequently focused on subscriber growth over immediate profitability.

For “Star Wars”, a series that played a crucial role in Disney+’s debut and ongoing popularity, reconsidering its strategy might lead to substantial adjustments in upcoming content. This could involve an inclination towards more affordable productions or perhaps returning to cinematic releases for major titles.

In other words, Disney’s financial difficulties in its streaming sector hint at a possible change in strategy. If upcoming Star Wars series and seasons of established shows don’t attract significant audiences, they may encounter budget constraints affecting their quality. This could signal the end of an era filled with abundant Star Wars content on Disney+, moving towards a model that focuses more on financial success rather than extensive storytelling. Given the popularity and expansive nature of Star Wars, such a change might lead to a less diverse and daring future for the franchise, possibly restricting the creative freedom that made Andor so successful.

Disney’s Shifting Streaming Strategy Conflicts With Andor’s Success

Read More