James Gunn’s ‘Weak’ Superman: A Bold Move to Revive the Iconic Hero!

by

As the first chapter of the DC Universe, “Superman” is about to make its debut, and James Gunn’s interpretation of the character has sparked controversy for seeming “vulnerable.” However, this might actually address a long-standing criticism of the character. Recently, a full trailer for “Superman” was unveiled, showcasing the titular hero engaging in battles with various opponents such as a massive kaiju creature, María Gabriela de Faría’s Engineer, and an enigmatic black-clad adversary believed to be Ultraman. The depiction of Superman fighting these adversaries has led some potential viewers to question the strength of David Corenswet’s portrayal of Superman, labeling it as weak.

The speculations about this new portrayal of Superman began as early as the first trailer for Superman, where he is shown injured and frozen in the arctic snow. For some, this contradicts the traditional image of Superman as an invincible Man of Steel with a seemingly endless list of superpowers. However, it addresses longstanding questions about Superman that have been around for decades, and provides a more complex and realistic character on the big screen.

Superman Being Too Powerful Has Long Been A Criticism Of The Man Of Steel

Some Believe Superman’s Powers Make Him Boring

The extraordinary abilities of Superman are virtually boundless, encompassing a range of powers such as remarkable strength and swiftness, but also more abstract talents like his capacity to erase memories with a kiss. His invulnerability, particularly in relation to kryptonite and the harmful consequences that come from exposure to it, is one of Superman’s most renowned traits. However, despite this weakness, or ‘Achilles heel’, Superman’s near-invincibility can sometimes diminish the tension for some viewers as it lessens the potential perils that Superman might encounter.

Enhancing this critique is Superman’s exceptional knack for doing good deeds. His unwavering nature often gives Superman a touch of monotony, which is partly why the character Homelander from The Boys is so intriguing. The powers that Superman possesses are far more ominous (and thus thrilling) when wielded by an undeniably evil character. This shift in perspective turns the relatively low-stakes story of Superman on its head, making it significantly more engaging.

James Gunn’s Superman Movie Is Getting The Character’s Power Level Right

Superman Will Be At His Most Compelling

James Gunn and David Corenswet’s portrayal of Superman in the teasers and trailers seems to address a frequent criticism by emphasizing the character’s vulnerabilities. The storyline shows Superman grappling with multiple threats, making his healing process under the focused rays of the sun appear arduous. This suggests that Superman will face formidable challenges, implying that his battles promise to be intense and engaging, as it appears he may not always emerge victorious.

There remains a chance that Superman’s adversaries, who seem to be humanoids, could have Kryptonite – a substance known to weaken or harm him. Given that these two characters appear to be connected to Lex Luthor and Superman is deeply rooted in the DC Universe, it wouldn’t be surprising if Luthor had obtained some Kryptonite by now. Furthermore, while Superman may not be invincible, he is exceptionally powerful among superheroes. This potential vulnerability offers intriguing storytelling possibilities.

Superman Being Less Powerful Can Focus On More Interesting Aspects Of The Character

Superman Can Focus On How To Use His Powers

James Gunn has confirmed that the upcoming Superman movie will not retell his origin story. Given that audiences are already familiar with Superman’s basic powers and feats, the new film doesn’t need as much time to show what Superman can do compared to films like Man of Steel. Instead, by focusing on a narrative where Superman experiences pain and potential mental weaknesses, this version of Superman is set to delve into less-examined aspects of his character that are more intriguing.

This expansion also provides a novel starting point for the DCU’s Superman storyline. Instead of primarily showcasing his powers, the movie could delve deeper into Superman’s dilemma about when and how to employ his abilities. Although he may confront challenges from other super-powered beings, he has the potential to single-handedly prevent a war, a situation that raises ethical questions, as discussed in interviews with Superman and Lois. Essentially, this flawed version of Superman presents an opportunity for the DCU to venture into unexplored territories, making the character feel more relatable and appealing to casual fans.

Read More

2025-05-24 04:30