John Nolan’s Smart Career Move Saves The Rookie From Major Mistake!

by

Following seven seasons, the police drama featuring Nathan Fillion as Officer John Nolan will come back for Season 8 on ABC. Initially, the series’ concept revolved around Nolan as the rookie cop, but a smart move regarding his career enabled the show’s title to remain relevant, regardless of how many seasons were produced. Originally, John Nolan aspired to become a detective, but choosing not to follow that typical career progression in the LAPD prevented a major blunder that could have derailed the series. The police procedural show has continued the partnership between Fillion and series creator Alexi Hawley, which started with Castle, another successful murder mystery series on ABC. The recent renewal for The Rookie reflects its enduring success in comparison to its predecessor.

The series continues to be a significant fixture on ABC’s programming lineup, despite the fact that it was initially considered an unlikely candidate for renewal for another season. Unlike many police procedural dramas, The Rookie primarily concentrates on street-level law enforcement, following officers from the Mid-Wilshire Division of the LAPD. Instead of a single case each week that unites the entire cast, the characters deal with numerous crimes, ranging from minor infractions to major incidents. The show offers a mix of high-octane action, shootouts, and arrests, but it also delves into unique police stories, exploring themes related to policing, their role in the community, and personal narratives that are independent of their jobs. In Season 1, one of John Nolan’s professional aspirations almost threatened to derail the show.

John Nolan Was Originally the LAPD’s Oldest Rookie and Then His Career Took a Turn

Being Framed by a Corrupt Officer Led to a Black Mark On His Record

In the initial season of The Rookie, there were many potential storylines that could have unfolded, but one of them was a budding romance that the producers decided to cut short. On the other hand, the ambition of Nolan and his fellow officers to move up in rank from patrol officer to detective lingered for a longer period. Interestingly, Melissa O’Neil’s character Chen also aimed for this promotion, but she didn’t make it through the detective exam. Instead, she was promoted to sergeant in Season 7, paving the way for the much-loved relationship between her and Eric Winter’s character Tim Bradford.

The start of Nolan’s career decline occurred when one of his peers from the academy, a young officer, died under mysterious circumstances. Investigations revealed a conspiracy within the ranks and uncovered the first corrupt cop on the show. Despite his efforts to apprehend the guilty party, Nolan was instead falsely accused of the murder. Following this dramatic turn of events that are characteristic of The Rookie, Nolan broke the law and went into hiding in order to clear his name. This illegal act resulted in him receiving a “Letter of Reprimand,” effectively ending any chance of becoming a detective and limiting his future promotions to beat cop positions.

Among the characters in the series, it was Harold Perrineau who portrayed the morally compromised police officer, Nick Armstrong. Before his exposure as a criminal associate, he had been an ally and guide to Nolan. The bittersweet aspect of this plot stemmed from the fact that when Nolan enlisted, he had very few allies. His status as the oldest LAPD recruit made most of the training officers, the shift commander, and others hostile towards him. However, as the protagonist of The Rookie, Nolan eventually gained their trust and admiration.

How John Nolan Got Back on Track to Becoming a Training Officer

Instead of Becoming a Detective He Used a ‘Golden Ticket’ to ‘Give Back’

Despite having limited job opportunities after graduation, Nolan chose to remain on the police force. He received recognition, in the form of a commendation from the police chief, following an extraordinary incident. This recognition, often referred to as a “golden ticket,” granted him special assignments within the LAPD regardless of his background. Interestingly, Nyla Harper, his training officer, similarly benefited from this unique advantage during her undercover work. Colleagues debated what role would best suit Nolan, suggesting options ranging from computer forensics to air assault, as well as some more comfortable positions within the Force.

In the finale of Season 5’s premiere, I found myself wielding my golden ticket, stepping into the role of a training officer. My new trainee was none other than Lisseth Chavez, portraying Celina Juarez – another familiar face from the Arrowverse. The title of our show took on a dual significance then, as Juarez was the novice in uniform, but I too was embarking on a new journey as a mentor. However, Season 5 saw more substantial shifts in the narrative structure. With both my comrades Harper and Alyssa Diaz’s Angela Lopez being promoted to detective positions, we delved deeper into traditional weekly cases, opening up new avenues for storytelling. This transition paved the way for more conventional case-of-the-week episodes.

Initially, it wasn’t a poor decision to give Fillion’s character less screen time and emphasize the roles of other characters in the series. If Nolan had been made a detective instead, what set this series apart would have vanished. The audience might have persisted to watch Nolan portray a typical TV police detective, but as the show’s title lost relevance, it could have left viewers confused.

Why Nolan’s Choice to Become a Training Officer Was Right for the Show

Not Just a Good Character Decision, It Helps the Title ‘The Rookie’ Make Sense

Following a truncated season, the series made some changes. It brought aboard two fresh training officers, and the narrative style morphed back to the multi-layered storytelling reminiscent of previous seasons. The show remains capable of fully committing to a concept, ranging from a romantic police officers’ ball to a citywide emergency like the Big Citywide Threat™. However, the majority of episodes now center on street-level stories, primarily teaching the new officers how to become effective cops. This character-driven approach sets The Rookie apart from similar shows and sheds light on policing issues that viewers might not anticipate.

John Nolan’s Season 7 Trainee Officers
Character Actor Result Significant Episode
Celina Juarez Lisseth Chavez Graduated Episode 7 “The Mickey”
Connor Craig David Gridley Transferred Episode 12 “April Fools”
Seth Ridley Patrick Keleher Injured Episode 16 “The Return”

In this rephrased version: Instead of continuing as the lead hero, Nolan’s character works more effectively as a mentor for a new recruit. An exceptionally poignant and impactful episode in Season 7 demonstrated this, where Fillion’s character was dismissed by Chen due to his fabrications about his past hardships and health issues. This particular episode showcased how the kind-hearted and amiable Fillion can portray Nolan as a demanding, almost intimidating Training Officer who places utmost importance on teaching his trainees, including Seth Ridley, the essential skills required to safeguard themselves, the citizens of Los Angeles, and even potential suspects.

As a devoted fan, I must admit that watching this show throughout its rich history has been an incredible journey. Yet, it was when John Nolan stepped into the role of a training officer that the series transcended its initial concept. His unique perspective as an underdog rookie adds depth to his teaching abilities. It also ensures that the core focus remains on the gritty street-level escapades, providing valuable lessons for his trainees and viewers alike about what it truly means to be a good cop.

You can find seasons 1 through 7 of “The Rookie” on Hulu, while season 8 is being produced for release during the fall-to-spring TV season.

Read More

2025-05-30 17:53