Menendez Brothers’ Lawyer Admits Ryan Murphy Show Helped Murder Case

Menendez Brothers' Lawyer Admits Ryan Murphy Show Helped Murder Case

As someone who has closely followed the Menendez brothers’ case for decades, I can’t help but feel a sense of intrigue and hope as the story unfolds yet again. The Ryan Murphy series, despite Erik’s criticism, seems to have stirred up conversations that could potentially change their lives. It’s fascinating how a work of fiction can sometimes lead to a factual reevaluation.


Although Erik Menendez has criticized Ryan Murphy’s portrayal of his and brother Lyle Menendez’s murder case, the series could potentially reshape or influence their lives in some way.

With fresh evidence potentially influencing a retrial, possible new sentencing or even release, attorneys for brothers serving life sentences for the 1989 murders of their parents Jose Menendez and Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez have expressed their thoughts on Ryan Murphy’s show “Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story”.

At a press conference held on October 16th, about a month after the release of the Ryan Murphy series, attorney Mark Geragos stated that the portrayal in the series was so exaggerated that it sparked a negative response, causing people to reconsider and take a closer look.

Erik strongly criticized Monster for its depiction of the siblings, but Ryan has chosen to ignore or downplay these criticisms.

In the 1993 court trial broadcasted on TV, it was stated that the reason Erik and Lyle fatally shot their parents was to gain access to their inheritance. But, the brothers claimed that their parents had been abusing them physically, emotionally, and sexually for a long time. Their legal team argued that they acted in self-defense when they killed their parents.

In 1996, after being found guilty at their second trial, Lyle and Eric received a sentence of life imprisonment with no chance of parole, due to the fatal shootings of their parents.

Menendez Brothers' Lawyer Admits Ryan Murphy Show Helped Murder Case

Geragos said that due to the “younger generation,” there has “been a movement.”

Geragos stated at the press conference that he is aware some videos of the initial trial were televised, where the District Attorney’s office argued men cannot be raped because they don’t possess the necessary equipment. He also mentioned encountering various arguments supporting this viewpoint.

In modern times, it’s almost impossible for those born later to comprehend such events. Therefore, I would argue that the changes over time have been truly groundbreaking, even earthquake-like in their impact.

For quite a while now, both brothers have been submitting habeas corpus requests aiming to reverse their verdicts, with the latest attempt made in 2023.

At the press conference, Geragos stated that if a new hearing (habeas) is granted, it could lead to another trial for the individuals in question. Furthermore, he explained that if they are resentenced by the judge under California law, the judge has the flexibility to choose from various sentencing options.

The petition claims that the shootings of the Menendez brothers’ parents were not premeditated murders, but rather instances of manslaughter, driven by an understandable yet irrational fear for self-protection, following years of alleged sexual and physical abuse.

Menendez Brothers' Lawyer Admits Ryan Murphy Show Helped Murder Case

In the given document, the legal team representing the siblings contends that a letter supposedly penned by Erik prior to the murders, which implicated their father in abuse claims, and similar accusations levied by former band member Ray Rosselló against Jose, undermine the avarice motive that prosecutors had presented during the trial.

Two weeks post the unveiling of “Monsters,” where Nicholas Alexander Chavez and Cooper Koch portrayed Lyle and Erik, I, as a lifestyle expert, found myself intrigued by a subsequent development. Los Angeles District Attorney George Gascon announced that his office would scrutinize fresh evidence, suggesting that the brothers had been victims of molestation.

Following 2005, they weren’t hopeful; instead, they felt certain they would serve out the remainder of their lives behind bars, and they had come to terms with this reality. – Geragos stated this.

He commented, “I prefer the phrase ‘guardedly hopeful.’ It’s somewhat paradoxical that Democratic Alliance politics had a part in their verdict.

Read More

2024-10-17 02:22