Menendez Brothers’ Lawyer Uncovers New Evidence in Murder Case

Menendez Brothers' Lawyer Uncovers New Evidence in Murder Case

As someone who has closely followed the Menendez Brothers‘ case for decades now, I find myself once again captivated by the latest developments in their ongoing saga. The new pieces of evidence presented by their legal team, particularly the letter written by Erik to his cousin Andy and the declaration by former Menudo member Roy Rosselló, have added a fascinating layer to this complex story.


New evidence is being presented by Erik Menendez and Lyle Menendez‘s lawyers.

The Menendez siblings are at present serving life imprisonment for the 1989 killings of their parents, José Menendez and Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez. However, Lyle and Erik, who were 21 and 18 years old during the incident, claim that the murders transpired due to long-term sexual abuse by their father. Lawyer Mark Geragos is optimistic that with the discovery of two new pieces of evidence, the brothers may be granted a reevaluation of their sentences.

During a press conference on October 16th, Geragos stated that Judge William Ryan made an unofficial demand for a response. This unofficial demand was aimed at urging the District Attorney to address the claims of newly discovered evidence.

Two fresh pieces of information have surfaced, one being a letter penned by Erik to his cousin Roy Rosselló Canto, approximately eight months prior to the homicides, which contained accusations of mistreatment. The second is a testimony from a former member of the band Menudo, Roy Rosselló, who claimed that he too was victimized by José – a colleague of his at RCA Records while serving as COO – within the Menendez residence.

The letter addressed to Andy was discovered at the residence of Marta Cano, Lyle and Erik’s aunt who is also José’s sister. As stated by Geragos, during the initial trial that commenced in 1993, Andy testified. However, by the time of the second trial in 1996, his testimony was either discredited as fabricated or deemed untrue.

According to Geragos, this letter serves as evidence or supports the fact that Andy was speaking truthfully, and it details the incident of abuse.

Menendez Brothers' Lawyer Uncovers New Evidence in Murder Case

Concerning Roy’s assertions, he signed a statement in 2023 accusing José of physical abuse against the singer. Geragos emphasized that it required significant bravery for Roy to speak out after such a long time, and he considered the information as highly crucial, given that the alleged incident occurred within the Menendez residence.

Geragos pointed out that the statement supports the idea that José believed his safe haven was within the house.

He went on to explain, “This aligns with what the family stated as a strict and awkward rule in their household: you weren’t allowed to walk the hallway when José was with any of the boys. This was the basis for his predatory behavior.

As per Geragos, Lyle (aged 56) and Erik (aged 53) felt they had utilized all possible legal options by 2005, accepting that they would spend the remainder of their lives in prison. However, he remains optimistic that with the recent discovery of new evidence, they may be given a fresh sentence.

Menendez Brothers' Lawyer Uncovers New Evidence in Murder Case

Over the past year, my attention has been consistently drawn to the Menendez brothers, with their names frequently gracing the headlines due to fresh evidence, the captivating Netflix documentary titled “Menendez Brothers,” and Ryan Murphy’s gripping miniseries, “Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez.

In that gripping film, I couldn’t help but be enthralled as Lyle and Erik laid bare their harrowing experiences of being subjected to abuse by their father. Lyle poignantly shared his feelings, expressing that he found it extremely hard to discuss anything related to our past.

Dr. Ann Burgess observed in her report that following encounters with the individuals soon after the murders, it seemed evident to her that “there must have been some kind of familial issue or dynamic at play for this incident to occur.

She went on to say, “There’s no reason, like a need for money or any other motivation, or seeking revenge, or anything else we might consider, that they would do this.” Then she added, “What I’m sensing is something deeply troubling within the family.

Read More

2024-10-17 03:18