Nintendo Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Which gaming handheld is better?

The advanced version of the Nintendo Switch, known as the Nintendo Switch 2, is scheduled for launch on June 5, 2025. Compared to its predecessor, the original hybrid handheld console, it boasts enhanced specifications.

Since 2023, the ASUS ROG Ally has been available, essentially functioning as a compact Windows 11 gaming laptop equipped with built-in controllers. Notably, it is only offered in a sleek white housing.

Absolutely, another device I often suggest is the latest ROG Ally X, which stands out as the top-tier portable PC gaming device available currently. Notably, it’s only available in black at the moment.

If you’re finding it tough to choose between a Switch 2 and an ROG Ally, you’ve landed in the ideal spot!

I’ve put these two unique handheld devices side by side, examining them in several aspects, so you can choose the one that aligns most with your preferred gaming style.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally Specs

Initially, let’s examine the specifications of both the Switch 2 and ROG Ally (including the ROG Ally X model). Once that’s done, we’ll explore various aspects and compare these portable devices side by side.

Having taken a brief look at the specifications, allow me to share my insights on how these distinctions and commonalities could impact you as a potential user.

In this way, I hope to provide a clearer understanding of what owning this product might entail for you.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Price

Initially, analysts speculated that the price of the Switch 2 would be $399.99 or higher, but it’s now confirmed that the new generation Switch will retail at $449.99.

Additionally, you can opt for a Mario Kart World Bundle priced at $499.99, which includes a game as part of the deal and offers you a discount on the game’s regular price.

Starting on the 9th of April, two new pre-orders will be available. The handheld device, referred to as Switch 2, is slated to hit the market on the 5th of June, 2025. If you’re keen, feel free to register for Switch 2 notifications at Best Buy.

With this buy, you’ll receive additional value as the Switch 2 package includes a TV docking station, a charger, and an extra controller. On the other hand, the ROG Ally only comes with a charger.

Compared to the initial ROG Ally AMD Z1 (non-Extreme), priced at $499.99 on Best Buy, the base Switch 2 comes in at a lower cost of $50 less. It’s particularly suitable for cloud gaming and Xbox Game Pass users.

Speaking of it, if you decide to purchase an ROG Ally, I’d suggest you opt for the Z1 Extreme model priced at $649.99 on Best Buy. This configuration delivers superior gaming performance for offline gaming experiences.

Currently, if you’re seeking the top-tier portable PC gaming device, there’s an upgraded ROG Ally X model with a sleek black exterior. This version is available for $799.99 on Best Buy.

The reason for its higher price is that it boasts greater memory and storage capabilities, along with twice the battery power compared to the white Ally model.

Don’t forget about handheld sales

For several years, I’ve kept an eye on discounted handheld devices, specifically the ones from ASUS. Notably, they often see significant price drops (as much as $200) during promotional events such as Prime Day and Black Friday at Best Buy.

Purchasing an ROG Ally during one of these sales will likely cost you less than the suggested retail price of the Switch 2.

In contrast, the initial Nintendo Switch handhelds seldom experienced price reductions, and when they did, the discount was minimal. Given this, it seems uncertain that the Switch 2 will come close to matching the sales figures of ROG Ally devices.

WINNER:

The Nintendo Switch 2 boasts a more affordable initial cost and includes additional items such as a TV docking station within the package. On the other hand, the ROG Ally portable devices often receive significant price reductions, making them potentially cheaper than the Nintendo Switch 2.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Performance

As the launch of the Switch 2 is still pending, it’s challenging to definitively compare its performance with the ROG Ally and ROG Ally X. However, I’ve formed some informed assumptions based on the device’s known specifications.

Although specific details regarding the custom NVIDIA processor in the Switch 2 are still under wraps, it’s been disclosed that the upcoming Switch 2 incorporates Tensor Cores, enabling advanced AI capabilities such as Deep Learning Super Sampling (DLSS) and Ray Tracing support.

Additionally, the new Switch 2 offers Variable Refresh Rate (VRR) technology, specifically NVIDIA G-Sync, to enhance motion smoothness by preventing screen splitting.

The upgraded Switch 2 is expected to deliver much more impressive graphics (up to 4K resolution) and improved gaming experience in terms of fluidity compared to the first model. Yet, it’s important to note that occasional stuttering or lag may still be experienced on these new devices.

It’s been observed that the configurations for the ROG Ally Z1 Extreme offer exceptional handheld gaming performance, which is among the best you can find in the market, surpassed only by the high-end MSI Claw 8 AI+.

The Z1 Non-Extreme Ally, while still capable, is more compatible with cloud gaming due to its lower power capabilities compared to some other options.

The ROG Ally and Ally X, unlike the Lenovo Legion Go, offer Variable Refresh Rate (VRR) technology, specifically through AMD FreeSync. This feature enables the device to maintain a good frames per second (FPS) rate based on the type of game being run.

In simple terms, I upgraded AFMF 2 on my ASUS ROG Ally and boosted its VRAM, leading to a significant improvement in frame rates during gaming sessions. This enhancement allowed me to consistently achieve an average of 88 frames per second while playing Cyberpunk 2077.

On Ally handhelds, there might still be occasional stuttering and roughness, but when compared to other PC handhelds currently available, the performance of ROG Ally is quite impressive. It’s reasonable to assume it outperforms the hypothetical Switch 2.

What about storage and memory?

The as-yet unrevealed successor model of the Nintendo Switch might have a limited memory size, given that its predecessor featured just 4GB of LPDDR4 RAM.

Simultaneously, the initial ROG Ally sports a 16GB LPDDR5X memory, whereas the Ally X model boasts 24GB LPDDR5X RAM. Generally speaking, having a greater amount of RAM allows your system to retrieve game data quicker.

Moreover, the new Switch 2 features 256GB internal memory, albeit smaller than usual for PC handhelds, it significantly surpasses the modest 32GB storage space found in the initial Switch model.

As an enthusiastic supporter, I’d like to share that expanding the storage on your Switch 2 can be done, but it’s essential to note that the handheld device supports microSD Express cards exclusively – classic microSD cards are not compatible in this instance.

The ROG Ally model features a 512GB Solid State Drive (SSD), whereas the ROG Ally X variant can include an SSD ranging from 1TB to 2TB. Both models support standard microSD cards as well.

Swapping out the SSD on my ROG Ally allowed for additional storage space for games, making it a viable solution as well.

Historically, Nintendo has been cautious about modifications to its hardware, so it seems plausible that alterations or upgrades similar to those you mentioned may not be straightforward on the Switch 2.

It’s quite plausible that the Switch 2 and ROG Ally might deliver comparable performance in general. Nevertheless, since the ROG Ally and ROG Ally X boast larger memory and storage capacities, they may potentially outperform their counterpart in terms of speed and efficiency.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Touchscreen & display output

The ROG Ally and ROG Ally X sport identical 7-inch LED touchscreens with a maximum resolution of 1080 and a swift refresh rate of up to 120Hz. While it might not be the top-tier handheld display available, it delivers satisfactory color and contrast levels, and provides crisp detail.

By connecting your device to a ROG Ally docking station (similar to the one I reviewed in my JSAUX 6-in-1 Multifunctional Docking Station article), you’ll be able to display your games on a monitor or TV, much like how the Switch 2 does.

On the Switch 2, you’ll find a significantly bigger 7.9-inch screen, boasting 1080p resolution and a swift 120Hz refresh rate. This screen size is bound to seem expansive in comparison to the display on the Ally device.

Due to the fact that I haven’t had a chance to personally examine the Switch 2 display, I can’t provide a firsthand account of its color, contrast, and sharpness, but based on expectations, they should be satisfactory.

Furthermore, when connected to a compatible TV or monitor within its dock, the Switch 2 can display resolutions up to 4K, enhancing your visual experience beyond what the ROG Ally offers.

Currently, neither the ROG Ally nor the Switch 2 offers an OLED display. But given the potential for future updates, we might see this feature added at some point.

WIN: Compared to the ROG Ally and Ally X, the Nintendo Switch 2 boasts a larger screen, and it’s capable of displaying 4K resolution when connected to a TV, which is a feature not found in them.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Buttons and joysticks

Similar to many portable gaming devices, the Switch 2 and ROG Ally share a common control design, with key components such as ABXY buttons, menu controls, a home button, directional pads (D-Pads), bumpers, and triggers included on both.

But that’s where the similarities stop.

It’s clear that the ROG Ally and Ally X models do not feature Hall Effect joysticks, but it remains undecided if the same applies to the Switch 2. I’m optimistic that Nintendo has upgraded the joystick design in light of the fact that the initial Switch encountered numerous drift problems, which we hope will be addressed in the new model.

Instead of ROG Ally, the Switch 2 offers a more adaptable design, featuring detachable JoyCon controllers that magnetically link. Unlike the ROG Ally, it also boasts an integrated kickstand for tabletop mode, providing additional versatility.

As a gaming enthusiast, I love how Nintendo designed the JoyCon controllers to be versatile. Not only can you use them together in their standard orientation, but you can also flip them sideways to utilize each half independently for swift and hassle-free multiplayer gaming on-the-go!

Additionally, the Switch 2 includes a gadget that allows you to join the two parts into a conventional controller when the device is connected to a docking station.

Unlike the Switch 2, the ROG Ally features customizable back buttons. You can assign various functions to these buttons using its Armoury Crate software, making it effortless to adjust all the button settings.

Neither of the devices lack touchpads, however, the new Switch 2 boasts a feature capable of delivering comparable precision in games.

As a game analyst, I’ve observed that since the DS and Wii era, Nintendo consistently incorporates unique control mechanisms into their gaming systems (ranging from motion controls to stylus and dual screens). In line with this trend, I anticipate that the control gimmick for Switch 2 could potentially involve “mouse controls.

Users have the option to position these controller halves horizontally on a flat surface and then glide them for navigating the on-screen camera or cursor. A press down on the bumper serves the same function as a left mouse click.

Before I personally test this feature, I’m unsure about its effectiveness and ease of use.

Given these circumstances, it might be more advantageous for games requiring extensive mouse usage that the Nintendo Switch could offer a superior gaming experience.

As a devoted enthusiast, I’m excited to share that both the ROG Ally and Ally X offer the flexibility to hook up a mouse and keyboard for an enhanced gaming experience. If you’re playing games that don’t natively support controllers, this setup can be incredibly useful!

It’s quite probable that individuals desiring to employ Switch 2 mouse controls while relaxing on a couch would find it beneficial to acquire a lapboard similar to the one reviewed in my NerdyTec Couchmaster CYCON², as an alternative setup might not offer the most comfortable experience.

In the end, what we have here are tradeoffs.

The ROG Ally sports a conventional design, featuring attached control pads and buttons that can be effortlessly reprogrammed. Additionally, it’s straightforward to link a mouse and keyboard to this device.

Instead, you might find it convenient to know that the Switch 2 comes equipped with detachable JoyCon controllers that magnetically attach, allowing for easy sharing among multiple players. Additionally, it supports mouse control, enhancing gameplay for titles that were originally designed without controller functionality in mind.

As a researcher, I can’t definitively say which one is superior until I’ve had the chance to test the controls of the Switch 2. However, it seems that the ROG Ally could be a better choice for those seeking extensive customization options. On the other hand, the versatility offered by the Switch 2 might make it more appealing for multiplayer experiences and games heavily reliant on a mouse.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Compatible games & Operating system

The choice between an ROG Ally or a Switch 2 largely depends on your preferred operating system. To begin, let’s delve into the operating system aspect.

Although Nintendo hasn’t shown much about the software and interface for the Switch 2, it’s reasonable to assume that they will resemble the ones found on the initial Nintendo Switch.

If you’re unsure or have forgotten, the original Nintendo Switch isn’t particularly versatile when it comes to customization. However, with hacking, it opens up more customization possibilities.

But Nintendo is very against that, and hacking can void any active warranties.

For example, you might be able to use an unofficial method to open a hidden web browser on a Switch and potentially stream Netflix, but keep in mind that these approaches are not endorsed by Nintendo and may carry risks. Given Nintendo’s strict control over its devices, the interface and restrictions could possibly resemble those on a Switch 2 as well.

As an analyst, I’m excited to share that Nintendo has made significant strides in facilitating friend interaction, particularly compared to the initial Switch model. They’ve introduced a novel feature called GameChat, which is designed to enhance our communication experiences while gaming together.

By plugging a webcam into either of the handheld device’s USB-C ports, you can engage in conversations with friends while simultaneously screen sharing with them.

From another perspective, the ROG Ally and Ally X are both Windows 11 devices, functioning similarly to compact gaming laptops.

You can personalize the ROG Ally in numerous ways to boost its capabilities, should that be something you’re interested in.

Additionally, I appreciate the convenience of the speedy sidebar feature, which allows me to modify settings like refresh rate, resolution, power consumption, and other options seamlessly during gameplay.

Rather than relying on the communication tool that comes with a ROG Ally, it’s simple for me to chat with my friends using Discord as we explore Baldur’s Gate 3 simultaneously.

On ASUS devices, Ally users enjoy greater flexibility compared to Switch 2 users, as they can seamlessly browse the web, personalize settings, operate multiple applications, and utilize diverse gaming platforms like Battle.net, Epic Games, Xbox Game Pass, and so forth.

One potential drawback is that Windows 11 may include excess features, which could lead to more problem-solving being necessary.

Moreover, Microsoft’s operating system lacks the user-friendly simplicity that the Switch 2 evidently boasts. However, it appears that Microsoft is making efforts to address this issue.

A wide range of games on handheld

In essence, if a game works on a gaming laptop, it’s probably compatible with the ROG Ally. This implies that you can play an array of games, ranging from small indie games such as Balatro to large-scale titles from renowned studios like Assassin’s Creed Shadows.

Keep in mind that visually intensive PC games may not perform optimally on Ally compared to a dedicated gaming computer.

In simpler terms, the Switch 2 isn’t designed to directly run computer games. Instead, it requires specific Switch adaptations for those games to be played on it.

Absolutely, Nintendo boasts many well-known characters and unique game series that are exclusive to the Nintendo Switch, such as Super Mario, Pokemon, The Legend of Zelda, Metroid, Donkey Kong, Pikmin, and numerous others.

As a researcher delving into the realm of portable gaming, my personal findings suggest that if your preferences lean towards Nintendo’s intellectual properties, then opting for their handheld device might be the wiser choice. However, if you value the flexibility and expansive possibilities offered by PC gaming, then the ROG Ally could be more appealing to you.

Currently, you can enjoy Nintendo games on portable PC devices; however, running these games on the ROG Ally is considered a legal gray area due to copyright laws.

It’s important to mention that many original Switch games can be played on the upcoming Switch 2. Furthermore, there are multiple anticipated Switch 2 releases slated for this year, making the library of games for Switch 2 quite extensive.

The Switch 2 offers an exceptional experience for family gatherings and game nights, boasting numerous multiplayer and local cooperative games, some of which can accommodate as many as eight players using a single device.

Many people label the Switch 2 as a kiddie handheld, but this is a mistake.

Besides numerous options for family-oriented games, you can find many mature titles as well, such as the upcoming Switch 2 exclusive, The DuskBloods – an intense, multiplayer vampire game by FromSoftware.

As a gaming enthusiast, I’m thrilled to have unexpectedly seen some big PC games grace the screen of my first-generation Nintendo Switch – something I wouldn’t have anticipated with this handheld device!

Given the high demand for the Switch 2, it’s likely that we’ll witness an increase in compatible games and potential new editions of the Switch 2, such as the forthcoming Cyberpunk 2077: Ultimate Edition.

One drawback of the Nintendo Switch 2 is that it requires a Nintendo Switch Online subscription for most online multiplayer games, which isn’t necessary when using ROG Ally or other PC handheld devices.

It’s worth noting that with this subscription, you can enjoy playing both the original NES and SNES games using their official emulators. This can be a great experience if you’re reminiscing about the past or discovering these classic games for the first time.

As a tech enthusiast, I’m excited to share that if you’re intrigued, you can level up your gaming experience by upgrading your Nintendo Switch Online membership to the Nintendo Switch Online + Expansion Pack. This premium upgrade grants you access to classic games from consoles like the N64, Sega Genesis, and GameBoy Advance, and there’s even more to explore! In the near future, GameCube games will join the lineup as well.

In summary, both devices offer a variety of gaming experiences, but each has its unique strengths. The Switch 2 is exceptional for local multiplayer sessions and game nights with its more user-friendly couch co-op options. On the other hand, the ROG Ally shines in providing seamless access to online multiplayer games and the latest AAA titles, while also offering typical PC features.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Battery life

Just like any other gaming gadget, the length of time a handheld device can operate is influenced by its system settings and the kind of game being played. Games with heavy graphics tend to drain batteries quicker.

According to an official Nintendo Switch 2 specifications sheet, the upcoming handheld device is estimated to run for anywhere between two to approximately six and a half hours, though it does not disclose the exact battery capacity.

I’ll have to verify Switch 2 battery life when I get my hands on one.

In my experience, the ROG Ally’s battery life ranges from about 45 minutes to four hours, while the ROG Ally X’s battery can last anywhere from two to approximately 8.5 hours.

If Nintendo’s statements are correct, it appears that the ROG Ally X boasts the finest battery life. Nevertheless, the Switch 2 manages to run for a longer duration compared to the initial ROG Ally model.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Hand comfort

Without a doubt, when it comes to ergonomics and comfort for your hands, the ROG Ally X stands out as the undisputed champion.

Despite being the lightest gadget (weighing 1.18 pounds when the JoyCon controllers are attached), the JoyCons lack any sort of grip or curvature to them, making them rather flat.

Similar to the initial JoyCons for the Nintendo Switch, it’s likely that the controllers for Switch 2 may not be ergonomically designed for extended gaming periods due to their structure.

That’s why I’ve already ordered a Satisfye ZenGrip 2 for my Switch 2.

Absolutely, you can absolutely make use of the provided Switch 2 grip accessory to combine the JoyCons into a more conventional-style controller. This accessory is designed to provide superior handholds for comfortable gameplay in both tabletop and docked modes.

If you prefer a controller design more akin to the Xbox one, you may opt for the separate purchase of the Switch 2 Pro Controller, boasting a user-friendly layout.

In contrast, while the original white ROG Ally offers a reasonable grip, its larger rear buttons tend to disrupt my finger positioning.

The new design for the ROG Ally X features reduced-size back buttons that offer more comfortable use by minimizing interference with your fingers. Additionally, it has a slightly thicker build compared to its predecessor, making it feel more ergonomic in hand, despite weighing slightly more (approximately 1.49 pounds, compared to the original ROG Ally’s 1.34 pounds).

In terms of comfort, the ROG Ally X boasts the most comfortable grips among Switch 2, ROG Ally, and ROG Ally X. However, the additional Switch 2 controller accessory can significantly enhance the comfort of the detached JoyCon controllers.

Switch 2 vs ROG Ally: Which should I buy?

If you prefer PC gaming with greater control over your system, you might be interested in the Z1 Extreme ROG Ally.

For those seeking an exceptional high-end portable gaming experience, the recently released ROG Ally X could be an excellent choice due to its enhanced control features, increased memory, expanded storage, and double battery capacity compared to the initial model.

While The Ally’s interface may not be as straightforward as that of SteamOS or Nintendo’s, it offers a more versatile experience, allowing you to utilize the device for various tasks beyond just gaming.

You also have the option to buy a docking station and enjoy playing your ROG Ally or Ally X on a larger screen, like a TV or monitor.

If your preference leans towards Nintendo games or if you’re looking for a system primarily for social gaming experiences on the couch, then the Switch 2 would be an ideal choice for you.

Various single-player and multiplayer titles will be available on the Switch 2, spanning from lighthearted platformers to mature gaming experiences.

It’s possible that you may need to be patient as the most recent computer games might not be immediately available on Switch 2, if they are adapted at all. However, there will be a plentiful selection of exclusive games to enjoy in the meantime.

2025-04-04 14:44