Phase 5 Broke an Unfortunate MCU Record (But Marvel Studios Can Learn From It)

by

The final episodes of “Ironheart” have been released, marking the end of Phase 5 in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. However, the total earnings of this phase, about $3.66 billion, represent a concerning pattern – it’s the lowest-grossing phase in the MCU’s 17-year span. To put things into perspective, this amount is less than what the original six films of Phase 1 made over a decade ago, which was approximately $3.81 billion. Essentially, the phenomenal success of “Deadpool & Wolverine” couldn’t fully conceal the underlying issue.

It’s evident that Phase 5 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe had some notable disparities if we delve beyond the overall earnings and focus on individual performances. While two films, notably Deadpool and Wolverine, amassed a colossal $1.34 billion collectively, and Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 brought in an impressive $845.6 million, other titles underperformed significantly compared to expectations. Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania managed $476.1 million, Captain America: Brave New World earned $415.1 million, Thunderbolts made $381.9 million despite positive critical and fan reception, all falling short of profitability. The most striking disappointment was The Marvels, which ended its run with a disappointing $206.1 million worldwide, setting a new record as the biggest box office flop in the MCU.

This trend shows a substantial drop, even compared to the turbulent Phase 4. Despite criticism for its lack of unity, Phase 4 still managed to generate over $5.8 billion, largely due to the success of true event-level films. For instance, Spider-Man: No Way Home gained cultural significance by bringing together three generations of Spider-Men, earning $1.9 billion. Similarly, Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness cashed in on the buzz following WandaVision and its multiverse ties to reach $955 million. Even Thor: Love and Thunder ($760M) and Black Panther: Wakanda Forever ($859M) leveraged the strong brand recognition of their successful predecessors.

Marvel Studios fell short of the staggering $11 billion achieved during Phase 3, but the accomplishments of Phase 4 were still worthy of praise. Now, it appears that the declining profits of the MCU in Phase 5 are not just a temporary setback, but rather a sign of a flawed financial model. This model combines nine-figure budgets with unattainable expectations in an ever-evolving movie theater environment.

The Unsustainable Math of a Modern Blockbuster

The decline in box office revenue for the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) doesn’t happen without reasons. Since 2019, when multiple films crossed the billion-dollar mark, only a handful of movies have managed to do so. This change is due to several factors: audiences are now more selective about what they watch, streaming services have shortened the time between theater release and online availability, and movie ticket prices have risen significantly. As a consequence, a billion-dollar hit is no longer common but an exceptional event.

The fundamental problem lies in Marvel Studios’ inability to adjust their financial approach to the current situation. They persist in maintaining budget expectations from before the pandemic, viewing almost every project as a potential blockbuster requiring a billion-dollar profit. With films such as The Marvels reportedly costing $270 million and team-ups like Thunderbolts at $180 million, the threshold for success is unrealistically high. In today’s context, a film like Brave New World earning $400 million might be seen as a disappointment, when in reality it could be considered a decent return. This strategy, which insists every film must be a home run, is no longer sustainable.

The MCU Must Diversify Its Budget to Survive

To ensure Marvel stays on track, it’s not just about producing better films, but rather creating them with greater intellectual thought. The standard $200 million budget should be reconsidered and replaced with a more adaptable financial plan that caters to the unique creative scope and audience appeal of each project. It’s important to remember that not every character requires a movie with a world-ending plot, and not every film needs such a grand budget to match that ambition.

In this new era, Marvel’s main rival is crafting what appears to be the most promising model for them – the new DC Universe, under the leadership of James Gunn and Peter Safran, is working on a smaller-scale horror movie titled Clayface. This film, with an estimated budget of $40 million, doesn’t require blockbuster status to become financially successful. By focusing on delivering a high-quality genre-specific flick that appeals to a dedicated audience, it can still achieve massive financial success even if it earns around $150-$200 million at the box office. This profitable outcome would undoubtedly make executives pleased and contribute to the growth of the DCU.

It’s crucial that Marvel Studios grasp this particular lesson. By implementing a tiered financial structure, they can ease the immense burden on each release while simultaneously expanding their creative horizons. This strategic adjustment is essential for maintaining both the financial sustainability and artistic richness of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) over the next decade.

As a cinephile and Marvel enthusiast, I’d love to share my thoughts on what an intriguing smaller-budget Marvel production might look like.

From my perspective, Marvel could delve into the untold tales of lesser-known characters, perhaps focusing on the rich history of S.H.I.E.L.D., or even a gritty, character-driven narrative centered around a single hero who hasn’t yet hit the mainstream.

Imagine a film that takes us back to the roots of the Marvel Universe, exploring the origins and struggles of these heroes before they donned their iconic suits and saved the world. It could provide a fresh perspective, offering a more grounded, human take on the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU).

Or maybe we could see a standalone movie that delves deep into the darker aspects of the MCU, focusing on the moral complexities that come with having superpowers. This could provide an opportunity to explore themes not typically found in larger-scale Marvel productions.

Whatever direction they choose, I’m confident that a smaller-budget Marvel film could offer a unique and captivating addition to the MCU, while still maintaining the high-quality storytelling we’ve come to expect from this iconic franchise. So, fellow Marvel fans, what are your ideas for a smaller-budget Marvel production? Share them in the comments!

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/marvel-phase-5-movies-post-credits-scenes-ranked/embed/#

Read More

2025-07-06 20:11