Psycho’s Hidden Influence on One of The X-Files’ Most Heartbreaking Episodes

by

Initially known for Mulder and Scully, the main characters in the show evolved during its later seasons, with Monica Reyes and John Doggett stepping into their roles. Unlike the dynamic between their predecessors, the relationship between these new agents wasn’t as captivating, but they still shared an intriguing bond. In many instances, they could understand each other through unspoken words.

In the realm of cinematic critiquing, I must express that the episode titled “4-D” truly stands out, even if it appears Doggett’s dialogue is scant. This installment masterfully explores the intricacies of parallel realities, a theme that resonates deeply. Yet, what many viewers may not realize is that this episode draws its inspiration from a heartrending, real-life tragedy – a fact that adds an unexpected layer of poignancy.

Moreover, the main adversary in “4-D” harks back to one of the most formidable villains ever conceived, making it a must-watch for aficionados. However, it seems that these thoughtful tributes often go unnoticed by fans.

“4-D” Took Inspiration From a Range of Fascinating Stories

In Season 9, Episode 4 titled “4-D,” the story opens with detectives Monica Reyes and John Doggett embarking on an undercover mission to capture a dangerous fugitive named Erwin Lukesh. As Reyes tries to trail him into a stairwell, Lukesh seems to anticipate her move and attacks from behind, slashing her throat. Doggett persists in chasing him through a narrow alleyway, only to be ambushed as well. The narrative then shifts unexpectedly to Monica’s new apartment, where a contented Doggett is seen presenting her the finest Polish sausage the city has to offer. All of a sudden, Reyes receives an unforeseen phone call reporting that Doggett has been wounded, despite him being in perfect health just moments ago, standing right beside her.

The situation grows increasingly strange, with the FBI firmly believing that Reyes killed her partner. However, when they connect Doggett to a specialized computer system, they find evidence that Lukesh assaulted both agents simultaneously. Monica manages to piece it all together and proposes that Lukesh can traverse parallel realities. To retrieve the genuine Doggett from his universe, she must shut down the lifeless one in her presence. Fortunately, this plan works, and the scene restarts peacefully within Reyes’ fresh home environment.

At first glance, “4-D” might appear as just another common sci-fi tale about alternate universes, a theme frequently employed in the genre. However, this particular episode carries some significant real-world relevance, particularly with regard to Doggett’s innovative communication system. Throughout the episode, Doggett communicates using Morse code by tapping his finger. This code is then translated and shown on a screen next to him. Interestingly, this concept was inspired by a real-life figure, Jean-Dominique Bauby, a journalist who became paralyzed following a stroke in 1995.

Despite being confined to only blinking his left eyelid, the journalist was nevertheless commissioned to write a book. With the assistance of a speech therapist, he devised an innovative alphabet system based on his eye blinks. Over a span of two months, they managed to produce a 130-page manuscript without uttering a single word. This method bears striking resemblance to the life depicted in Bauby’s book, “The Diving Bell and the Butterfly.” The scene in which Monica shaves Doggett’s face was inspired by this very book, as actor Robert Patrick shared it would lend an intimate touch to the episode.

Erwin Lukesh might not be as unsettling as Fluekman or Eugene Toombs, yet there’s no disputing that he’s downright chilling. This enigmatic character has a troubled past, with his father’s demise marking a significant turning point in his life. As an adult, Lukesh devotes much of his time to caring for his infirm mother, but he views her more as a burden than a loved one, mainly because she rigidly adheres to her daily routine. It’s not hard to surmise that Steve Maeda drew inspiration for Lukesh from… The screenwriter appears to have a penchant for literary allusions, naming his main character from “Redrum,” Martin Wells, in homage to the celebrated science fiction author H.G. Wells.

This Episode Also Pushed Its Special Effects Team to the Limit

The television series “The X-Files” has consistently received acclaim for its exceptional special effects, particularly in crafting its terrifying antagonists. Yet, in “4-D,” a significant amount of computer-generated effects were used, which viewers might not have noticed during their initial viewing. To traverse into an alternate universe, characters Lukesh and Doggett pass through a portal that appears as a gentle ripple on a pond’s surface – a seemingly uncomplicated effect, but one that required the special effects team to invest considerable time in perfecting.

Initially, expert Mat Beck envisioned characters either entering black holes or simply vanishing from sight to emphasize the transition’s clarity. Later on, he opted for a combination, capturing distinct shots of both actors and their surroundings. Subsequently, Beck employed specialized software to blend these layers seamlessly, creating an illusion that the men had essentially disappeared before viewers’ eyes.

For the promotional content of this episode, distinct visual effects were incorporated as well. In the “4-D” trailer, each scene was flipped symmetrically to hint at the emergence of a counterpart reality. Consequently, the script had to be written in reverse so that the spelling remained correct when flipped, similar to how ambulances display messages on their rearview mirrors. Granted, all this appears labor-intensive, but it was undoubtedly worth it. Mirror universals are quite prevalent, particularly in science fiction productions, as they provide writers with a platform to explore diverse scenarios without compromising the overall storyline.

The X-Files elevated this theme, subtly hinting at familiar tropes without fully committing to them. This left viewers with a sense of the show’s direction but kept them guessing about whether it would stick to the formula or surprise us with something entirely new. In summary, though The X-Files purposefully employed these methods, their thoughtful use only added to their charm.

Even Without Mulder and Scully, This Episode Still Shines

Although Season 9 of The X-Files boasts captivating plotlines and stunning visual effects, it’s frequently criticized by fans due to the reduced screen time for Mulder and Scully. While Scully does make appearances in “4-D,” her role seems more supporting than central. However, some viewers might contend that Doggett and Reyes provide an equal amount of tension and intrigue to the series, with “4-D” serving as a testament to this claim. Despite spending most of the episode confined to a hospital bed and barely moving his index finger, Doggett still manages to keep audiences on the edge of their seats in this episode.

Robert Patrick skillfully expresses a wealth of emotion through his eyes alone, making it seem as if his character is joking with his partner despite the fear and sadness visible in his gaze. This doesn’t diminish David Duchovny’s emotional performances, but “4-D” demonstrates that The X-Files can effectively deliver a profound impact on viewers without relying excessively on dramatic scenes.

In the initial seasons, Mulder and Scully adhered to their specific roles. Mulder, filled with conviction, yearned to prove to the world that life extends far beyond our own planet. Conversely, Scully was a hardened skeptic, finding solace in science and reason when faced with the unexplained. However, in contrast, Doggett and Reyes swap these roles: Reyes exhibits an intrigue for parallel universes and challenges her understanding of reality. When things get too extraordinary, Doggett serves as a grounding force, reminding her that they are FBI agents, not X-Files investigators by default.

Essentially, “4-D” is a tale about evading one’s reality. The narrative cleverly employs multiple dimensions to enable its villain, Lukesh, to flee the monotony and tension of his everyday life, despite his actions resulting in the taking of lives. Though it may be difficult for viewers to empathize with Lukesh, they can grasp his motivation for jumping between realities. The episode, however, doesn’t delve deep into the technical aspects of these alternate dimensions, but rather excels in illustrating why someone might crave a temporary escape from their existence.

Read More

2025-06-01 06:52