Seize These Dead Poets Society Secrets With No Regrets

by

It’s not quite midsummer yet, but a Dead Poets Society rewatch is still a dreamy option for spring.

1959 brought a heartrending film to theaters that featured an ensemble of promising young actors portraying students at the prestigious, male-only Welton Academy. Robin Williams starred as their inspiring English teacher in this movie, which quickly became a sensation, winning over both critics and audiences.

Tom Schulman was awarded an Oscar for his original screenplay, one of the five nominations that encompassed categories like Best Picture, Best Director (Peter Weir), and Best Actor (Williams). Prior to this recognition, Williams was primarily recognized for his electrifying comedic roles. However, it turns out he was equally skilled at delivering quiet, introspective performances as well.

For those who may not have recognized the lasting impact of Mr. Keating’s group of budding Tennyson enthusiasts, Taylor Swift was fully aware of the strength of nostalgia. She brought together Dead Poets Society stars Ethan Hawke and Josh Charles, who played Todd and Knox respectively, for her “Fortnight” video, casting them as mad scientists.

Last year on The Jess Cagle Show on SiriusXM, Hawke speculated that there might have been a psychic link she aimed to establish for the audience regarding The Tortured Poets Department and Dead Poets Society. Essentially, she was paying tribute in a subtle way, so she invited a few of us veteran actors to appear, making our presence felt.

Just call her captain.

I’m absolutely hooked, just like a dedicated member of a particular cave exploration group, you can’t help but be curious about “then”. Seize this very moment and delve deeper into the enigmas surrounding “Dead Poets Society” by continuing to read, uncovering hidden truths along the way.

Disney found the title “Sultans of Strut” appealing and imagined it as a musical centered around growing up, similar to “Fame“. In 2016, an off-Broadway stage adaptation was announced, with Jason Sudeikis set to play the role analogous to Keating.

2. John Keating, the character from the movie, was inspired by a real-life professor: Samuel F. Pickering Jr., who was an English professor at the University of Connecticut. Screenwriter Tom Schulman, when he was 15, had taken a course taught by Pickering at Montgomery Bell Academy in Nashville. The teacher made a significant impact on him and solidified his passion for literature.

However, Pickering humbly downplayed his impact on the character’s development, stating to the Times Daily, “Any part of me that might be found within that character must be minimal. I was merely a youngster at the time, and the character was just a child. A gap of 23 years between us. So, it’s unlikely there would be much of me in the film.

As a die-hard admirer looking back at the golden days of cinema, I can’t help but reminisce about the groundbreaking moment when Tom Schulman’s debut screenplay, “Dead Poets Society,” graced the silver screen in 1989. This masterpiece earned him an Oscar for Best Original Screenplay the following year. Incidentally, in the same historic year, Schulman also struck gold with another box office hit: “Honey, I Shrunk the Kids.

4. Initially, when I learned that Robin Williams was set to play Keating, earning his second Oscar nomination, it wasn’t always a given. In fact, big names like Mel Gibson had previously declined the role. Liam Neeson was even favored by an early director, Jeff Kanew, of “Revenge of the Nerds” fame. However, Disney had their heart set on Williams, but he wasn’t keen on working with that initial director. With both parties at a standstill, the project seemed to be doomed. The sets were even dismantled and burned down! But luckily, over a year later, Peter Weir stepped in as director and Robin Williams joined the team, ultimately giving us the magical film we all know and love today.

5. Dustin Hoffman had initially been set to act and direct in the project, but scheduling issues arose that stopped him from doing so, making way for Weir’s involvement later on.

6. Two years before it, he got nominated for his performance in “Good Morning, Vietnam”. However, “Dead Poets Society” marked Robin Williams’ debut in a dramatic role. Known for his knack for improvisation, approximately 15% of his lines in the movie were improvised by him.

7. In an unprecedented move, the entirety of Dead Poets Society was filmed in Delaware, although it’s worth noting that the famous cave where the Poets Society gathered wasn’t a genuine cavern, I’m afraid to disillusion you. The townsfolk of Middletown, Delaware, recall Williams as amiable, often strolling around town and conversing with the locals. “That’s why everyone now feels a bond with him,” mayor Ken Branner shared with Delaware Online following the actor’s demise. “We have a lasting connection to him through Dead Poets. That connection will never fade.

 

8. Ethan Hawke and Josh Charles, who later became famous for their roles in CBS’ hit series The Good Wife, initially met during auditions for the same director. They both secured roles after trying out together with other actors. However, the movie didn’t materialize, leaving them in limbo for an entire year, unsure if it would be produced again or if they would be re-casted. “We screen-tested together with other actors,” Charles explained to Entertainment Weekly, “[and] then the film collapsed, and we were left waiting another year, uncertain if it was going to happen again.

Absolutely, they each maintained their positions, as Weir shared with the crowd, “Josh stood out in auditions like no other. His charisma and acting skills were unmatched compared to everyone else.

9. In the early stages of his career, Ethan Hawke’s role in “Dead Poets Society” was particularly significant as it was just his second film. At that moment, securing the part of the timid Todd held immense importance for him.

He was 18 years old, believing that landing this role would significantly alter his life, he imbued it with such significance, as he explained in a DVD extra. Later, Hawke would become an acclaimed actor of his generation, starring in films like “Reality Bites”, the “Sunrise” trilogy, “Training Day”, “Boyhood”, and many others, ultimately earning four Oscar nominations.

10. To truly capture the authentic camaraderie that could only blossom in a boarding school setting, Weir had us, the young cast members, reside together for two weeks leading up to and during filming. We delved deep into the ’50s era, getting our hair styled appropriately (which, let me tell you, was not Hawke’s favorite), studying the pop culture of the time, and even writing poetry and playing theater games together. By the time the cameras started rolling, it felt like we had spent years at school together, as Kussman put it.

11. They grew extremely close, leading them all to spend a weekend in New York City together, supporting Hawke and Leonard during their joint auditions for the part of ‘Dad’. (Ultimately, Hawke was cast for the role.)

12. To ensure the evolving relationship between Mr. Keating and the poets appeared authentic, Weir opted for an uncommon approach by shooting the film sequentially, following the timeline of events.

13. One of the movie’s most impactful scenes, where Todd and Neil discard the desk that Todd received as a birthday gift from his parents, was not originally written in the script. At first, Hawke was meant to give a monologue expressing self-pity, but during filming, they and Weir found it didn’t fit quite right. So Weir allowed them to improvise, leading to the idea that they would toss the desk off the roof. This idea was met with approval from Weir, much to their delight.

Hawke reminisced about him and Bob in the car ride home, saying something like, “We couldn’t believe he would actually include that scene in the movie!” The experience was a blast, as we were improvising our lines and he was jotting them down. It was pure fun.

14. At 17 years old when the film was produced, Charles found Williams to be the most significant celebrity he had encountered yet. He shared with The Hollywood Reporter that he was amazed by how ordinary the actor, then highly acclaimed for Mork & Mindy and Good Morning, Vietnam, appeared. “What truly stood out to me,” Charles said, “was his kindness and his genuine consideration towards us 17-year-old, 18-year-old youngsters. Although he was undeniably the star of the movie, he made a great effort to blend in with the rest of the cast.

15. (As a Lifestyle Expert) Over the years, I’ve forged a deep bond with a remarkable individual named Leonard, which eventually led us to embark on an exciting venture together. We established our own theatre company right here in the bustling heart of New York City, joining forces with other talented actors we’ve come to know and respect along the way.

In Leonard’s words, the group frequently found themselves in New York and spent a considerable amount of time bowling. One day, they pondered, ‘Why not try coming up with some fresh ideas when we’re idle?’ This is how the group originated, and Leonard expressed great pride in many of their accomplishments.

2004 saw Leonard sharing screen time with Hugh Laurie on the popular Fox medical series “House,” a show that spanned eight seasons. As a theater actor at heart, Leonard publicly grappled with the challenges posed by the television industry.

He expressed his satisfaction with the show, stating that he found it commendable. Speaking to The Standard in the UK, he admitted that he wasn’t ashamed of it and had peers in TV series who were, so he understood the distinction. The income was appealing since it provided financial stability for him and his family, something he lacked during his theatre days. He felt a sense of responsibility as a father, contributing to his family’s finances through House.

17. Amidst the grandeur of Williams’ personality, those on the set of Dead Poets Society picked up on the melancholy within the actor.

At the age of 18, it was clear as day to me that he was suffering intensely, as Hawke explained to CBC Radio. Anyone paying attention could tell.

Norman Lloyd, the actor who portrayed Keating’s adversary, disclosed the private struggles Victor Willaims was experiencing during that period in an interview given to The Hollywood Reporter.

During the filming of “Dead Poets Society“, it was a time when his first marriage to Valerie Velardi was falling apart. That’s when he started dating and eventually married Marsha Garces, who was taking care of his children at the time, as he later remembered. He managed to conceal the entire situation quite skillfully. There were no signs of it in his work, everything remained hidden and under control.

18. While the movie didn’t reach the top spot at the U.S. box office, it still managed to earn nearly $100 million domestically and over $235 million overseas, placing it among the top five highest-grossing films globally that year.

19. Despite being both critically acclaimed and commercially successful, there was one well-known critic who didn’t appreciate the movie: Roger Ebert, who only awarded it two stars and expressed his feelings about the climactic scene by stating, “I felt so emotionally stirred that I felt like vomiting.

20. Although the majority of the actors were around 18 to 20 years old, matching their character’s ages closely, Gale Hansen (Charlie Dalton) stood out as the eldest among them at the age of 29.

21. The Academy Award-winning actor Sam Rockwell tried out for the character Charlie, however, he failed to secure the role as he mentioned to The Guardian, “I appeared too youthful, yet I’m not always adept at portraying young characters.

Originally, Lara Flynn Boyle was cast for a minor part in the movie as Chet’s sister Ginny. However, her parts were eventually removed from the final edit of the film, leaving her to appear only as a silent background character in certain scenes.

2016 saw Saturday Night Live humorously imitating the 1999 film “Dead Poets” in a pre-recorded sketch titled “Farewell, Mr. Bunting.” In this rendition, Fred Armisen assumed the teacher’s role, while the inspiring finale took an unexpectedly grim twist thanks to ceiling fans.

24. In the initial sequence featuring Keating and the seven poets, Weir encouraged Williams to recite a snippet from Shakespeare and then let the actors improvise around it. “With two cameras rolling, I simply announced, ‘Gentlemen, this isn’t scripted,'” he shared with Premiere. “Regard Robin as your mentor and respond accordingly, and remember that it’s 1959.” (As an overly enthusiastic fan, this approach made me feel like I was right there on set, watching the magic unfold!)

24. In the initial draft by Schulman, a hospital death scene for Keating, diagnosed with Hodgkin’s disease, was included to explain his perspective on life in the movie. However, Weir persuaded him to remove it after three days of discussion, as the powerful ending with Todd standing up had a stronger impact without the illness serving as a motivator.

25. During his pre-casting meeting with Weir, Kussman boldly challenged a script detail that seemed inconsistent with Richard Cameron’s character. This decision significantly changed the ending scene, as originally all the poets were meant to stand on their desks.

Peter Weir agreed with my sentiment that it wouldn’t be true to the character for him to stand on the desk. Instead, he should either not be allowed or choose not to defy Mr. Nolan in this scenario.

26. In that crucial moment, Weir, known for setting a mood on set with his choice of music, often Irish-Celtic tunes during “Poets”, used a speaker lent from Charles’ father to play a song that the actor would always remember while filming.

He mentioned that when we filmed that particular scene, Ennio Morricone’s music from the movie “The Mission” was playing loudly. It was a stunning and poignant piece of music. The impact of music on our feelings is something I’ve carried with me ever since, recognizing how it can evoke emotions. This is an aspect I make use of frequently in my work.

27. In an interview on “The Graham Norton Show”, Hawke shared a humorous incident where his mother made his children watch “Dead Poets Society”. However, instead of enjoying the movie like he hoped, one of his sons asked, “When do you come on, dad?” partway through, which was unexpected and somewhat disheartening. He humorously added, “‘Oh, the crooked teeth, yeah!'” to express his feelings about it.

28. During an interview, Williams shared that “Dead Poets Society” was among the films he’d ever starred in, which held a special place for him.

He stated, “That film resonated with people in a way that transcended typical movie-watching experiences.” He shared a story about a man who told him, “Mr. Williams, after watching the movie Dead Poets Society, I used to work for a big corporation. I discarded my business attire, even burning it, and now I run an art gallery.” Upon hearing this, he exclaimed, “I must purchase art from you now!

In a Reddit AMA session, I shared that George Lucas is among my most cherished directors I’ve collaborated with throughout my career. Reflecting on our work together, in a 1990 interview, Lucas expressed his confidence in my ability to portray the nuanced character of Keating due to the fact that he had encountered that quieter, thoughtful, and humorous man during our initial encounter – which was none other than myself.

29. Following Williams’ sad demise in 19, the phrase “O Captain, my Captain” gained a profound fresh interpretation, as numerous tributes invoked the well-known quote from Dead Poets Society to honor the actor. However, it held a particularly poignant significance for Hawke, who found himself frequently reminded of this line by fans throughout the years, having spoken it himself.

In conversation with Vanity Fair, he shared that upon his death, he found himself engrossed in a Walt Whitman poem, which held a profoundly moving impact on him.

30. At the start of filming, Hawke initially assumed Williams disliked him due to his attempts to maintain character during improvisation scenes, which seemed to frustrate the actor. As Hawke didn’t laugh at Williams’ antics, the latter grew increasingly eccentric, leading Hawke to believe he was hated. However, it turned out that Williams wasn’t angry with him; in fact, a phone call from Williams’ agent following the movie would significantly impact Hawke’s career for the better.

[Williams] told me that you would become significant and suggested I represent you,” he reminisced. “He was the one who secured my first agent, and he remains my agent to this day.

Read More

2025-06-02 10:18