Stranger Things’ Biggest Plot Hole Finally Explained: How Did Will See Joyce’s Alphabet Wall?

by

Netflix’s hit series, “Stranger Things,” sparked fascination since its debut, combining ’80s nostalgia, supernatural terror, and gripping character narratives. As the final season nears, the intricate plot and time-bending storyline have sparked passionate conversations and debates among fans. Although later seasons enriched the “Stranger Things” universe, some viewers revisit Season 1, dissecting early events through the lens of fresh discoveries. A recurring topic of debate, recently reignited on Reddit, revolves around a possible plot inconsistency concerning the workings of the Upside Down and one of “Stranger Things'” memorable scenes: Joyce Byers (Winona Ryder) communicating with her missing son Will (Noah Schnapp) using Christmas lights and an alphabet wall made of hand-painted symbols.

In “Stranger Things” Season 4, one of the major plot points revolves around the explanation of the shadowy mirror dimension similar to Hawkins. In the episode titled “The Massacre at Hawkins Lab (Chapter Seven),” Nancy Wheeler (played by Natalia Dyer) uncovers a significant rule about the Upside Down. She found that this otherworldly realm is like a fixed image, frozen on the exact day Will Byers vanished: November 6, 1983. This revelation surfaced when Nancy, exploring her Upside Down bedroom for weapons she obtained later, instead encountered older possessions and a diary whose last entry was dated November 6th.

In my own words as a devoted fan, I’ve noticed an intriguing inconsistency regarding timelines in Stranger Things. While Nancy’s investigation confirmed that the Upside Down replica mirrors Hawkins exactly at the moment when Eleven (Millie Bobby Brown) interacted with the Demogorgon and initially opened the Mothergate, a timing discrepancy emerged with Season 1 events. Specifically, Will went missing on November 6th, but Joyce didn’t set up her iconic alphabet wall until November 9th, three days later. This inconsistency has sparked a significant question among fans: If the Upside Down is locked at November 6th, how could Will perceive and utilize the alphabet wall that Joyce painted after this date?

The Upside Down Snapshot Paradox: How Did Will See the Letters?

In a recent Reddit discussion started by user ContributionOwn6977, the question was posed: “Given that Joyce wrote the alphabet on the wall after the Upside Down had taken a snapshot, and since the dates aren’t aligned in the two worlds, how did the letters appear if everything in the Upside Down is frozen in time? How could Will see these letters?

In simple terms, it’s puzzling how Will appears to manipulate the letters added later, given the existing guidelines. This might seem confusing because, in Season 1, the visual storytelling suggests that Will directly controls the lights that represent the letters Joyce painted on the wall.

In response to this, other fans in the discussion thread swiftly provided explanations based on the concept of cross-dimensional interaction within the show ‘Stranger Things’. User lastseason highlighted a mechanism shown later using a Lite-Brite, stating, “Each letter on the wall had a light bulb above it. So, on Will’s side in the UD, similar to the older teens, each light bulb corresponded with a glimmer cluster.” This idea is consistent with visual hints that suggest lights in the main dimension create corresponding energy particles or ‘auras’ in the Upside Down.

Significantly, sound as well as energy signatures can traverse dimensions, especially near gateways or contact points. As Sanjay-The_Almighty pointed out, “Will utilized light particles to control the bulbs placed above each alphabet letter.” TelephoneCertain5344 also noted that Joyce gave a clear description of where she was painting each letter, which Will deduced. Although Will didn’t see the actual paint or physical bulbs, he could manipulate their energy signatures. Additionally, hearing his mother explain her setup and the letters she was using (like “R is… R-U-N,” guiding him), Will logically figured out the sequence to spell messages. Moreover, canatlas99 suggested that Will might have even drawn a guide in the Upside Down dirt to keep track of his progress.

Retcon or Rule? The Evolving Rules of Stranger Things

Some viewers, like Reddit user tolgren, propose that the inconsistencies might stem from the evolving storyline over time. This idea suggests that the writers didn’t establish the rules governing the Upside Down’s temporal mechanics until after Season 1, leading to interpretations of early season events that seem contradictory to later rules. The confirmation of the November 6th freeze wasn’t revealed until Season 4, eight years after the airing of the alphabet wall sequence. This delay could result in revisions (retcons) where later rules unintentionally create plot holes in earlier seasons. If the writers hadn’t planned the snapshot rule for Season 1, Will’s interactions with the wall would have seemed less problematic then.

Instead of varying its methods, the series consistently uses light patterns as a means of communication. In Season 4, this is demonstrated when the Hawkins group utilizes Holly Wheeler’s Lite-Brite to contact the teenagers trapped in the Upside Down. They manage to manipulate the energy patterns that correspond to the Lite-Brite pegs, despite the fact that the device doesn’t physically exist in the Upside Down. This underscores the notion that Will’s communication method from Season 1 was based on these energy transfers, not on seeing an impossible physical barrier.

In Season 4, we learn about Vecna’s past and his exile to Dimension X in 1979. This dimension later became a snapshot of Hawkins when Eleven opened the gate in 1983. While this new information adds depth, it doesn’t contradict the main storyline. The way Will communicates despite the frozen timeline makes sense due to the established rules about light and sound transfer. However, some viewers might find it confusing that the “snapshot” rule was not revealed earlier, leading them to question the original events sequence.

I’d love to hear your opinions about the reversed sequence of events in the Upside Down world and the mysterious alphabet wall. Feel free to share your thoughts and theories in the comments below!

Read More

2025-04-27 18:12