Superman Fans Are Divided Over James Gunn’s New Trailer Shot, Despite Henry Cavill Doing the Same Thing

by

Supporters are engaged in a passionate argument over a single scene from James Gunn’s latest trailer, where Superman shields himself from a fire blast, even though he’s supposed to be immune to it. Past DC Extended Universe films have depicted Henry Cavill’s Superman defending against bullets, sparking a lively debate about which version of Superman is more powerful.

Recenty, Gunn unveiled the upcoming movie, set to premiere on July 11 in cinemas, and DC Comics enthusiasts have been scrutinizing every scene for hints about the film’s plot. Gunn has hinted that David Corenswet’s Superman character is in his mid-twenties, which makes him younger than Henry Cavill’s portrayal in the DC Extended Universe. Some fans on social media platforms (previously known as Twitter) have criticized Corenswet for appearing weak after a shot of him in the trailer showed him shielding his face from a kaiju’s fire.

Fans of Superman defended the new portrayal of the character in “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice”, explaining that he protected himself from bullets, something Superman is immune to. However, another fan disagreed, arguing that Cavill’s actions were not shielding but rather him reacting angrily, similar to how Marvel’s Hulk reacts when bullets are fired at him.

In the heated discussion about whether Corenswet’s portrayal of Superman was less powerful than Cavill’s, a fan offered a more rational explanation for what seemed like a significant plot inconsistency. “I attribute both instances to Superman having been brought up by ordinary people,” the user explained. “He might not fully grasp the limits of his invincibility at this point, and his instinctive reaction to possible pain and reflexive flinching are aspects that make him more human.

Viewers might make snap decisions about the film based on brief trailer snippets, yet it may later become clear that the scenes offer more depth than first perceived. Regardless, accounts like @AllFatherMedia find it intriguing that Superman appears to behave more human-like in these instances rather than strictly Kryptonian. In their opinion, a live-action Superman resembling the 1930s character could be more engaging, as he’d possess immense strength and resilience but not absolute invincibility.

Corenswet & Cavill’s Superman Characters Are Likely to Be Very Different

This summer, James Gunn’s Superman film is set to kick off the inaugural feature from the revamped DC Universe. Fans might find that Gunn’s upcoming vision for DC movies departs significantly from the DCEU where Henry Cavill’s Superman resided. The latest trailer suggests several notable distinctions between the two, such as the fact that Cavill’s Superman, though powerful, was more restrained in employing his abilities, and he initially perceived Batman not as a fellow hero or planet protector, but rather as a vigilante figure.

Instead of Cavill’s Superman straddling authority, Corenswet’s interpretation appears to be more focused on safeguarding innocent lives instead of worrying about his image or legal standing. The latest trailer snippets hint at a deeper, modest side to Corenswet’s persona as a journalist. Fans might find themselves divided over the contrasting Superman depictions; however, when Gunn’s Superman film premieres, it could convince viewers that both versions can effectively embody a hero with extraordinary strength and compassion.

Superman will be released in theaters on July 11, 2025.

Read More

2025-05-20 19:28