The Bizarre Saga of a Melissa McCarthy Christmas Movie That Won’t Die

by

As a seasoned film enthusiast who has seen the rise and fall of countless projects over the years, I must say that the tale of Margie Claus is one for the history books. It’s like watching a phoenix rise from its own ashes, but with a whole lot more holiday cheer!

The recently renamed animation department of Warner Bros. Pictures, known now as Warner Bros. Animation, has an upcoming lineup of films that align with the studio’s reputation. Adaptations of Dr. Seuss stories, such as “The Cat in the Hat,” are on the horizon. A modern interpretation of The Flintstones is set for cinemas. Two Robins from DC Comics lore will star in “Dynamic Duo.” Generally, Warner Bros. Animation is concentrating on developing franchises that are synonymous with the Warner Bros. brand. However, a title slated for release on November 5, 2027, seems to buck this trend.

The date mentioned is associated with the animated Yuletide movie “Margie Claus,” featuring Melissa McCarthy as the lead character. At first glance, this project might not seem particularly unique for a family-oriented animation studio. However, the production of “Margie Claus” has an unusually long and convoluted background. When it eventually hits the screens, it will be nearly ten years since its initial announcement in a dramatically different concept.

The First Iteration of Margie Claus

Read moreHunt: Showdown Permanently Gets Cheaper, but With a Catch

Back in June 2017, it was announced that Warner Bros./New Line Cinema would release “Margie Claus” in theaters on November 8, 2019. This musical production, featuring McCarthy as Santa’s wife searching for her missing husband, was set to be an original story. McCarthy had gained significant popularity through Universal comedies such as “Bridesmaids” and “Identity Thief.” It appeared that Warner Bros./New Line Cinema were eager to establish a long-term collaboration with McCarthy, having already produced her first starring role for them in 2014’s “Tammy,” followed by “Life of the Party” in 2018 and “The Kitchen” in 2019.

In a similar vein to how Tammy and Party were directed by Ben Falcone, who is married to and longtime creative partner of Melissa McCarthy, Margie Claus would likely have been under his direction as well. A grand Yuletide musical would’ve represented a significant change in scale for Falcone, deviating from the down-to-earth comedies he had previously produced. Regrettably, due to the project never materializing, we didn’t get to witness whether or not Falcone could thrive within this new creative realm. Unfortunately, Margie Claus faded away without a formal announcement from Warner Bros., leaving its intended November 2019 release date behind.

Instead of staying relevant, the film faded from public attention almost silently. Following Melissa McCarthy’s post-2016 comedies that failed to perform well at the box office (including Warner Bros.’ films “Party” and “Kitchen”), it seems this underperformance may have cooled the studio’s enthusiasm for McCarthy as a leading lady. Initially slated for a grand release during Christmas 2019, Melissa McCarthy’s film “Superintelligence” was instead premiered on HBO Max over Thanksgiving 2020. This suggests that her relationship with the studio may have lost its initial spark. The movie “Margie Claus” found itself in the middle of this situation.

Why Did Margie Claus Come Back From the Dead?

Currently, there’s yet no clear answer as to how and why Margie Claus was resurrected, particularly since Warner Bros. Pictures Animation unveiled one of their major project announcements. What has been established is that McCarthy continues to portray the lead character, but Falcone is no longer at the helm. Instead, animation veteran Shane Prigmore is said to be directing the project. This change in creative leadership hints that the revamped Margie Claus will likely resemble Klaus and Arthur Christmas more in style, rather than The Boss.

Read moreDeadpool & Wolverine Director Reveals What Part of Making Sequel Was Most Fun

As a movie enthusiast, I’d rephrase it like this: “My theory is that Margie Claus’s return could be linked to the resurgence of Christmas movies in Hollywood. From 2020 to 2023, there were hardly any new films similar to classics like The Polar Express or Elf gracing our cinema screens. But then, November 2024 saw the release of both The Best Christmas Pageant Ever and Red One – a refreshing change! With this renewed interest in holiday movies, it’s no surprise that studio executives might have been keen to capitalize on this trend. In such a scenario, reviving a project already in development, especially one that would provide a new animation studio with a significant project, seems like a logical move.

One interesting wrinkle about Margie Claus: this project will mark McCarthy’s first time providing voice-over work for a theatrical animated feature. Since the 2015 DreamWorks Animation title B.O.O.: Bureau of Otherworldly Operations (which she was supposed to headline with Seth Rogen) was abruptly cancelled, Margie Claus will be McCarthy’s grand introduction to big screen animation. It’s not surprising this performer is anchoring a major American animated movie. What is surprising, though, is that it will be for a movie that basically died and then abruptly came back to life. Margie Claus has truly a bizarre saga that could ultimately prove more compelling than anything that ends up on the big screen.

Read More

2024-12-01 00:09