The Breakfast Club: Why It Can’t Be Made Today?

by

As a connoisseur of cinema, I can confidently say that “The Breakfast Club,” hailing from the golden age of the 1980s, remains one of the most revered comedy films, cherished by fans who yearn for the unique narrative flair of the late, great John Hughes. Even after four decades, the original five stars graced us with a reunion to reminisce about its enduring impact. They unanimously agreed that a movie like “The Breakfast Club” might be challenging to recreate in today’s cinematic landscape.

A tribute to The Breakfast Club was held at C2E2 convention in Chicago, marking the 40th anniversary of the movie. Attendees included Emilio Estevez, Judd Nelson, Ally Sheedy, and Anthony Michael Hall. This reunion was their first since the film debuted four decades ago. Estevez expressed his eagerness to finally participate with his fellow actors in this special occasion.

Estevez expressed a unique sentiment about the film, stating, ‘It’s in Chicago where we shot this movie,’ he said. ‘Given it’s our 40th anniversary, it seemed appropriate. When someone suggested that maybe Estevez doesn’t care for us, my heart ached. I replied, ‘No, of course I cherish all of them.’ This explanation resonated with me, so I’m here now.’

Could The Breakfast Club Be Made in 2025?

The actors discussed that “The Breakfast Club” was a reflection of its era and might not have the same impact if made today. Estevez thinks that the character-focused idea behind such a film as “The Breakfast Club” would likely be rejected by studio executives, since modern movies tend to prioritize visual grandeur over storytelling compared to the 1980s.

Modern films often prioritize ideas over character development, but John Hughes stood out by focusing on characters initially. If we were to pitch this movie today – it’s about five students stuck in a library for detention – studio executives might wonder where the action or spectacle is, asking questions like “Where are the monsters? Where are the special effects?

He went on to say, “It’s crucial to recall that we produced this film with a budget of $1 million, which was substantial at the time but relatively small compared to Universal’s current standards. This wasn’t considered a large-scale blockbuster as they are today. Given the risk involved, it’s safe to say that under present conditions, this movie likely wouldn’t be produced.

For Ringwald, times have shifted significantly, making her believe that a remake of The Breakfast Club might not resonate as strongly. Instead, she advocates for more films that draw on some aspects of The Breakfast Club, but with a focus on diversity in the cast to better reflect today’s society. As she elaborated, she feels it’s time for fresh stories that carry forward the essence of The Breakfast Club.

As a film enthusiast, I’m not on board with the idea of remaking that particular movie. Instead, I advocate for creating films that draw inspiration from classics while also reflecting the contemporary world. It’s clear to me that this movie, given its time and context, resonates deeply with people. However, it lacks diversity in terms of ethnicities and doesn’t address issues like gender. I believe our world today demands movies that mirror the rich tapestry of life, and a remake of this movie could do just that by exploring different perspectives, perhaps even building on the themes presented in “The Breakfast Club.

The Breakfast Club is currently streaming on Netflix.

Read More

2025-04-19 01:53