The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

As a curious and engaged viewer who has followed the unfolding drama surrounding Netflix’s hit series “Baby Reindeer,” I find myself deeply intrigued by the complex web of real-life inspirations and speculations that have emerged since its release.


It was only a matter of time before Scottish comedian Richard Gadd shared his own chilling tale during a performance once he felt prepared to do so.

He likely wouldn’t have anticipated that a TV show based on his life experiences would skyrocket to become the most-watched series on Netflix in both the U.S. and U.K., igniting a widespread discussion about trauma, stalking, privacy, and the allure of unsolved mysteries that captivates internet detectives.

Despite this, “Baby Reindeer,” a seven-episode series based on Gadd’s 2019 one-man show of the same name and recently Emmy-nominated for eleven awards, has followed this pattern. Gadd confesses to making significant storyline adjustments and renaming the protagonist Donny Dunn. However, he assumes the role himself, delivering a darkly humorous performance that represents another opportunity for him to confront his inner turmoil.

Only this time, millions of people have watched.

“The show has resonated strongly with people, as Gadd, 35, expressed to The Guardian following the April 14 premiere. He genuinely believed in it, but its unexpected success has left him feeling somewhat overwhelmed.”

As a viewer who has been through her fair share of challenging and thought-provoking shows, I can’t help but be frustrated by Baby Reindeer. The series introduces us to Donny, a struggling comedian who, unbeknownst to us, has hit rock bottom and is now working as a bartender in a London pub. But what comes next is not just unexpected; it’s infuriating.

If, that is, a title card at the beginning didn’t tell you that “this is a true story.”

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Gadd, the scriptwriter for every episode, explained that the storyline underwent minor adjustments to generate dramatic peaks. “It accurately reflects my own experiences of being stalked and mistreated, but we aimed to present it as a work of art rather than just a personal account to ensure the safety of those involved.”

Whether or not that part is working out has provided the latest twist in the Baby Reindeer saga.

A woman claimed to the Daily Mail that she is the one portrayed as stalker Martha in the series, but it’s Gadd who supposedly has the issue. Meanwhile, unofficial online investigators haven’t hesitated to involve real names in the discussion.

In response to speculation about the identities of real-life people depicted in our show, Gadd asked for restraint on Instagram, stating, “Let’s focus on the essence of our production rather than guessing who they might be.”

“Why do we call it a baby reindeer? I’ll explain the fascinating origin of this term as revealed in the most controversial TV series of the year.”)

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Born in the Scottish village of Wormit, located in Fife, Richard Gadd is a graduate from the Oxford School of Drama. He gained recognition through his provocative performances at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, including “Cheese & Crack Whores” (2013), “Breaking Gadd” (2014), and “Waiting for Gaddot” (2015), which earned him a Scottish Comedy Award for Best Solo Show.

In his interview with The Skinny in March 2016, Gadd shared that he wouldn’t label himself as a typical comedian. Instead, he mentioned, “I don’t believe I can deliver a stand-up performance by telling stories or crafting anecdotes and jokes. What I offer is thought-provoking theatrics, grand concepts, and in-your-face, rough comedy.”

Despite openly addressing his own challenges in his art, “Confronting such uneasy territories makes you grow as an individual,” he was recognized for portraying eccentric personas during live performances.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

But the real Gadd stepped up in Monkey See Monkey Do, which debuted at the Fringe in August 2016.

While endlessly jogging on a treadmill, Gadd worked through the emotional burden he carried from an traumatic event in his past. Four years prior, at the age of 23, he was drugged and sexually assaulted by another man, leaving him grappling with self-hatred and a crisis of masculinity. He shared his story candidly on stage, incorporating visuals and excerpts from therapy sessions that he lip-synced to enhance the performance.

The Guardian characterized Gadd’s style as having “unfiltered emotional honesty,” specifically mentioning an incident where he struggled with even casual conversation after encountering an ex-girlfriend following his assault, overwhelmed by self-awareness and embarrassment.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Gadd shared with the magazine, “I’ve undergone a significant transformation. It’s an life-altering experience. Following the incident, I found myself unable to control my actions.” Fearful of others’ reactions, he kept quiet for a prolonged period, refraining even from informing the authorities.

In his own thoughts, Gadd had constantly fretted about people’s judgments and opinions. Yet, as he later discovered, most people didn’t really care or think less of him due to his concerns. After sharing the matter with those closest to him, he felt ready to openly express himself.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

The quirky and enigmatic comedy show “Monkey See Monkey Do,” which Gadd characterized as “dark, off-kilter,” and “weird,” was awarded the Edinburgh Comedy Award for Best Comedy Show. This recognition came with a £10,000 (approximately $13,500) prize.

In an interview with The Scotsman, Gadd admitted, “I’ve shared many of my struggles publicly, that much is clear. However, I’ve tended to exaggerate them on stage, making the true meaning and reality hard to discern at times…The profound issues I was addressing were so overt that they were rarely given the serious consideration they deserved.”

As an obsessed fan of the fascinating concept behind “Monkey See Monkey Do,” I can’t help but share its captivating origin. This intriguing title is inspired by the wisdom of sports psychiatrist, Professor Steve Peters, and his groundbreaking Chimp Paradox model. According to him, we humans are essentially “apes striving to be rational beings.” Emotionally driven creatures that we are, we must constantly remind ourselves to engage our reasoning abilities.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Gadd opened up about his struggle with anxiety and manic depression, but assured us that he had undergone extensive therapy, remained sober, and was dedicating time to meditation and physical fitness. His newfound hobby of running long distances before bedtime helped him fall asleep more easily, allowing him to integrate this important routine into his performance.

He expressed, “I had planned to share this tale when I found the right listeners. Yet, I didn’t want to hasten my own healing. I needed patience. There was some apprehension and self-doubt, asking if the time was right. However, I hope it will have a positive outcome.”

Audiences came in droves and Gadd spent months performing Monkey See Monkey Do around the U.K.

Towards the close of 2016, he shared with The List that he didn’t desire another year filled with misery. Instead, his ambition was to merge his personal objectives of seeking tranquility within himself and his professional aim of making people listen to his messages.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

In 2019, Gadd went back to the Fringe with his unsettling narrative titled “Baby Reindeer.” This work recounted the long-term harassment he endured from an older woman named Martha, whom he had met at a London bar in 2013. He clarified that Martha was not her true name. During their initial encounter, Martha appeared down and distressed, and Gadd felt compassionate towards her, offering her a free cup of tea. He didn’t intentionally ward off her advances at first.

“Before I acknowledged the seriousness of the situation, I unwittingly made it more volatile by acting foolishly at times,” Gadd explained to The Independent.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

During his performance, he featured Martha’s emails (a total of 41,071 over three years) and excerpts of 350 hours of voicemails as part of his show’s innovative multimedia presentation. Additionally, there were testimonials from his parents and other individuals recounting the impact Martha’s misplaced affection had on their lives.

The terror mounts as Gadd recounts the great difficulty he encountered in persuading the police to intervene, only finding justification for their involvement after painstakingly searching through years of her messages to uncover the threatening gestures hidden among seemingly innocuous communications.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Gadd believed he had finished working on that chapter until “Monkey See Monkey Do” created quite a stir, and later, Martha discovered his contact information.

I shared with The Guardian after unveiling Baby Reindeer, “That was the most disheartening experience for me.” It seemed as if I had exorcised the torment of someone who inflicted immense pain on me, just to make room for her to assume a more prominent role. The irony of the situation was bitterly palpable.

At that point, according to Gadd’s account for Netflix, he began saving and jotting down notes on every voicemail my ex-partner left me, hoping to find something damning that would help resolve the situation decisively. I longed for her to make a revealing statement.

In 2017, the issue was handled. One restless night, it struck him that he had to “set the scene for this entire incident.” However, he found himself unable to make things happen once more.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

As an obsessed fan, I must confess that I hadn’t fully understood the depth of it then. Rushing to share my story a year ago would have resulted in a mere victim narrative. And let me tell you, everyone would have praised me for my bravery and commended my efforts. But deep down, I knew there was more to it than just being brave.

Additionally, he mentioned that labeling her as a terrible person and himself as the victim wasn’t an accurate representation of the situation.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Gadd understood that interacting with Martha was inappropriate for the audience, and a large portion of the uneasiness stemmed from observing him make the situation worse.

I can’t help but feel uneasy when I engage in flirtatious banter with Martha during my performances, represented by an empty bar stool. It’s a discomfiting experience, as the audience’s disapproval is palpable in those moments. And they have every right to feel that way.

And despite everything she put him through, he felt for her.

Instead of “When we imagine stalkers, our minds go to movies such as ‘Misery’ and ‘Fatal Attraction,’ where the stalker is portrayed as a terrifying figure lurking in dark alleys,” Gadd stated, “However, most stalkers have a past connection with their victim – a friend, an ex-partner, or a coworker. Stalking and harassment are manifestations of mental illness rather than deliberate malice. It’s crucial not to demonize her because she’s sick, and the system has let her down.”

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

In my experience as a lifestyle expert, when it comes to the events depicted in Baby Reindeer, I can confirm that the foundation of the story is undeniably authentic, according to Gadd’s statement to The Guardian.

But, his theatrical account was much more dramatic than how it played out in real time.

He shared that during harassment, one experiences an overwhelming sense of monotony and annoyance. He aimed to prevent this sensation for his audience.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

A seven-part series adapted from Gadd’s namesake show, along with the heart-wrenching tale from “Monkey See Monkey Do,” debuted on Netflix on April 14.

Gadd depicts Donny Dunn, a struggling writer-performer, who encounters Jessica Gunning (previously known as Martha) at the bar. Feeling compassionate towards her apparent sadness, he offers her a free cup of tea to cheer her up.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

When Martha, whom Donny affectionately refers to as “Baby Reindeer” due to their shared resemblance with her childhood toy’s large lips, big eyes, and adorable small bottom, sends him a friend request on Facebook, Donny conducts a search online. He discovers articles detailing Martha’s controversial history, one of which bears the title “Alarming Stalker Harasses Lawyer’s Deaf Child.”

Despite her proposal, he goes ahead and things take a turn for the worse. Later on, it is disclosed that Donny was deeply hurt emotionally when he was drugged and sexually violated by an trusted older man named Darrien (Tom Goodman-Hill) shortly before meeting Martha.

Based on Netflix’s data, “Baby Reindeer” ranked fifth among the most-watched programs during its debut week with approximately 2.6 million viewers. Subsequently, it climbed to the top spot for two consecutive weeks, accumulating around 22 million views and a total of 87.4 million hours worth of viewing.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

As Gadd soon found out, Netflix viewers are even more interactive than theatergoers.

When they learned that the tale had a factual basis, online investigators couldn’t just stand by. They were determined to bring potential wrongdoers to light if they were still out there hiding.

Instead of Gadd keeping quiet about the identities of Darrien and Martha’s inspirations, Reddit users and X posters have enthusiastically tried to uncover these mysteries on their own. Several social media profiles are suspected to belong to the real Martha, while guessing games abound regarding Darrien’s true identity.

Gadd pleaded with his Instagram followers on April 22 to avoid speculating about the identities of certain individuals mentioned in ongoing rumors, among whom is Sean Foley.

As a lifestyle expert, I’d suggest paraphrasing it this way: When coming across a harmful message directed towards me, as an actor, director, and Olivier Award-winning writer like Foley, I would take immediate action. I would report the issue to the authorities and let them handle the investigation of any defamatory, abusive, or threatening posts.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

The actress portraying Martha expressed that those intensely working to identify the real-life inspiration behind Gadd’s narrative had overlooked the primary message of the production.

As an obsessed fan, I’d say: I heard Gunning speak on BBC Scotland’s The Edit, and let me tell you, if you’re hooked on the show like I am, don’t get distracted by trying to uncover Martha and Donny’s real identities. In my humble opinion, that misses the mark entirely. It’s a shame, really, and I implore fellow fans to rewatch the series and appreciate the unique connection between Martha and Donny as the heart of the story.

Gadd skillfully avoided portraying the story as overly simplistic with clear-cut heroes or villains, stating, “Instead, they are intricately complex characters, much like real people.”

I find Martha absolutely captivating. One moment, she’s endearingly fragile; the next, she’ll leave you in stitches with her humor. It’s her intriguing mix of vulnerability and wit that keeps me hooked.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Before the show’s launch, I, an overzealous fan, assured myself I had nothing to fret about when it came to Martha reaching out. In an interview with Vanity Fair, I shared, “Things unfolded in such a way that she can no longer get in touch with me.” (I’ve emphasized the importance of careful word choice in numerous interviews since 2019 due to legal constraints.)

He also mentioned, “Regarding stalking, there’s always a lingering fear in the depths of your mind – no matter how hard you try to elude it.”

On April 26, an unnamed woman claimed in an interview with the Daily Mail that Martha is based on her, and she is currently enduring unwelcome advances from Gadd.

She shared with the magazine that “He’s been using ‘Baby Reindeer’ to follow me lately,’ she explained. “I’m the one being targeted, and he’s created a disturbing production about me.” The woman added, “The actress portraying Martha bears some resemblance to me after I gained some weight during lockdown, but I’m still far from unattractive.”

She denied stalking Gadd, saying, “Richard Gadd has got ‘main character syndrome.'”

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

Gadd did not respond to TopMob News’ request for comment about the Mail article. 

But he previously said that the production took pains to mask identities.  

As a lifestyle expert, I believe in drawing inspiration from my own experiences and those of real people I’ve encountered. However, it’s essential to remember that artistic and legal considerations come into play. You can’t directly copy someone’s life and name for television. It’s important to respect privacy and protect vulnerable individuals. Therefore, I always strive to create authentic stories while ensuring the well-being of those involved.

The Deeply Disturbing Story Behind Baby Reindeer

And he emphasized that real-life events didn’t unfold exactly as they do in Baby Reindeer.

Gadd emphasized that stalking can become monotonous, and shared his approach: “Adjusting the sequence of events, shifting key moments to the finale of episodes, helps enhance the narrative and keep it visually engaging.”

While the storyline contains elements of psychological thrills, his primary intention was to explore the aftermath of trauma, he shared. This theme may not be apparent to some viewers at first glance, but many are now recognizing Donny’s self-destructive behavior as a result of past traumas. Surprisingly, this aspect provides solace for audiences.

Watch
TopMob News

weeknights Monday through Thursday at 11 p.m., only on TopMob.

Read More

2024-07-17 19:21