The Godfather’s Al Pacino almost missed out on iconic role: “They wanted Jack Nicholson”

The Godfather’s Al Pacino almost missed out on iconic role: “They wanted Jack Nicholson”

As a supporter of Al Pacino, I can’t help but marvel at the serendipitous twists and turns that shaped his illustrious career. The revelation that he was almost overlooked for the iconic role of Michael Corleone is simply mind-boggling. Imagine if Jack Nicholson, Robert Redford, Warren Beatty, or Ryan O’Neal had donned the Corleone crown instead!


It’s well-known that Al Pacino gained widespread recognition for his performance in Francis Ford Coppola’s film version of Mario Puzo’s The Godfather. However, what might surprise you is that he was nearly outshone by several other well-known actors vying for the same role.

In his recently published autobiography titled “Sonny Boy,” Al Pacino reveals an interesting tidbit: Although Francis Ford Coppola had long desired Pacino to play Michael Corleone, the production studio, Paramount, initially held reservations about it.

According to a passage from the book, as reported by The Guardian, Pacino stated that Paramount initially did not wish for him to portray Michael Corleone. Instead, they considered Jack Nicholson, Robert Redford, Warren Beatty, and Ryan O’Neal for the role.

In the novel, Puzo portrays Michael as the “youngest member of the Corleone clan” who appears petite, has dark hair, and possesses an attractive, refined beauty. However, he gives off no sense of danger or menace to others.

“That didn’t sound like the guys that the studio wanted. But that didn’t mean it had to be me.”

The Godfather’s Al Pacino almost missed out on iconic role: “They wanted Jack Nicholson”

In my case, I shared that I had to undergo a screen test for the part and jet off to California, which turned out to be quite challenging because at that time, I was grappling with a deep-seated apprehension about flying.

My supervisor, Marty Bregman, instructed me, ‘It’s time for you to board that airplane,'” he clarified. “He provided me with a glass of whisky for the journey, and I made it to my destination.

Pacino went on to say: “The key is, Francis desired me. He desired me and I recognized it. There’s no feeling quite like knowing a director wants you.

He additionally bestowed upon me a gift, which took the shape of Diane Keaton. It seemed as if there were several contenders vying for the part of Kay, yet his preference for teaming me up with Diane implied that she held a distinct advantage during the auditions.

I was aware that she was thriving professionally and gracing the stage on Broadway, featuring in productions such as Hair and Play It Again, Sam alongside Woody Allen.

Not long before our screen test, I ran into Diane at Lincoln Center’s bar in New York City. We instantly connected – she was witty, approachable, and found my humor appealing as well. From the moment we met, I felt like I had made a friend and a supportive partner.

Following a fortnight of shooting, Pacino stated that Paramount once more raised doubts about his role, prompting Coppola to bring forward the filming of the scene set in an Italian eatery, where Michael seeks retribution against Sollozzo and McCluskey.

Pacino expressed uncertainty as to whether Coppola intentionally did this, yet pointed out that it provided an opportunity for him to demonstrate his capabilities.

As a cinephile, I found myself in awe as The Godfather clinched the prestigious title of Best Picture at the Academy Awards. Marlon Brando’s captivating performance earned him the Best Actor accolade, while Mario Puzo and Francis Ford Coppola shared the glory for their masterful adaptation of the screenplay. Robert De Niro, in his powerful portrayal, was also recognized with a nomination for Best Supporting Actor.

The film received another six nominations on top of that.

Coppola’s new movie, Megalopolis, has been released in theaters not too long ago, receiving a variety of opinions from critics, and experiencing difficulty at the ticket sales.

Read More

2024-10-13 12:33