The Hidden Flaw in MHA’s Hero System Revealed by American Hero Captain Celebrity

by

Initially, in the early seasons of “My Hero Academia”, the role and reputation of pro heroes were considered unquestionable. Characters such as All Might and others were revered as the uncontested protectors of peace, justice, and law, with most people admiring them greatly. However, it was not until later that the series began to challenge the legitimacy of the pro hero industry, revealing its harsh hypocrisies and paradoxes. Now, Captain Celebrity is further highlighting these flaws in a more evident manner within the current storyline.

Although Captain Celebrity may seem an exceptionally extreme figure in the worldwide pro hero circuit, it’s important to note that this industry has its roots in the very qualities that make Captain Celebrity so questionable. Essentially, Captain Celebrity embodies the flaws inherent in the system itself, making him less of an anomaly. Given these shortcomings, Stain the Hero Killer appears increasingly appealing, even with his violent history, as he challenges the very foundations of this problematic industry.

Captain Celebrity Reflects the Vain Origins of the Pro Hero Industry

Pro Heroes Were Born Out of Popularity Contests

Initially, it might seem that the flamboyant and self-focused Captain Celebrity goes against the very essence of being a professional hero, potentially tarnishing the ethos of the profession. However, contrasting him with modest, diligent heroes like Ryukyu and Sir Nighteye drives home this point. Yet, upon reflection after speaking to Koichi, it became apparent that individuals like Ryukyu are the exceptions rather than Captain Celebrity. Surprisingly, a humble hero who underplays their own abilities and achievements could be at odds with the founding principles of the entire profession. While modest heroes such as Ryukyu are indeed commendable, it’s important to remember that their approach deviates from the initial behavior exhibited by the pioneers of the hero industry. This discrepancy raises significant concerns for those who study the origins of professional heroism.

Back in the dawn of Quirks and extraordinary abilities, we found ourselves thrust into a peculiar new existence, struggling to establish a fresh order amidst this unfamiliar presence of Quirks. At first, it was the vigilantes who held sway, with some factions like Destro advocating for unrestricted use of these powers. However, as time passed, the initial chaos began to settle, giving way to stricter guidelines. The masses yearned for a clear-cut definition of heroes, and surprisingly, it wasn’t the strength or nobility of our Quirks that defined us, but rather, our popularity.

The first batch of pro heroes emerged when the public, in their wisdom, chose which vigilantes resonated as true heroes within their hearts. Unfortunately, those who failed to win this popular vote found themselves labeled as criminals.

By the time Koichi Haimawari embarked on his vigilante journey, it appeared that society had largely brushed aside the origins of the professional hero industry. People seldom pondered over its history, and when they did, societal acceptance of the popularity contest nature of the system was widespread. For generations, this system continued to operate, but it harbored deep-seated corruption at its core. Captain Celebrity emerged as a brash symbol of the industry’s dubious origins. Every aspect of Captain Celebrity showcases his self-centered and fame-hungry personality, from his hero name and playboy lifestyle to his reluctance to save anyone unless the cameras were present to ensure maximum media coverage.

Stain Warned Everyone About the Vanity of Pro Heroes

Methods Aside, Stain Has a Fair Outlook on the Pro Hero Industry

In a manner that may stir memories among fans of “My Hero Academia”, the self-centered and superficial actions of Captain Celebrity mirror the sentiments of Stain, the self-proclaimed hero killer. This is not only because Stain made an appearance in “My Hero Academia: Vigilantes” during his Stendhal days, but also due to their shared beliefs. Stain’s rogue career aimed to eradicate pro heroes who were driven by money or fame, and he sought to eliminate those who fought for questionable reasons. He was deeply passionate about inspiring heroes to showcase their authentic selves as individuals motivated by altruism, saving lives because it is morally right, not for rewards or recognition. A true hero, in this context, would selflessly save another life out of genuine kindness, without the need for monetary compensation or fame.

In no way does Stain’s brutal actions towards heroes like Tensei Iida, also known as Ingenium, who was forced into an early retirement due to his injuries sustained in Stain’s assault, hold any justification. However, when a figure like Captain Celebrity emerges and gains admiration across Japan, fans of My Hero Academia can comprehend why such a person as Stain is necessary to challenge the status quo with his words. Although Stain’s tactics are indefensible, his message serves an important purpose that has been long overdue. If society ever required a wake-up call regarding the superficial and materialistic nature of the pro hero industry, Captain Celebrity is that jolt. It seems as though Captain Celebrity is challenging Stain to confront him, even if Captain Celebrity remains unaware of who Stain is.

Many Other Pro Heroes Focus on Image Over Substance

Pop Step Commented on This to Koichi

In the spotlight, Captain Celebrity clearly embodies the archetype of a pro hero who leverages fame, yet he’s not alone. Watching Captain Celebrity bask in adoration in Japan, Pop Step subtly pointed out to Koichi that many other pro heroes share this celebrity-like behavior. While she didn’t elaborate, it’s clear from the world of My Hero Academia that she’s referring to the fact that during times of tranquility and stability, some pro heroes may find themselves with little else to do but boost their public image through grandiose displays and maintain a polished public persona for the pro hero industry. A good image is important for every hero, but some heroes overly rely on it.

One instance portrayed in “My Hero Academia” features the support hero, Uwabami, whose Serpentress Quirk enhances her senses. In emergency situations, such as finding civilians trapped under debris, Uwabami excels. However, when not on duty, Uwabami focuses significantly on her personal image. This isn’t to say that Uwabami is solely defined by her actions; she also engages in advertising, promoting products like shampoo or hair conditioner. This was the reason behind Momo Yaoyorozu’s and Itsuka Kendo’s internship with her. Uwabami selected these student heroes based purely on their appearances, inviting them to model alongside her in ads. Uwabami seemed content with this arrangement, but Momo and Itsuka soon realized that their time was not being productively utilized. Later, Momo regretted that she gained no knowledge or experience from her internship.

Captain Celebrity Makes Even the Roughest Vigilantes Look Good By Comparison

By Nature, Vigilantes Can’t Fight for Fame & Money

As long as vigilantes such as Knuckleduster, who resembles Batman in his roughness, don’t transform into full-blown villains, they can appear admirable compared to figures like Captain Celebrity. Vigilantes typically possess weaker abilities than professional heroes and lack the resources for logistical support, but their motivations are genuine. Characters like Koichi and Knuckleduster are selflessly determined to help others, putting their lives on the line and even risking arrest to combat crime whenever professional heroes can’t get there in time. In this way, all vigilantes embody Stain’s original definition of professional heroes, making them more noble than attention-seeking celebrity heroes or those who rely solely on popularity.

As an onlooker, it seems Captain Celebrity still has a chance to adjust his path and embody the true spirit of a hero who battles for genuine reasons. Regrettably, the reality is that the hero industry’s heart is tainted, with self-promotion, wealth, and popularity being the primary drivers among licensed heroes. In stark contrast, vigilantes struggle to obtain such accolades, tirelessly performing their challenging and underappreciated duties in obscurity. It’s almost ironic that the officially approved hero work is so flawed, while individuals like Koichi and Knuckleduster risk imprisonment for embodying what heroes should have always stood for.

Read More

2025-05-31 21:52