The Rings of Power season 2 review: Splendid storytelling redeems series – but it still has flaws

The Rings of Power season 2 review: Splendid storytelling redeems series – but it still has flaws

As a lifelong fan of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth, I must admit that The Rings of Power has been an absolute rollercoaster for me. On one hand, the visual spectacle is nothing short of breathtaking – the opulence of the Elven and Dwarven realms, the grotesque creativity of the Orcs, and the stunning landscapes are all a testament to the show’s attention to detail and budget well spent.


The first season of The Rings of Power was an intriguing showcase, drawing inspiration from the complex historical backdrop that J.R.R. Tolkien created for Middle-earth. Marketed as a precursor story to Peter Jackson’s iconic and cherished Lord of the Rings film trilogy, it offers a semi-prequel experience.

Featuring an enthralling ensemble, breathtaking cinematography, a captivating soundtrack, and an epic narrative that left audiences spellbound, this series appeared to be a masterfully designed work of artistry on virtually every aspect. It seemed destined to earn universal acclaim as an immediate timeless classic. However, its plot was disorganized.

In an effort to match the grandeur typically associated with Middle-earth, it utilized a vast and winding storyline, banking on the idea that including more elements such as characters, settings, narratives, subplots, and backstories would equate to a more ‘epic’ tale.

Initially, that inherent trait was misguided, leading secondly to a significant deficiency in richness and purpose within the sequence. It clearly demonstrated how even a single basic mistake can impede growth, if that error lies at the very foundation.

After its comeback, The Rings of Power is tasked with only one mission in its second season: It must refine its storyline. Given its vast potential and impressive starting point, it requires a more compelling narrative to keep audiences engaged.

The Rings of Power season 2 review: Splendid storytelling redeems series – but it still has flaws

In essence, The Rings of Power’s second season continues to embody the excellence of the initial installment, and notably enhances its narrative structure. However, there are some considerations to keep in mind.

Season 2 begins straightaway following the conclusion of season 1 in 2022. It is revealed that Halbrand (played by Charlie Vickers) is indeed Sauron, and we start to understand the initial stages of his scheme once he forges the three fateful rings.

Currently, our attention shifts towards Sauron’s planned actions, as he skillfully spins a net of deceit to forge more Rings of Power – tools essential for his aspired control over Middle-earth. The subsequent struggles – be they personal or military in nature – will unfold following this deceptive act.

Simultaneously, the battles persist in Middle-earth elsewhere. The Dwarves of Khazad-dûm grapple with the persistent fear that haunts their underground realm, while Númenor ponders its role within the world’s structure. Meanwhile, the Stranger (Daniel Weyman) embarks on a journey to Rhûn in search of his mission and self-discovery.

The Rings of Power season 2 review: Splendid storytelling redeems series – but it still has flaws

Among all the intricate plotlines in The Rings of Power season 2, the most impressive accomplishment lies in the main narrative – Sauron’s influence over Celebrimbor (Charles Edwards). This central thread stands out as the most compelling and acts as a robust foundation for the entire story.

In contrast to the first season, this captivating central storyline maintains its independence and drives the plot forward, instead of dissolving into an indistinct clamor of unrelated story arcs vying for dominance.

Skilled, intelligent, and charming, Celebrimbor carries a heavy burden of pride, arrogance, and self-importance – traits that Sauron subtly and maliciously manipulates. This complex bond between them is captivating: an enthralling, delicately poised dance that unfolds across all eight episodes, inexorably moving towards its predestined end.

Among all the Middle-earth characters depicted on screen, Edwards has crafted Celebrimbor as one of the most intricately complex and distinctive, imbuing the second season with a sustained dramatic depth that eluded the initial one.

Another relationship that shines is that of the father and son, equally stubborn and obstinate, Prince Durin (Owain Arthur) and King Durin (Peter Mullan). Counterbalancing the journey of Celebrimbor and Sauron, theirs is relatable, heartfelt and earnest. Whenever attention turns toward it, it’s a welcomed tether to reality.

The Rings of Power season 2 review: Splendid storytelling redeems series – but it still has flaws

The fact that the cast is consistently set against an exceptionally beautiful landscape adds to the charm. In comparison to its first season, the visuals in The Rings of Power’s second season are truly stunning and worth admiring.

Specifically, viewers get an up-close look at the lavish and sparkling realms of Dwarves and Elves: each unique and appropriate to their cultures, reminiscent of scenes straight out of J.R.R. Tolkien’s creative mind.

As a film enthusiast, I can’t help but marvel at the captivating assortment of creatively grotesque orcs in the Lord of the Rings films. Their design is nothing short of wonderfully gruesome, a testament to the artistry that Peter Jackson and his team possessed. However, when it came to The Hobbit trilogy, I believe he made a misstep by opting for CGI over tangible costumes and makeup.

The dedication and effort put into the production of The Rings of Power is simply astounding, with each dollar from its well-known budget appearing to be spent wisely. Regardless of how long a scene showcases breathtaking landscapes or intricate details, such as Dwarven architecture or Elven trees twisted with golden hues, you’ll find yourself craving for even more.

In no way was Tolkien’s work shallow; he devoted equal care to shaping the magnificent lands of Middle-earth as he did to crafting its inhabitants. Achieving an authentic and faithful portrayal of such a world is something to admire, and it’s crucial to remember that this isn’t a feat that should be underestimated.

The Rings of Power season 2 review: Splendid storytelling redeems series – but it still has flaws

Improved storytelling and consistently stunning imagery make it simpler to overlook the ongoing problems in The Rings of Power, as these flashes of brilliance suggest.

Although the show’s concentration has significantly increased, which certainly addresses the slow tempo from the initial season, there remains a substantial gap in the caliber of the numerous storylines.

Although the Elven and Dwarven plotlines are well-developed, the predominantly political storyline of Númenor feels overly tedious and dull. Similarly, the Stranger’s persistent search for his own identity fails to hold interest as well.

Similarly, the consistency of geography and timeline (important, intricate aspects of Tolkien’s work) often suffers, as characters seem to travel vast distances almost instantly. The storyline occasionally relies on obvious plot devices. The language can sometimes be overly elaborate and heavy-handed, which may feel jarring.

“It’s quite vexing how ‘unveiling the true name of this character’ continues to be a major plot device in the storytelling process. Admittedly, we learn the Stranger’s real identity by the end of this season, but it feels contrived that such a crucial detail wasn’t disclosed earlier, especially not after two seasons.”

After it has been finally resolved, it’s clear that it had outlived its stay by a significant margin. Most disappointingly, it is swiftly followed by another identical enigma, featuring yet another enigmatic character with an equally vague name.

A more effective version of “The Rings of Power” might have been created if it had abandoned its less compelling storylines, but now it’s evident that inconsistency is built into the show’s genetic code; at times, it shines brilliantly, and at other times, it leaves viewers puzzled. It’s important to evaluate “The Rings of Power” for what it currently offers, rather than what one might wish it could be.

It’s challenging to decide if the genuine enhancements in the second season reduce or increase the annoyance caused by persistent flaws. In essence, The Rings of Power Season 2 is skillfully made, innovative, and engaging, making it effortless to savor and admire what works well, while overlooking most other aspects.

Read More

2024-08-28 16:34