This Might Be the Most Underrated Batman Story (And I’m Not Afraid to Say So)

by

There’s no dearth of timeless Batman narratives. From “Year One” to “The Killing Joke” to the enduring Elseworlds tale “The Dark Knight Returns,” Batman has starred in some of DC Comics’ most iconic and cherished storylines ever. These three have been transformed into animated films, and that’s not even scratching the surface of the famous ones that have received animation treatment. Batman boasts one of the richest reservoirs of excellent tales in comics, and even those who aren’t fans of Batman are familiar with these classics. They are classics for a reason and rightfully receive all the accolades they do, but they’re not the only fantastic stories that Batman graces as the central figure. There are many more, and some that sadly don’t get the recognition they deserve.

As a devotee, I can attest that the two-part tale I followed, where I was labeled both a Murderer and a Fugitive, stands among the greats in Batman lore from 2002. This story transcended every Batman and related titles, becoming an epic saga that left an indelible mark on the comic book world. While DC may churn out numerous Batman comics, this particular narrative rises above the ordinary, offering a reading experience that’s truly unparalleled.

The story unfolds as Batman, accompanied by his crime-fighting associate Sasha Bordeaux, arrives at Wayne Manor following a regular patrol. Upon entering, they discover Vesper Fairchild, Bruce’s former girlfriend, fatally wounded on the floor. Before any action can be taken, the GCPD storms in and apprehends both of them for the murder. With the entire Bat Family becoming involved to clear Bruce’s name, the investigation only seems to pile up damaging evidence against him, causing even them to ponder his guilt. In the end, Batman decides to relinquish his Bruce Wayne persona entirely and exclusively live as the Dark Knight.

For some readers, the idea presented might seem plausible. After all, DC Comics has long explored the notion that Bruce Wayne is merely a disguise for Batman. Lines like “I’m still Batman in my head” from Batman Beyond and panels of him holding Wonder Woman’s Lasso of Truth while maintaining his identity as Batman are often cited. The Lego Batman movie also adds humor with the line, “Bruce Wayne lives in Batman’s attic.” However, what makes Bruce Wayne: Murderer and Bruce Wayne: Fugitive unique is how they delve into this idea and then cleverly twist it.

Bruce Wayne: Murderer? and Bruce Wayne: Fugitive Are Deep Dives Into What it Means to be Batman

What makes these tales distinctive is their profound exploration of Batman’s inner mind. They portray Batman as a solitary figure, existing solely as the guardian of Gotham City, devoid of a Manor to claim as his own and lacking the support of the Bat Family. This isolation enables them to delve into the unanswered questions that many people barely scratch the surface of. Questions such as what motivates Batman to aid Gotham City, why he refrains from taking lives, and even the reason behind his choice to be Batman in the first place.

Through these meditations, the Dark Knight finds himself back at Crime Alley, where his journey started. It’s only natural for him to witness a crime unfolding – a mobster being brutally assaulted by the Joker’s minions. Without hesitation, he leaps into action. To rescue the mobster, he takes a hail of bullets to his chest, thereby addressing his inner struggles. The determination to safeguard Gotham stems from the principles instilled in him by his parents. Batman abstains from taking lives, a lesson imparted by Thomas Wayne about the sacredness of every life. Batman’s existence is rooted in Bruce Wayne’s desire to prevent anyone else from experiencing the torment he felt that fateful night. As the bat symbol miraculously reappears on his chest after being blown away, it symbolizes that beneath the cloak of fear and vengeance, Batman’s essence is none other than Bruce Wayne.

This comic offers an outstanding exploration of Bruce Wayne’s personality, while skillfully involving the entire Bat Family to showcase their unique abilities. Each character contributes significantly to solving the enigma of who framed Bruce Wayne, demonstrating their detective talents fully. Tim Drake serves as the emotional backbone, keeping faith in Bruce until the end. Barbara Gordon, or Oracle, employs logic to tackle the case and presents arguments for why Bruce couldn’t have been involved in his own framing. Cassandra Cain functions as the perceptive observer, discovering evidence that proves Bruce’s innocence. Dick Grayson, aka Nightwing, leads the family, bridging faith in Bruce with concrete proof to support it. His prior experience as Batman speaks to his effectiveness in this role. Each member plays a vital and equally important part, and such balance is rare in comics.

In the end, the tales skillfully intertwine an intense enigma with character development centered on the profound subject of parenthood. David Cain, the primary culprit behind the murder, harbors resentment towards Batman for taking his daughter away from him. His objective was to demonstrate to his daughter, Batgirl, that Batman is as monstrous as he is. Cain aimed to shatter Batman’s resolve to prove that he would never be capable of being a father due to his solitary nature. However, the plan almost succeeded until Bruce returned to his family, apologized for his absence, and vowed to be a better role model and father. Cain’s scheme faltered because he failed to recognize Batman as Bruce Wayne.

The intriguing narrative of “Bruce Wayne: A Suspected Murderer” or “Bruce Wayne: On the Run” skillfully unveils a seldom-seen aspect of Batman. This tale stands out not only for its quality as a Batman story, a Batfamily story, but primarily because it is an exceptional exploration of Bruce Wayne’s character. It reveals that Bruce Wayne is a man who errs and alienates others, yet he has a profound affection for those in his circle, a feeling that has consistently and will continue to fuel the Batman.

Read More

2025-04-03 05:10