Which Gilmore Girl Boyfriend Was Best For Rory?

by

In the beloved series Gilmore Girls, Rory’s romantic interests – Dean, Jess, and Logan – each contributed significantly to Rory’s growth. However, one of them always seemed to grasp Rory better than the others. Although the primary focus of Gilmore Girls was to depict the evolution of Rory and Lorelai as mother and daughter, women, and friends, their romantic endeavors were crucial in shaping their character arcs. Rory wasn’t known for short-lived relationships. Each boyfriend left a lasting impression on her life, whether it was for better or worse, even during her teenage years.

Despite leaning on her boyfriends emotionally, Rory’s innermost self was independent, much like her mother. From an early age, she was clear about what she desired, and she persistently strove to realize those aspirations, particularly her educational goal of attending an Ivy League school. Her academic pursuits and journalistic ambitions defined a crucial aspect of her personality. The way each of her boyfriends responded to these goals (and Rory’s occasional academic setbacks) offers valuable insights into their characters, revealing much about who they truly are.

Dean’s Tantrum About Harvard Proves His Insecurities

Their Relationship Was Destined To Fail

Analyzing the initial stages of Dean and Rory’s relationship can be challenging due to their youth and inexperience. At 16 or 17, every decision, error, outburst, and feeling seems significant. It wasn’t always easy for them to articulate themselves, which is reasonable given their age. However, when Rory struggles with her college application and the lack of extracurricular activities, it becomes evident that she was grappling with anxiety. Unfortunately, Dean didn’t recognize this struggle.

Instead of understanding her situation, I lashed out at her, saying, “I don’t care about Harvard,” focusing more on the fact that we were no longer able to hang out as planned. Now, it wasn’t necessarily wrong or absurd for me to feel upset about not spending time with Rory lately. However, in that moment, I began to feel increasingly entitled to her time, driven by jealousy and insecurity.

It’s clear that Dean recognized Rory’s ambition to attend Harvard. However, there are instances when he shows support. Yet, when it came to the point where Rory’s Harvard aspirations became a reality, he struggled to handle it. For Rory, education was paramount, and he failed to comprehend that his attempts to keep her close would ultimately create a divide between them. Eventually, he might have begrudged her for chasing her dreams, which is not a predicament either of them should have found themselves in.

Jess Always Knew How Important Education Was To Rory & Supported Her

He Supported Her Dreams Unconditionally

During his time with Rory, Jess tended to make numerous errors. Instead of opening up to her, he chose to remain silent, and departed without so much as a word. Similar to Dean, Jess struggled to manage his feelings effectively. Unlike Dean who might express his emotions angrily at times, Jess suppressed them profoundly, choosing not to share his feelings with Rory.

Despite Jess’s imperfections, there was an uncanny resemblance between him and Rory, far surpassing others. He didn’t take school seriously, but he possessed a natural talent; he cherished reading, dissecting, and crafting words, and he recognized and nurtured her academic ambition. Despite their occasional estrangement, he inquired about her plans for Harvard, and when Rory temporarily left Yale, he was among the few individuals (alongside Lorelai) who refused to endorse her deception.

Indeed, Rory encountered a difficulty, yet she was capable of rising above it. Jess confronted her directly about this. It’s worth noting that among Dean and Logan, Jess had the deepest understanding of how much education mattered to Rory. When Rory left Yale, Jess had found his footing. To be honest, by then, they could have been a great match, but Rory was involved with Logan (and Jess saw through him as well).

Logan Was Only Too Happy To Let Rory Be A Kept Woman

Being With Logan Was Distracting And Fun

Logan possessed numerous admirable traits, yet when it came to aiding Rory, he struggled to comprehend her needs. Her decision to leave school barely registered with him. Given his circumstances, this response is unsurprising. After all, he would never fully grasp the extent of her determination to attend Yale. Comfortably settled himself, he was content to let Rory tag along on his journey, encouraging her self-destructive behaviors. She was adrift, and what she truly needed was a guide to steer her toward the correct path. That role, however, was never Logan’s.

It’s clear he adored her and even assisted in bringing out her hidden side, yet when it mattered most in Rory’s personal life, there were noticeable shortcomings. This is revisited in the revival of Gilmore Girls, titled Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life. Logan didn’t hinder her intentionally, but he also didn’t correct her mistakes. Spending time with him was effortless and enjoyable, which makes it difficult to resist. Each of Rory’s love interests in Gilmore Girls contributed something unique to her life, but none comprehended her as deeply as Jess Mariano did.

Read More

2025-06-03 23:01