Which South Park Kid Would You Ditch? The Shocking Answer Will Surprise You!

by

Despite being nearly 30 years old, the heart of South Park‘s success lies in the dynamic interactions among its primary quartet: Stan, Kyle, Cartman, and Kenny. However, no show thrives solely on four mischievous kids, and as the series advanced, other characters emerged into prominence. Some were there from the start but gained more screen time and character development over the seasons, such as Butters and Randy Marsh. Others, like Timmy, Jimmy, and Towelie, joined later and became permanent fixtures. Although these characters are significant, the show could continue if they were to disappear.

Could we also make that observation about the main quartet? After all, they’ve attempted similar plots before in the series.

Which of the Four Boys Can the Show Not Live Without?

To determine which of the four boys could potentially be written off without damaging the show, we should examine who is most integral to the plot. Let’s start with Cartman. Initially, what captivated the show’s audience wasn’t just the unique idea of hearing fourth graders swear, but rather their verbal spats with each other that started gaining traction after the ninth episode, “Mr. Hankey, the Christmas Poo.

The primary originator of those vulgar slurs is none other than Cartman. His cold-hearted and self-centered actions seldom benefit others, and he frequently initiates the events in an episode. Moreover, when a plan is in motion, it’s usually not conceived by Kyle, Kenny, or Stan; instead, it’s Cartman who comes up with it.

We can focus on a particular season for analysis. To be specific, let’s consider Season 9. For example, the plot device of the talent agent in “Wing” originated from Cartman, just like the plan to make Kyle’s cousin Kyle sink their baseball team in “The Losing Edge,” the idea to steal a boat in “Two Days Before the Day After Tomorrow,” and the act of throwing Butters dressed as a pig off the roof in “Marjorine.” Additionally, it’s important to note that “Die Hippie, Die,” “Ginger Kids,” and of course, “The Death of Eric Cartman” predominantly revolve around Cartman.

Essentially, Cartman’s schemes, whether they’re likely to fail or driven by his prejudice and lack of knowledge, make the show what it is. Even if opinions differ on how well the character has evolved over time, there’s no denying that he plays a crucial role in the series.

To understand the unique dynamic of banter among the characters in this show, start with Cartman and observe how it ultimately connects to Kyle and, to a slightly lesser degree, Kenny.

Occasionally, Kyle and Stan seem to be swap-able characters, but more frequently, they serve as the voices of reason, commenting on the bizarre occurrences that shake up their town each week, such as a robotic Barbara Streisand or the unexpected arrival of NAMBLA. If it boils down to choosing one, Kyle would be the one to stay, since Cartman heavily relies on Kyle in Season 10’s “Smug Alert!”. As shown, Kyle helps direct Cartman’s humorously uninformed bigotry, a key element that has remained effective for nearly three decades.

It’s understandable that some viewers might think Stan, being the main character, can’t be removed from the show because of episodes like “Asspen” in Season 6 and “Over Logging” in Season 12, which spotlight him. However, it’s important to note that while these episodes center around Stan, they also feature other significant characters. For instance, in “Asspen,” all four boys (Stan, Kyle, Cartman, and Butters) are present at the title location. Similarly, in “Over Logging,” episodes like those from Season 9 onward often focus on not just Stan, but also his father, Randy. This suggests that while Stan might be the protagonist, other characters play crucial roles in the success of these episodes as well.

Essentially, the storyline revolves around Stan and Kenny, as “Asspen” primarily focuses on Stan, Kyle, Cartman, and Butters. Notably, Kenny died in the second last episode of Season 5 (temporarily, at least). The series managed to carry on for an entire season without Kenny, but his absence was certainly felt. Upon his return, Kenny’s character became more developed, and he began starring in episodes more frequently than before.

Unlike several episodes from later seasons that primarily focused on Stan, episodes such as “Best Friends Forever” (Season 9), “Major Boobage” (Season 12), “The Ring” (Season 13), and “The Poor Kid” (Season 14) of South Park, stand out for being centered around Kenny. At this stage in the series, if one were to hypothetically consider which of the four main boys the show could function without, it would be Stan. This is because, by that point, losing Kenny again would seem redundant due to his frequent deaths and resurrections.

South Park revolves around fresh episodes that air on Comedy Central. You can catch it streaming on Max, while full-length specials are available on Paramount+.

Read More

2025-04-08 14:13