Why silence Hardtalk?

Why silence Hardtalk?

As a seasoned viewer of international news and a passionate advocate for quality journalism, I must say that the decision to cancel “Hardtalk” after 27 years is nothing short of baffling. With my decades-long experience in following global headlines, I can confidently state that this program has been a beacon of impartiality and insight in an increasingly chaotic world.


Add Hardtalk to your watchlist

On my computer, I store a folder filled with items that instantly make me burst out laughing whenever I revisit them. One such item is the video clip from 2014 in Afghanistan, where BBC’s Middle East correspondent, Quentin Sommerville, attempted to broadcast live amidst an eight-tonne blaze of burning narcotics. His report, filled with uncontrollable laughter and giggles, ended up becoming quite the comedic spectacle instead.

It’s rare for news in this country to be dominated by BBC journalists who are more recognized abroad than at home. But it happened again when it was announced that “Hardtalk,” the only long-form interview program on BBC, is being discontinued after 27 years of questioning public figures thoroughly. The show’s host since 2005, Stephen Sackur, has expressed his concern about this decision, voicing it on social media and other BBC shows. He tells me that he finds the decision “very unusual.

Additionally, he saw a bitter irony in this situation, as it occurred on the same day that Tim Davie, the BBC’s director-general, passionately advocated for additional government funding (which was granted in the Budget) to strengthen the World Service. He highlighted the service’s valued “impartial radio broadcasts,” its weekly reach of 320 million people, and its significant role in the global struggle for truth. Simultaneously, while appealing for trust on a global scale, he was effectively canceling one of the corporation’s most esteemed and widely-admired programs with his other hand.

Stephen Sackur showcases polite but unbending journalism

Hosting an impressive array of guests spanning from Nelson Mandela to Gwyneth Paltrow, and including Mikhail Gorbachev and Henry Kissinger, the team behind Hardtalk tirelessly worked for extended periods, at times even months, to gain access to influential figures making worldwide news. As Sackur describes it, “We strive to embody everything that BBC executives cherish most.” Indeed, as its impartial host, he skillfully delivers a blend of polite yet resolute journalism and leads a unique brand that has successfully evolved for the digital age. With an estimated weekly TV show audience of 70 million, it is also broadcast on World Service radio, available in podcast form, and disseminated via social media in short, digestible clips.

It seems like the thought process behind this decision involves two main aspects: cost-cutting and strategic planning. However, it’s important to note that the cost reduction argument may not be as substantial as it appears: given its small team, low operational costs, and repetitive format, Hardtalk operates very efficiently. Terminating the show would only result in a savings of about 5% – which is far from the amount needed by BBC News.

A tactical change, at least, seems more logical: as the corporation prioritizes live and breaking news, it can’t spare the indulgence for a program dedicated solely to interviews. This is something the BBC frequently accomplishes in numerous shows and formats every day. Hardtalk, however, excels in this area.

The discontinuation of “Hardtalk” is occurring amidst a deep-rooted disagreement between the BBC’s domestic and international news teams, conflicting programming agendas, and a fundamental dilemma for BBC News executives: prioritizing the vast audience worldwide who are unaware of the licence fee, or focusing on the guests appearing in the 8:10 am slot on the “Today” program.

Stephen Sackur may be bigger in Chechnya than he is in Chiswick, but he and his programme are linchpins in that fight. The decision to remove them from the battlefield is, indeed, very strange.

Read More

2024-11-07 20:06