Why The Death of Superman Still Shocks and Defines the DC Universe After 30 Years

by

Among comic book tales, none has left an enduring impact quite like DC’s The Death of Superman. This groundbreaking narrative not only topped sales records but also challenged conventional ideas about what a superhero story, specifically a Superman tale, could or should encompass. To this very day, its influence lingers, and there are countless comic enthusiasts who hold a particular fondness for this now-iconic narrative. Whether you adored it or criticized it initially, it has undeniably become one of the most indelible stories in comics. While there are certainly other extraordinary Superman stories being spun today, recapturing the immense resonance of this story is a challenge that few have been able to match – a testament to its continued relevance and ongoing exploration in the comics world. In my opinion, it remains the greatest Superman story ever told.

Clearly, nostalgia plays a significant role in my affection for these childhood favorites, including Superman. Being such an integral piece of my comic book adventure, the “Death of Superman” had a profound initial impact on me. However, I never could have foreseen the true extent of its influence, not just on me but on comics fans everywhere. Given my doubts about how well it would stand the test of time, I revisited the story again. Remarkably, it still resonates as deeply today as it did back then, which is a testament to its quality.

A Moment in Time

1990s-era productions often have elements that feel dated or incongruous compared to today’s standards, and that includes “Death of Superman.” Although it officially starts in issue #17 of “Superman: The Man of Steel,” the early issues mainly establish the story’s background as Doomsday tries to break free from his cell. This occurs in issue #18, after which the narrative gains momentum and never slows down, with Doomsday destroying everything and anything in his path.

Originally conceived in 1992, this narrative might surprise you due to its age. However, most of the distinctive ’90s aspects are linked to the Justice League of America’s team at that time, featuring characters such as Blue Beetle (Ted Kord), Booster Gold, Guy Gardner, Fire, Ice, Bloodwynd, and Maxima. Despite being beloved by fans, this lineup was less powerful compared to other rosters boasting heavyweights like Wonder Woman, Martian Manhunter, The Flash, Batman, Aquaman, and others. Initially, this didn’t bother me, but upon further reflection and analysis of comics, it seemed strange and almost like a footnote attached to the events portrayed.

We Took Superman For Granted

Over time, I’ve found myself returning to my initial perspective on this topic. To put it plainly, I’ve grown to value what this ensemble brings to the narrative. One of the key themes that stands out in the story is the overlooked nature of Superman, and there’s a clear subtextual reference (or meta aspect) to this theme that runs throughout the series. This thread is skillfully woven by the creative team consisting of Louise Simonson, Dan Jurgens, Jerry Ordway, Dennis Janke, and Roger Stern.

Characters such as Guy, Booster, Fire, Maxima, and Bloodwynd are all characters who seem perfectly suited for this era with its enigma and captivating charm that was so highly valued then. They also have significant scenes in the narrative, but their most crucial role is in demonstrating the immense trust and faith in Superman that even his critics hold, despite their differences.

One clear illustration is Mitch, initially showing no affection for Superman upon our introduction to him and his kin. Even when Superman makes an appearance, his dislike remains unaltered. However, as the circumstances become increasingly perilous, it becomes evident that behind his sarcastic exterior lies a deep-seated faith that Superman will intervene.

In various other scenarios too, Luthor questions the necessity of Supergirl, suggesting that Superman is sufficient on his own. However, internally, Superman acknowledges his need for assistance, yet never verbally expresses this, instead overcoming the discomfort and pressing ahead.

In the interview preceding Superman’s initial encounter with Doomsday, there are elements similar to this. Multiple perspectives of the interview portray it as dull or outdated for modern times. However, Superman discusses traits that we now identify as his character and heroic style. Interestingly, during the subsequent battle, these qualities turn out to be accurate reflections of who he is as a hero.

Observing Superman from different perspectives, we witness not only the public’s varying views but also the emotional responses of those closest to the man beneath the iconic symbol. Martha, Jonathan, and Lois experience a heart-wrenching ordeal as they watch their loved one make the ultimate sacrifice on live television. In the midst of it all, Lois bravely shields Superman from danger, creating scenes that are deeply moving. The poignant ending between Lois, skillfully depicted by artists like Jon Bogdanove, Bob McLeod, Jurgens, Brett Breeding, Janke, Jackson Guice, and Denis Rodier, leaves a lasting impression, making us feel as if the invincible hero, who was never meant to fall, finally did.

The Legacy

This idea we’re discussing is about legacy, something I believe has enhanced the significance of “The Death of Superman” over the years. Although not all aspects related to Superman and Doomsday have aged well, the original narrative and the subsequent events undeniably did. The story and its aftermath etched an enduring impression on the DC Universe from that point forward.

The story “Funeral for a Friend” delved into the reality of a world without Superman, revealing various enigmas and personal narratives linked to his demise. Following this, we have the popular saga known as “Reign of the Supermen“, where four new Supermen emerged, each becoming significant figures in the larger Superman lore. Ultimately, Superman made a comeback, but these experiences left an indelible mark on him too.

Over numerous tales spanning years, the theme has been delved into, and it’s not exclusively about Doomsday. A particular scene that readily pops up is Batman’s memorable statement in “Infinite Crisis”, where he tells Superman, “The last time you truly motivated people was when you were dead.” This scene carries an impact only if the global effect of Superman’s death wasn’t merely suggested but actually felt, and it was.

Over the years, Superman has frequently returned to that pivotal moment in his life, as well as the emotional impact and distress caused by his death and its circumstances on his family. This significant aspect was highlighted in the 30th Anniversary Death of Superman Special, where we witnessed Jon’s response upon learning about his father’s demise. Viewing the story from Jon’s perspective added a fresh, emotional depth to the narrative.

Even though all those aspects are significant, there’s a fundamental concept at heart that remains relevant even today. Before Superman perished, you had this sense that your heroes might falter, but they’d just withdraw, regroup, and return more powerful. The marketing portrayed it as the demise of a legendary figure, but deep down, we all felt it was merely a stunt because, well, isn’t Superman invincible? But then he did die, shattering our belief that heroes would ultimately triumph. To this day, the tale retains its powerful impact and has forged a legacy of its own within the rich tapestry of Superman’s legendary character. That’s what makes it my favorite Superman story of all time.

Sure thing, I’d love to hear your thoughts. Did I hit the mark, or did we veer off course a bit? Feel free to share your insights below, and let’s have a great chat about comics on Bluesky @knightofoa!

Read More

2025-05-01 05:40