You have used all your credits for this month. Please add more credits to continue.

by

A fresh fan theory, put forth by redditor u/rOkBad7175 on the /marvelstudios subreddit, utilizes Jonathan Hickman’s groundbreaking “House of X” and “Powers of X” saga to explain why mutants have been absent in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The theory offers a smooth method for integrating the X-Men into the Sacred Timeline as well. Gaining popularity among MCU fans, this theory focuses on Hickman’s reimagined character, Moira MacTaggert, and her special abilities and urgent mission to protect mutantkind. This could be the reason behind the delayed appearance of mutants in the main timeline of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The idea provides a rich backstory that not only addresses the delay but also lays the groundwork for intricate future storylines, much like the complex narratives that characterized Hickman’s acclaimed tenure on the X-Men comics.

During his time writing the X-Men comics, Hickman introduced a fresh, daring chapter known as the Krakoan Age, which significantly changed the norm for Marvel’s mutants. A major turning point in this massive overhaul was a surprising twist on the character Moira MacTaggert. Usually recognized as a human geneticist and strong supporter of Charles Xavier, Hickman unveiled that Moira is actually a mutant with the unique ability to reincarnate. With each passing, she returns to the instant of her birth, carrying over all memories from her past lives.

In House of X #2, it’s explained that Moira is currently living her tenth life and has, in her past lives, been instrumental in shaping various timelines through her foresight. However, she discovered a harsh, unchangeable reality across her nine previous existences: mutants consistently face defeat. No matter the approach – be it noble self-sacrifice, forceful dominance, or diplomatic integration – all paths ultimately lead to the oppression, enslavement, or annihilation of mutantkind. This fate is often inflicted by humans, superior Sentinels, or formidable cosmic or artificial entities.

Equipped with profound wisdom from past lives spanning centuries, Moira X embarked on her tenth reincarnation determined to halt a disastrous pattern. She sought out Charles Xavier earlier than in prior realities, exposing her mutant identity and the impending doom for their kind. This disclosure altered Xavier’s initial vision of harmonious coexistence, compelling him towards a more extreme approach for mutant preservation. Subsequently, Magneto was included in this clandestine council. As a trio, guided by Moira’s unique foresight into past errors, they engineered the creation of Krakoa, a self-governing mutant nation, and the Resurrection Protocols, perhaps most importantly. This innovative plan allowed for the revival of deceased mutants, essentially eliminating death as a significant hazard to their species. This daring move brought together former X-Men, allies, and even many long-standing enemies under one flag, all guided by Moira’s unseen influence and the desperate aspiration that this life would be the one where mutants could endure and thrive.

MCU Fan Theory: Could Moira’s Cycles Explain Mutant Absence and Emergence?

Based on the intricate history of Moira MacTaggert as portrayed by Hickman in his X-Men series, u/rOkBad7175 presents a novel viewpoint regarding why mutants have been absent from the MCU and how they might eventually come to light. In their opinion, “The reason we haven’t seen them is due to Moira MacTaggert. Perhaps this is her 9th life or more. She attempted multiple times for the mutants to survive. Could the Sacred Timeline be one of those lives? She seems to have orchestrated significant events there?” This theory posits that the MCU’s Sacred Timeline could represent another of Moira’s attempts to guide the precarious journey of mutantkind, possibly even learning from occurrences in other realities such as the Fox X-Men film universe.

A fundamental aspect of this theory revolves around Moira’s potential adjustment in her approach within the current Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) timeline. As u/rOkBad7175 puts it, “Moira eventually understood that for mutants to survive, they should keep quiet and avoid going public. So far, this strategy seems effective.” This implies a strategic choice by Moira to maintain the secrecy of mutants. The theorist further proposes a connection between Moira’s actions and the fate of another superpowered group, suggesting that Moira may have intentionally worked towards eliminating threats: “Perhaps she played a role in the disappearance of the Inhumans from the Sacred Timeline, or maybe she took away the terrigen mist (a substance in the comics that causes mutants to fall ill). This could explain why we haven’t encountered the Inhumans in this timeline.

A different user, u/rCaciulacdlac, has proposed an in-depth integration of the TVA into u/rOkBad7175’s narrative: “I can incorporate the TVA into your storyline. It might be that for the sacred timeline to function correctly, Moira must live through all the timelines that ultimately result in the demise of the mutants, allowing her to eventually choose the path of the Sacred Timeline. Any timelines where she perishes are then eliminated.” This reinterpretation presents Moira’s multiple lives as a challenging yet necessary process, possibly overseen by the TVA, with unsuccessful timelines being discarded, thereby supporting the “mutants inevitably fail” theme until a stable pathway is established.

In the highly anticipated film titled “Avengers: Doomsday“, set to hit theaters on December 18, 2026, mutants are set to play a pivotal role in the Marvel Cinematic Universe crossover.

Read More

2025-05-27 13:11