Honestly, it breaks my heart when I see anime characters absolutely crushed by their storylines. You know the ones – they’re burdened with all the heavy emotional stuff, they make you feel everything right alongside them, and then… they just get dropped. It’s like, these characters deserved some serious self-care! A good therapist, a relaxing vacation, even just a fun, lighthearted beach episode would have been amazing instead of constant trauma and a sad piano melody playing them out. They deserved better, seriously!
Some anime characters leave a lasting impact, not because of happy endings, but because of how tragically their stories unfolded. They’re the ones we endlessly discuss with friends, still upset about what happened to them. Every fandom has these characters – those who deserved better, who could have found redemption or happiness, but instead became examples of anime’s bittersweet power. We haven’t forgotten them, and we still blame the writers for their fates.
10. Maes Hughes – Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Hughes was central to the story, and his death felt particularly shocking and pointless. It seemed intended only to upset the main characters, not because it made sense for his own arc. He was a good man – a friend, a father, and a soldier who truly believed in doing what was right.
His death dramatically changed the show’s atmosphere, making it consistently darker and focused on disappointment and treachery. Though it moved the story forward, many viewers were upset by how harsh it was. While his death fit the unforgiving nature of the military setting, it also removed a rare source of hope from the series.
9. Kurapika – Hunter x Hunter
After his clan was brutally murdered, Kurapika dedicated his life to revenge. He transformed from a hopeful and inquisitive child into a hardened and single-minded weapon. While his abilities and intellect made him incredibly powerful, his descent into darkness served as a heartbreaking example of how the pursuit of justice can destroy a person.
Despite winning battles, he never found true peace. His journey felt unfinished, always taking a backseat to Gon and Killua’s. Kurapika is still trapped by his grief, bound to his quest for revenge both physically and emotionally.
8. Sasha Blouse – Attack on Titan
Honestly, when Sasha died, it really hit the fandom hard. She started as this fun, lighthearted character, but she grew into someone incredibly relatable and hopeful, even in such a dark world. That’s why it felt so jarring when she went so suddenly, especially during what felt like a really important turning point for her. It didn’t feel like it served the story, more like a shock for shock’s sake, and it just left a lot of us feeling really empty.
Sasha represented purity and goodness as the world around her fell apart, and her death only emphasized the show’s bleak outlook. She struggled more than many to maintain her compassion, so her fate felt like a cruel consequence for remaining decent in a world that had lost its kindness.
7. Jiraiya – Naruto
For many anime fans, Jiraiya’s death was one of the most heartbreaking moments. His battle against Pain was both heroic and visually stunning, but it was especially sad because he didn’t live to see the peaceful world he worked so hard to create. It wasn’t just the loss of a powerful fighter; it was the loss of a wise teacher and the important lessons he shared.
Jiraiya should have lived to see Naruto succeed – he deserved to witness his student’s victory. Sadly, he died a lonely death, offering only a hopeful prediction of the future. Even now, people speak his name with a sense of lost potential. While his sacrifice was significant, it left fans feeling unfulfilled, denying them the emotional closure they wanted for such a popular and well-loved teacher.
6. Kamina – Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Kamina was a character defined by his incredible determination. He sparked the energy of the series, making his untimely death a huge shock – and a real loss for anime fans. His passionate spirit drove the story forward, so when it was extinguished, it felt particularly impactful.
Simon continued to grow after Kamina’s death, but his victories always felt shadowed by the loss. Fans were disappointed that Kamina’s potential was cut short, even though his fate served a purpose in the story. It was a meaningful plot point, but a difficult one to accept emotionally, and remains a particularly painful sacrifice in the world of giant robot anime.
5. L – Death Note
Watching L, I always felt like he was the show’s moral compass, a brilliant thinker in a world built on lies and manipulation. When he died, it wasn’t just a plot point – it felt like a real loss, a genuine betrayal. That incredible tension between him and the villain, what made the show so famous, just disappeared the moment he was gone. No one could fill his shoes; they never managed to recapture that same spark.
He should have won, or at least had a respectful ending. Instead, a combination of overconfidence and bad luck led to his downfall. He brought a remarkable talent to the show, and seeing that talent dismissed so easily was deeply frustrating for audiences, who felt his potential was wasted.
4. Koro-Sensei – Assassination Classroom
Despite being a force for good and offering his students a path to a better future, Koro-Sensei’s life ended sadly. Knowing he didn’t have much time, he led his students with care, creating moments that were both heartwarming and heartbreaking. While his death wasn’t entirely unexpected, it was still deeply upsetting. The anime didn’t shy away from the pain, showing how hope and sadness existed side-by-side. After trying so hard to make amends for his past, he deserved a peaceful ending, but ultimately, he was a sacrifice that brought emotional release.
3. Lelouch Lamperouge – Code Geass
Honestly, Lelouch’s story just gets me. He really tried to play god, and it cost him everything. His plan for peace was incredible, but also incredibly sad, and his death? It sparked so much discussion – was it justice, or just the weight of everything he’d done finally crushing him? What really stuck with me, though, was how completely isolated he became at the very end. He achieved so much, lost so much, but ultimately, he was all alone.
He should have been given the opportunity to redeem himself, rather than being remembered only as a tragic martyr. While his death created a powerful legend, it overshadowed the real man he was. It felt deeply unjust that the very principles he dedicated his life to ultimately led to his destruction, despite the cleverness of his plan.
2. Rem – Re:Zero
Rem’s story was incredibly sad. Though she started as a supporting character, she quickly became a fan favorite thanks to her unwavering loyalty, kindness, and bravery. Despite her deep love going unreturned, she finally found a measure of peace – only to be tragically erased from existence. After everything she suffered, she deserved to be happy, but her story ended at its most heartbreaking moment. Viewers witnessed her devotion crumble, and the impact of her loss is still felt today.
1. Neji Hyuga – Naruto Shippuden
Neji’s story centered on overcoming a predetermined fate. His death is often debated by fans, not because it was unexpected, but because it felt unsatisfying. He strived for personal freedom, a sense of self, and fairness – only to die protecting someone else’s goals. His character deserved a proper resolution, not an ending defined by self-sacrifice.
Neji’s death felt wrong because it didn’t honor the important ideas about freedom and self-improvement his character represented. He was a deeply complex figure in Naruto with a lot of untapped potential, but the writers chose to end his story simply to emphasize that everyone dies. Fans weren’t upset that he died, but that his character deserved a more fulfilling conclusion.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
https://comicbook.com/anime/list/10-anime-protagonists-who-are-actually-the-worst/embed/#
Read More
- Best Controller Settings for ARC Raiders
- Ashes of Creation Rogue Guide for Beginners
- Stephen Colbert Jokes This Could Be Next Job After Late Show Canceled
- 7 Home Alone Moments That Still Make No Sense (And #2 Is a Plot Hole)
- 10 X-Men Batman Could Beat (Ranked By How Hard It’d Be)
- Is XRP ETF the New Stock Market Rockstar? Find Out Why Everyone’s Obsessed!
- DCU Nightwing Contender Addresses Casting Rumors & Reveals His Other Dream DC Role [Exclusive]
- 10 Ridley Scott Films With the Highest Audience Scores on Rotten Tomatoes
- Neverness to Everness ‘Co-Ex Test’ sign-ups now available
- 10 Best Anime to Watch if You Miss Dragon Ball Super
2026-01-31 00:16