10 Great Movies Where The Villain Won (& You Were Happy About #3)

We often see movies where good wins, but what about the stories where the villain succeeds? These endings can leave you feeling shocked, upset, or uneasy, but they’re also hard to forget. They break the typical “hero wins” pattern, showing us that life isn’t always fair – and the villain doesn’t have to be superpowered, just clever or unstoppable. It’s this strange mix of shock and even a little bit of respect that makes these films so memorable, staying with you long after they end. They often become surprisingly appealing, even iconic parts of pop culture.

Here are 10 fantastic films where the villain triumphs over the hero, prompting you to consider what ‘winning’ truly means within a narrative. Each movie grabs your attention and leaves you pondering how its ending could be simultaneously harsh and masterful. Be warned: spoilers follow.

10) Saw

Saw is a hugely popular horror series, and many now consider it a classic of the genre. The original film is still the most memorable. What makes it effective, even now, isn’t simply the graphic violence, but the shocking ending, where Jigsaw (Tobin Bell) completely outsmarts both the characters and the viewers. The film centers around two men locked in a disgusting bathroom, compelled to decipher the rules of a terribly harsh game to survive. Ultimately, there’s no last-minute rescue by a police officer or heroic intervention – the villain was in charge the entire time. Jigsaw succeeds because his strategic thinking is unmatched. The movie leaves you feeling uneasy, but also with the realization that there was no other possible outcome.

9) Saltburn

Saltburn is certainly a divisive movie, but by the end, it’s hard not to admit that Oliver (Barry Keoghan) succeeds spectacularly. The film centers on a seemingly naive young man who enters the orbit of a rich and unusual family – and it soon becomes apparent that everything happens for a reason. It’s compelling to watch because you recognize that his schemes, fixations, and carefully planned actions are morally wrong. Feeling uneasy is part of the experience, particularly regarding his behavior, but the precision with which he takes down everyone around him is so impressive that even viewers who are shocked can appreciate how well his plan works. You might not approve of him, but you have to concede that he achieves a stunning victory. Plus, the film’s conclusion is simply perfect.

8) Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back

When this movie was first released, viewers weren’t prepared for the heroes to face such a defeat in a series of this size (and to be clear, it’s not that they completely lose; they just don’t achieve a real victory). Star Wars: Episode V – The Empire Strikes Back concludes with Luke (Mark Hamill) injured, Han Solo (Harrison Ford) imprisoned, and Darth Vader (David Prowse) shockingly revealing his connection to Luke. It was a huge disappointment for those hoping for another Rebel victory. However, this defeat ultimately became one of the saga’s biggest assets. While frustrating at the time, seeing the villain succeed is what made the movie a lasting pop culture icon. That outcome proved Star Wars could be more complex, thrilling, and have a greater effect on audiences than anyone anticipated.

7) The Dark Knight

In The Dark Knight, the Joker (Heath Ledger) didn’t need to destroy Gotham to succeed; his aim was simply to demonstrate how easily people can be broken. The film’s central conflict isn’t about physical fights or car chases, but rather Batman (Christian Bale) struggling to prevent total chaos. And ultimately, he doesn’t succeed. By the film’s conclusion, the city “loses” Harvey Dent (Aaron Eckhart), and Batman is compelled to accept responsibility for something he didn’t do. While it might appear the hero triumphs, the Joker’s philosophy is what truly prevails. It’s not a traditionally happy ending, but it’s compelling to watch a story where a villain’s greatest achievement is manipulating everyone’s perceptions. For someone like the Clown Prince of Crime, that’s a significant win, even if he’s eventually apprehended.

6) Se7en

Widely considered one of the greatest thrillers, Se7en isn’t just shocking because of its violence. The true power of the film comes from the chillingly calculated nature of John Doe’s (Kevin Spacey) scheme. The story follows two detectives as they investigate a series of murders based on the seven deadly sins, leading to John Doe’s surrender – but not before he executes one final, horrifying act. The script is masterfully written, culminating in a twist that genuinely surprises viewers. The ending is truly shocking, leaving the audience stunned. John Doe achieves a disturbing victory by maintaining control of every detail, even after his death. It’s so precise and unsettling that it’s hard not to be impressed, even though you can’t support him. Rarely has a villain been so completely successful in their plan.

5) Arlington Road

Often overlooked, Arlington Road is a standout film with an unforgettable ending. It centers on Michael Faraday (Jeff Bridges), a college professor who grows suspicious that his neighbors are terrorists. The story skillfully blurs the line between genuine fear and unfounded worry, leaving you questioning Faraday’s reactions for much of the film. As things unfold, it becomes increasingly clear that his suspicions are correct. The ending is harsh and uncompromising. There’s no traditional hero to save the day; the villains succeed with chilling efficiency. However, the impact of their win isn’t simply *what* happens, but *how* the film meticulously lays out every detail, making the outcome feel unavoidable. It’s a perfect illustration of a carefully constructed scheme where escape seems impossible. It’s rare for a psychological thriller to deliver such an ending while still feeling completely logical and inevitable.

4) 12 Monkeys

What makes 12 Monkeys so compelling is its constant ability to surprise you. The film centers on James Cole (Bruce Willis), a convict sent back in time from a post-apocalyptic future to discover the source of a deadly virus that decimated the human population. However, as he delves deeper into the investigation, it becomes increasingly obvious that his actions are simply a part of a fixed, repeating pattern. He doesn’t prevent the disaster, he doesn’t alter events – he merely observes what’s destined to happen. The film keeps you hoping for a different outcome, but ultimately reveals that the battle was already lost. While the plot can be a little challenging to follow at times, the film succeeds by presenting defeat in a way that’s both unsettling and impressive, demonstrating that not every story has a happy ending. The true antagonist isn’t a typical villain, but something far more disturbing, and that realization is powerfully impactful.

3) The Silence Of The Lambs

The Silence of the Lambs is a genuinely terrifying and iconic horror film that first introduced us to Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins) and established him as one of the most memorable villains in fiction (he even got his own TV show later!). While Clarice (Jodie Foster) does manage to capture Buffalo Bill (Ted Levine), it’s really the cannibalistic doctor who makes the biggest impact. The film centers on the young agent’s investigation, and she depends on Lecter’s incredibly smart (though disturbed) mind to find the serial killer. However, he consistently stays one step ahead. When he breaks free, the audience almost feels compelled to cheer for him. Is it disturbing to find yourself supporting a killer like him? Definitely. But for a lot of viewers, Lecter is so clever and charming that his success is strangely captivating. You’re left feeling more impressed by the villain getting away than by the crime being solved.

2) Avengers: Infinity War

When discussing movies where the villain triumphs, Avengers: Infinity War immediately comes to mind. For superhero films, it was truly surprising to see Thanos (Josh Brolin) succeed. In the movie, he accomplishes his aim of eliminating half of all life, and to add to the impact, the final shot shows him calmly relaxing – almost as if he’s mocking the viewers. This was arguably one of the most daring decisions made within the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Before Avengers: Endgame continued the narrative, it stood out as one of the most shocking and unforgettable cliffhangers ever. Seeing heroes vanish unexpectedly was heartbreaking, yet it was hard not to appreciate the story’s bravery. It was the first time Thanos felt like the protagonist.

1) No Country for Old Men

This movie deserves much more attention. No Country for Old Men centers on Llewelyn Moss (Josh Brolin) as he attempts to flee with a stolen sum of money after a failed transaction. However, the true source of fear isn’t the dangerous situation itself – it’s Anton Chigurh (Javier Bardem). He isn’t simply a murderer; he embodies death and the feeling that some things are unavoidable. His presence in every scene conveys an overwhelming sense of power. He’s cold, precise, and seems all-knowing, and his victories carry a weight that surpasses any plot twist. What’s particularly striking is the film’s message: sometimes, goodness doesn’t triumph, and our efforts can’t alter what’s meant to be. Like many great films, it leaves you feeling uneasy yet deeply impressed. Chigurh doesn’t just win; he fundamentally changes how we view villains in contemporary cinema.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/underrated-horror-movie-villains-need-franchises/embed/#

2025-10-04 02:14