10 Worst Decisions DC Superheroes Have Ever Made

Look, as someone who watches a lot of superhero movies, I’ve noticed a pattern with DC’s heroes. They always feel like they have to take on everything themselves, like the fate of the universe is one big group assignment they can’t delegate. And honestly? Their hearts are usually in the right place, but their solutions are… messy. They end up less like saviors and more like people who are just delaying the inevitable, shuffling around the disaster instead of actually preventing it.

Big, planned changes in DC stories often backfire spectacularly. The characters seem unable to avoid interfering, even when things are clearly best left alone. Often, being a hero isn’t about making the right choice, but about demonstrating that they can control a situation, even if it’s a mistake.

10. Batman Creating Brother Eye

Driven by a deep distrust of super-powered individuals, Batman created Brother Eye – an AI system using satellites to keep track of metahumans. While he intended it as a safety measure, his lack of faith in others nearly led to disaster. Maxwell Lord took control of the system and used it to create the OMACs, turning regular people into robotic soldiers who targeted heroes. Ultimately, Batman’s creation nearly caused the destruction of everything he was trying to protect.

This choice shattered his principles. It revealed that the man who always seemed in control was actually ruled by his own fear. Instead of preventing disorder, Batman unintentionally created it. Brother Eye serves as a constant warning that an excessive focus on control can actually destroy the values it’s meant to defend.

9. Wonder Woman Killing Maxwell Lord

Okay, so as a huge Wonder Woman fan, it was intense watching that whole situation with Maxwell Lord unfold. He was controlling Superman, making him attack his friends, and Diana just… acted. She killed Lord on TV to stop him, and while she absolutely saved lives, everyone just saw a hero commit murder. It was a really tough moment because it totally shattered the public’s faith in heroes and caused a huge rift within the Justice League. It was a brave decision, but it had massive consequences, and honestly, it’s something I still think about when I remember that storyline.

Her decision sparked a discussion about whether there are absolute rights and wrongs, or if violence can sometimes be justified. While Clark and Bruce believed in a clear line between right and wrong, Diana followed a warrior’s principles. What initially seemed like a practical solution quickly became a public relations disaster, making her appear cruel to the people she was trying to help and inspire.

8. Hal Jordan’s Rampage as Parallax

After the city of Coast City was destroyed, Hal Jordan was overcome with grief. When his request to rebuild it using the Green Lantern Corps’ power was refused, he lashed out at the Guardians. He took control of the Central Power Battery and transformed into Parallax, becoming a being of fear and corruption instead of the embodiment of willpower he once was.

As a lifelong fan, watching Hal Jordan fall was absolutely devastating. It wasn’t just a personal tragedy; it shattered the entire Green Lantern Corps and almost destroyed everything! While he did eventually find some kind of redemption, it could never undo the damage. It was heartbreaking to see him give in to the darkness he’d always battled, and it completely changed how I thought about what it meant for a hero to truly fall from grace. It wasn’t just a mistake; it was a complete and utter collapse.

7. Superman’s Injustice Regime

Following the Joker’s cruel manipulation – tricking him into believing he’d killed Lois Lane and their baby – Superman abandoned his commitment to justice. He began ruling Earth with absolute power, harshly punishing criminals and suppressing any opposition. His overwhelming sadness transformed into a ruthless dictatorship, turning the beacon of hope into a symbol of fear.

This event deeply divided the superhero world. While Batman opposed Superman, the harm had already been done—Superman demonstrated that even the noblest intentions can be corrupted by absolute power. The once hopeful “Man of Tomorrow” became a cautionary tale about the dangers of arrogance and unchecked authority.

6. Green Arrow Betraying His Team in Cry for Justice

After losing both his son and his city to the villain Prometheus, Oliver Queen sought revenge and killed him. While his team believed in bringing Prometheus to justice, Oliver chose to punish him. This act of vengeance destroyed his reputation among other heroes. The resulting moral conflict split the League, and Oliver ultimately lost sight of his own values.

As a movie lover, it really struck me how this character spent his whole life talking about understanding and forgiveness, but when push came to shove, he just lost it. It was heartbreaking to watch his carefully built image of being ‘the good guy’ crumble, mirroring the destruction around him. It just goes to show, even someone who preaches morality the loudest can stumble when grief and the desire for revenge take over. It’s a powerful reminder that everyone has a breaking point.

5. The Flash Resetting Reality in Flashpoint

Barry Allen’s biggest error stemmed from his love for his mother. When he traveled back in time to save her, he unintentionally created a drastically different and terrible present – the fractured ‘Flashpoint’ timeline. This new reality was filled with war, and he ultimately had to correct his actions, effectively undoing the rescue that started it all. His attempt to show kindness ended up turning history into a tragedy.

Barry’s attempt to change the past proved that even with super speed, you can’t escape the results of your actions. The resulting timeline – known as the New 52 – was permanently damaged by his interference. Driven by good intentions, he carried out one of the most disastrous time-altering experiments ever attempted by a hero.

4. Batman’s Contingency Files Falling Into Enemy Hands

Batman meticulously documented strategies to defeat each member of the Justice League, a precaution he hoped would never be necessary. However, Ra’s al Ghul’s actions forced him to confront the possibility. When those plans were stolen, they were used against his teammates, systematically taking them out of action. Ironically, the hero who planned for every eventuality ended up causing the very crisis he worked so hard to prevent.

The betrayal stung especially deeply because it came from someone inside the group. Batman’s need for secrecy and control ironically made him the biggest danger to the League, even if he didn’t mean to be. His belief that being suspicious kept everyone safe actually showed a troubling reality: you can’t truly control things and also have genuine trust.

3. Wonder Woman’s Handling of Amazons Attack

When the Amazons attacked the human world, Diana struggled to lead effectively. Torn between her allegiance to her homeland, Themyscira, and her responsibility to protect humanity, she couldn’t stop the conflict from worsening. This indecision led to needless deaths and damaged the trust she had carefully established with others.

She attempted to resolve the fighting with kindness, but good intentions couldn’t erase the violence that had already happened. Her struggle to fully commit to either side showed how fragile her divided loyalties were. Ultimately, she didn’t fail because she chose the wrong path, but because she couldn’t choose a path at all.

2. Superman Exiling Himself After For Tomorrow

Still burdened by his inability to save a million people who disappeared, Superman withdrew from Earth. He wasn’t avoiding conflict, but rather the weight of his duties. At a time when the world desperately needed encouragement, he chose to remain silent. This absence of hope allowed fear and distrust to spread.

As a film buff, I’ve always been fascinated by characters who fall from grace. This particular story really hits hard because it’s about someone who should be a beacon of hope, but ends up letting everyone down by doing nothing. It’s a powerful idea – that choosing to step back can be just as damaging as actively causing harm. It felt like watching a hero just…give up. He had the power to change things, to inspire, but he couldn’t even motivate himself to rejoin the world and help people. It’s a tragic waste of potential, honestly.

1. Batman Refusing to Kill the Joker

For decades, the Joker has been responsible for countless deaths. Batman always manages to stop him, but refuses to kill him, even though doing so would end the cycle of violence. This strict moral code, while defining Batman, ironically allows the Joker to continue his killing spree. Gotham suffers repeatedly as Batman remains fixated on his principles, and his dedication to morality becomes an all-consuming obsession.

What once made Batman admirable – his carefulness – now seems like a failure to act. His unwillingness to compromise his strict moral code has tragically harmed the innocent people he swore to protect. Despite his intelligence and skills, Batman’s rigid morality is arguably DC’s biggest and most damaging flaw.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/list/7-darkest-dc-comics-thatll-stick-with-you/embed/#

2026-02-03 20:20