2019’s Creepiest Horror Movie Finally Returns to Streaming (And ‘90s Kids Are Still Scared Of It)

by

The 1990s were a fantastic time for horror fans, especially kids! Growing up, many remember being spooked by books like R.L. Stine’s *Goosebumps* and Alvin Schwartz’s *In a Dark, Dark Room and Other Scary Stories*, and iconic shows and movies such as *It*, *Are You Afraid of the Dark?*, and *Hocus Pocus*. Now, over twenty years later, a 2019 horror film brought those childhood fears to life, scaring a new generation – and it’s available to stream again if you dare.

As a big fan of spooky stories, I was thrilled when André Øvredal’s take on *Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark* hit Peacock on September 1st. The movie follows a group of teenagers who find a book full of terrifying tales in a creepy, old house. Things get really intense when they realize the stories aren’t just *about* scary things – they start *living* them! It was a huge success when it came out, making over $105 million worldwide, and critics really liked it too – it earned a ‘Certified Fresh’ rating on Rotten Tomatoes with a 78% score. Guillermo del Toro produced it, which definitely added to the appeal!

Why You Should Watch Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark

The movie *Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark* is based on the popular and frightening children’s book series by Alvin Schwartz, with illustrations by Stephen Gammell, that haunted many kids growing up. The film effectively adapts Schwartz’s spooky tales into a single, connected story, capturing the same suspense, darkness, and deep-seated fear found in the original books. It also pays tribute to Gammell’s unforgettable artwork by bringing characters like the Jangly Man, Harold the Scarecrow, and the Pale Lady to life with incredibly realistic special effects and makeup, staying true to their terrifying appearances from the books.

What *Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark* does best is appeal to everyone. Fans of the original books will love the nostalgic and fun experience, and newcomers will enjoy it just as much. It’s a great starting point for those new to horror, balancing genuinely creepy moments with effective, but not overly graphic, scares. The engaging story and relatable characters make it a horror movie the whole family can enjoy.

New Halloween Season Additions on Peacock

If you’re looking for a spooky movie night this Halloween, Peacock has you covered! Along with *Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark*, you can now stream the family-friendly horror film *Goosebumps* (2015). It joined a lineup of other chilling movies that started streaming September 1st, including classics like *The Birds*, *The Haunting in Connecticut*, and *The Sixth Sense*. Plus, you’ll find films from popular horror franchises like *Amityville Horror*, *Child’s Play*, and *Halloween*.

Peacock will be adding a bunch of scary movies next month, just in time for Halloween! Starting in October, you’ll be able to stream the first three *Scream* films, along with favorites like *Poltergeist*, *Don’t Breathe*, and *The Ring*, and other spooky titles.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/90s-horror-movies-traumatizing-candyman-it-scream/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-21 01:14