Warning: This article contains spoilers from the One Piece manga! The One Piece manga is currently exploring the exciting Elbaf Arc, which is revealing the full story behind the God Valley Incident. Previously thought to have been started by Rocks D. Xebec, the incident was actually a carefully planned trap *for* him, orchestrated by the World Government. While Xebec has been mentioned before, the Elbaf Arc properly introduces him and also reveals he’s Blackbeard’s father. As the details of the incident and Xebec’s family history become clearer, one popular character has turned out to be somewhat disappointing. Garp has long been a fan favorite, even though his actions during the Summit War-specifically, not fully defending Portgas D. Ace before his death-were controversial.
As a huge fan of this series, I’ve always been fascinated by Garp! It’s expected of him, as a Marine officer, to always do what’s right – even if it means making incredibly tough choices, like prioritizing justice over family, even when it comes to his grandson. And let me tell you, he’s *powerful* – seriously, people used to put him on the same level as Gol D. Roger himself! What’s cool is that, even though he’s a Marine, he’s not nearly as ruthless as someone like Akainu, which is probably why he’s so popular with fans. But honestly, his actions back in God Valley were really troubling. They made me question his morality and whether he truly deserves the title of Marine Hero. It’s a complicated legacy, for sure!
Garp May Not Be As Good As One Piece Fans Initially Thought
After the God Valley Incident, Monkey D. Garp earned the title of Marine Hero by defeating Xebec. The World Government kept secret the fact that Garp teamed up with Roger to defeat the famous pirate. But now that the truth is out, it’s clear the entire incident was actually the World Government’s mistake, and Xebec was actually the victim. The Government has a history of underhanded tactics, disregarding the well-being of innocent people. They proved this by threatening an entire island-including Xebec’s wife and young son, who was only two years old-simply to capture him.
Having witnessed the power of the World Government, Garp hasn’t followed in his son Dragon’s footsteps by protecting those in need. He doesn’t require leaving the Marines to have an impact, but he’s noticeably different from someone like Admiral Fujitora. Garp possesses a sense of justice, though its true nature remains unclear. He showed no reaction upon hearing about the dreadful Native Hunting Competition in God Valley. Yet, he eagerly accepted the challenge to fight Roger and Xebec, rushing to the island immediately.
While the pirates were on the island attempting a rescue of Shakky and Xebec’s family, the World Nobles were engaged in hunting people purely for their own amusement. Seeing a massacre like that would horrify most people, but Garp remained focused solely on the pirates, not even pausing to consider the victims. This behavior might be understandable coming from someone like Akainu, who follows the World Government without question, but it’s shocking coming from Garp, a man widely respected as a Hero.
Garp Nurtured the Next Generation of Marines, But Has He Done Enough for the World?
Expecting Garp to challenge the Celestial Dragons independently might seem unrealistic, but nearly four decades have passed since the relevant event, and he hasn’t taken any steps to reform the system. Although refusing the position of Admiral is commendable – avoiding being controlled by the World Nobles is understandable – Garp still hasn’t achieved anything truly significant. Individuals like Sengoku, Akainu, and Kizaru are invested in maintaining the Government’s authority and desire the world to conform to their vision.
While figures like Fujitora and Dragon are working to stop the oppression and injustice, they approach the problem in different ways. Garp doesn’t quite fit with either side; he’s critical of the World Government but doesn’t actively oppose it. His decision not to save Ace was understandable, as despite vowing to protect Roger’s son, Ace ultimately became a pirate. Garp suppressed his own emotions and allowed Ace to face the consequences, believing that fate was appropriate for a pirate.
However, the people enslaved and native to God Valley were clearly innocent of any wrongdoing. Despite all his strength, Garp’s most impressive accomplishment is perhaps training promising young Marines like Koby, who are destined for great things. He even traveled to Hachinosu to rescue Koby, an act that earned him the admiration of many. Nevertheless, it’s hard to ignore the fact that someone as powerful as Garp could have done even more to help the world. His motivations remain a mystery, and while he’s undoubtedly charismatic, the God Valley Incident forces us to question whether he truly deserves the title of Hero.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
https://comicbook.com/anime/news/one-piece-just-settled-a-decades-long-power-debate-for-good/embed/#
Read More
- FC 26 reveals free preview mode and 10 classic squads
- Hazbin Hotel season 3 release date speculation and latest news
- Dancing With The Stars Fans Want Terri Irwin To Compete, And Robert Irwin Shared His Honest Take
- Jujutsu Kaisen Execution Delivers High-Stakes Action and the Most Shocking Twist of the Series (Review)
- Where Winds Meet: Best Weapon Combinations
- Red Dead Redemption Remaster Error Prevents Xbox Players from Free Upgrade
- Meet the cast of Mighty Nein: Every Critical Role character explained
- Is There a Smiling Friends Season 3 Episode 9 Release Date or Part 2?
- Walking Towards State Estimation: A New Boundary Condition Approach
- Where Winds Meet: How To Defeat Shadow Puppeteer (Boss Guide)
2025-10-01 18:13