3 Awful Horror Remakes That Should Never Have Existed

by

Remaking a movie is always a challenge, and it’s especially tricky when dealing with horror. Some remakes successfully modernize classic films while still capturing what made the originals great – think of movies like *IT*, *Nosferatu*, and *The Fly*. But often, remakes prove that some films are best left untouched. Hollywood loves revisiting popular franchises, but sometimes the results are terrible, due to poor decisions, bad acting, or simply a lack of demand. And when a horror remake fails, it usually fails spectacularly, becoming infamous for all the wrong reasons.

Horror movies rely on creating a creepy mood, building tension slowly, and hinting at scares rather than showing them outright. When these elements are missing, the movie just doesn’t work. Here are three horror remakes that completely miss the mark.

3) A Nightmare on Elm Street

Any attempt to remake *A Nightmare on Elm Street* needs a strong justification. The original film by Wes Craven remains effective, and this remake demonstrates that some classics are best left untouched. While the story – teenagers terrorized in their dreams by a disfigured killer – is familiar, the remake feels uninspired. It aims for a grittier, more realistic feel, but loses the unique personality, humor, and, crucially, the captivating presence that Robert Englund brought to the role of the villain.

The attempt to revive Freddy Krueger isn’t inherently bad, but this remake fundamentally misunderstands what made the character frightening. By trying to explain Freddy’s origins and ‘deepen’ his backstory, the movie actually diminishes his scariness – he was most effective as an inexplicable nightmare. Beyond that, the kills feel unoriginal, the scares are telegraphed, and the movie’s overall look is bland. It’s an easily forgotten remake that wasn’t needed and hasn’t found any defenders.

2) Psycho

As a huge Hitchcock fan, I was horrified when I heard they were remaking *Psycho*. It’s such a perfect film, I just couldn’t understand why anyone would try! And honestly, it was a terrible idea. The remake basically copied the original shot-for-shot, feeling more like a student film with a big budget than a worthy successor. The story is the same – Marion Crane steals money and winds up at the creepy Bates Motel run by Norman Bates – but it just doesn’t *feel* right. They included the famous shower scene and everything, but it lacked all the suspense and impact of the original. It just felt…pointless.

The biggest problem with this movie is that it doesn’t offer anything new or interesting. It’s a simple retread of the original, lacking any creative spark or worthwhile effort. The acting is weaker, and it feels like everyone is going through the motions in a dull imitation. Instead of being frightening, it’s just awkward. While intended as a respectful homage, it completely misses the point of what a tribute should be. In fact, most people have already forgotten it exists. At this point, the *Bates Motel* television series is the closest fans will get to a successful continuation of this story.

1) The Wicker Man

As a horror fan, I have to say the remake of *The Wicker Man* is in a league of its own… but not in a good way! The original is a truly creepy, smart film that builds tension perfectly and stays with you long after it ends. The remake, though? It’s just… a mess. It tries to follow the same story, but everything that made the original great is completely lost. What should be a suspenseful horror movie quickly turns into something unintentionally hilarious. They missed the whole point of the original – the interesting conflict between belief systems, the unsettling questions it raises, and how powerless the main character feels. It’s just a really disappointing take on a classic.

The movie follows police officer Edward Malus (Nicolas Cage) as he investigates a missing girl on a secluded island, discovering it’s controlled by a group of women who worship nature. While the premise has potential and the film aims for seriousness, it’s difficult for the audience to do the same. The result is chaotic, filled with exaggerated acting, a confusing plot, and a complete lack of suspense. The mystery unfolds slowly without building any tension, and the intended shocking climax falls flat, becoming unintentionally funny. This remake is a failure and proves that some films are better left untouched.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/horror-movies-1980s-remakes-wishlist/embed/#

Read More

2025-10-17 03:10