3 Forgotten Horrors From the 2000s That Are Still Scary Today

The 2000s were a diverse era in horror cinema, challenging straightforward categorization. Notably, many films claimed to be based on real events, a trend that had begun in the ’70s, but gained momentum during this period. The Blair Witch Project was a pivotal movie in this trend, sparking numerous other “found footage” films. However, some of the decade’s significant contributions to the genre seem to have faded from public memory.

In essence, there are three films here that, while they had varying financial success initially, aren’t widely recognized on a broad scale today. Though they have their devoted fanbases, it’s likely that the majority of people in 2025 would be unaware of these movies, given they were not so recently released.

3) Frailty

The surprising twist in the movie “Frailty” is just one of many compelling aspects of its storyline. The narrative centers around the Meiks family, comprised of Adam, Fenton, and their father, whom we simply know as Dad (played by Bill Paxton). Dad is a troubled individual who firmly believes that he’s been instructed by God to eliminate ‘demons’, who interestingly appear indistinguishable from ordinary humans. As an adult, Fenton (portrayed by Matthew McConaughey) recounts the murders committed by his father to an FBI agent. While Fenton was initially repulsed by these acts as a child, Adam showed no such revulsion and has continued down this disturbing path that was set by their father.

Throughout the entire film, we tend to assume that the father’s condition is mental instability, and his ability to gain psychic insights into others’ past misdeeds was simply a byproduct of this. When Adam claims to share these visions, we suspect he’s either trying to appease his father or merely exhibiting an overactive imagination typical of children. However, it’s revealed later that what both father and son perceived was indeed genuine. As the father had foretold, Fenton did evolve into a serial killer, but not one who preys on demons; instead, he targeted ordinary, innocent people.

In addition, the man facing off against the FBI officer is not Fenton, it’s Adam. Adam murdered Fenton because he had been prophesied as a serial killer, and now he’s here to deal with the FBI agent who was responsible for taking away the family’s matriarch originally. It’s quite a complex sequence of events, but it unfolds in a straightforward fashion. Interestingly, this was an outstanding directorial debut for Paxton, who tragically only directed one other (very distinct) film before his untimely death.

Stream Frailty on fuboTV.

2) Wolf Creek

The movie “Wolf Creek,” set in Australia, is remarkably raw and unsettling, earning it an unusually low CinemaScore of “F.” This film, with its unflinching realism, revolves around three backpackers navigating the outback. Their journey continues from Broome to Cairns, a distance too vast to walk comfortably, leading them to buy a car that appears to be near its end. Unfortunately, the vehicle’s poor appearance is not indicative of its reliability, and it breaks down during their stop at Wolf Creek National Park. Their luck seems to change when they encounter Mick Taylor, who offers to fix their car, but as he continues to speak, his words become increasingly questionable. To make matters worse, his seemingly harmless threats disguised as jokes are more alarming than amusing.

Mick, the cinematic monster, is exceptionally chilling due to his authenticity. Unlike typical characters, he’s not just a figment of someone’s imagination – he’s a real man who takes pleasure in killing. This isn’t your average movie with a tidy resolution; instead, it presents violence candidly, featuring characters that are more complex than stereotypes. The film often feels less like a movie and more like a snapshot of reality, which is made even more unsettling by its claim to be based on true events.

While the movie isn’t entirely fabricated, as it was influenced by two distinct backpacker murder cases, the phrase “based on true events” serves more to unsettle the audience than it does to state actual facts. This technique is quite powerful. No filmic violence seems as shocking as something that resembles our own reality, and for evidence, look no further than the similarly overlooked and forgotten British movie, Eden Lake.

Stream Wolf Creek on Prime Video.

1) Quarantine

As a fervent admirer, I’d like to draw attention to a relatively unsung found footage horror gem – the remake of ‘Quarantine’, which, while arguably overshadowed by its Spanish predecessor ‘[Rec]’, offers an immersive, claustrophobic spin on the zombie genre. I found myself in the shoes of Jennifer Carpenter’s character, Angela Vidal, a reporter who, along with her camera operator, is documenting a report about the L.A. Fire Department. Little did we know that our ride-along would lead us to an apartment building teeming with residents. However, this was no ordinary evening for a fire department visit; the building’s occupants were on the brink of a horrifying outbreak, a particularly virulent strain of rabies.

After the sensation that Paranormal Activity created as a landmark film, Quarantine was somewhat overlooked when it was released. Strangely enough, Quarantine outshines Paranormal Activity for me. Though it doesn’t possess the nerve-wracking “Is this really happening?” atmosphere that amplified the fear in the other film, it excels in better acting and shares a similarly grim and depressing ending. As a movie enthusiast who enjoys being immersed in the horror genre, I find Quarantine to be a more satisfying watch.

Rent Quarantine on Amazon Video.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/creepy-horror-movies-underrated-amityville-motel-hell-basket-case/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-06 02:40