3 Great Underrated Supernatural Horror Movies You’ll Regret Not Watching

by

When you think of supernatural horror, films like The Exorcist, Poltergeist, The Conjuring, The Witch, Paranormal Activity, and Hereditary immediately come to mind – and it’s easy to get caught up in those well-known titles. But if you’re looking for something a little different, or just want to explore beyond the usual suspects, there are many fantastic, lesser-known horror films worth checking out. These movies often create tension and psychological impact through atmosphere and suggestion, rather than jump scares or special effects, focusing on building fear through what you feel and imagine.

Here are three fantastic supernatural movies that don’t get enough attention. You may or may not be familiar with them, but they offer a unique and refreshing take on the genre – definitely worth watching if you’re looking for something different!

3) Saint Maud

Many people consider Saint Maud underrated, and for good reason. It doesn’t follow the typical formula of most supernatural horror films. Rather than relying on cheap thrills or a detailed backstory, the movie focuses on Maud, a deeply lonely nurse who finds intense solace in religion after a difficult experience. She becomes convinced she’s meant to save the soul of her dying patient. What makes the film truly disturbing is that the story largely takes place within Maud’s own mind, leaving the audience questioning whether what they’re seeing is a genuine spiritual event or a sign of a mental health crisis.

Many films blur the line between reality and fantasy, but Saint Maud deliberately avoids offering easy answers, which might not appeal to everyone. It’s a small, intensely personal, and often shocking film that focuses on the damaging effects of unwavering belief rather than relying on typical horror villains. The true horror comes from within Maud herself, not from any outside threat. What sets it apart is its powerful use of the supernatural to explore themes of inner turmoil and self-destruction, without resorting to obvious metaphors or heavy-handed explanations. Plus, Morfydd Clark’s performance is genuinely one of the most unsettling in a horror film in recent years.

2) The Blackcoat’s Daughter

If you enjoy the unsettling atmosphere of films by Osgood Perkins, you’ll find The Blackcoat’s Daughter immediately gripping—and deliberately uncomfortable. It demands your full attention and doesn’t offer easy answers. The story centers on two students, Kat and Rose, who are left alone at their Catholic boarding school over the winter break. Later, a third young woman, Joan, arrives. What initially seems like three separate narratives gradually weaves together, revealing hidden connections. While the basic idea is straightforward, the film masterfully builds a sense of dread through long silences, stark visuals, and a non-linear storyline that challenges the viewer to connect the dots.

This movie is overlooked because it’s not a typical horror film – it doesn’t hold your hand or rush the story. The Blackcoat’s Daughter respects its viewers, trusting them to follow a more subtle approach. While unsettling events and an evil presence are present, they aren’t presented as flashy or sensationalized; instead, they feel tragic and unavoidable, making them truly frightening. The movie’s power comes not from sudden shocks, but from the chilling realization of what’s actually unfolding. It’s a slow-burn horror that builds dread through patience and atmosphere, and those who enjoy atmospheric, supernatural stories will find it deeply effective.

1) Lake Mungo

Lake Mungo isn’t for everyone, and that’s intentional. It’s not a typical horror movie; it’s designed for viewers who appreciate thought-provoking stories with a strong atmosphere and a subtle approach to the supernatural. Instead of jump scares and obvious thrills, the film creates unease through a documentary-style presentation. It follows a family grieving the drowning of their daughter, Alice, and as they review photos, videos, and share their experiences, strange things begin to surface. While it seems like a ghost story, the film isn’t about proving the existence of ghosts. It’s a powerful exploration of grief and the void left behind by loss.

What sets Lake Mungo apart – and makes it both easy to miss and difficult to forget – is how subtle it is. It doesn’t rely on jump scares or big reveals. Instead, the horror gradually builds through seemingly ordinary details that become increasingly powerful. The film portrays the supernatural as a part of the grieving process, rather than the focus of it, and that’s what makes it so effective. It’s the kind of movie that stays with you, precisely because it feels so realistic.

Have you seen any of these movies, or are you planning to? Share your thoughts in the comments below and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/creepy-horror-movies-underrated-amityville-motel-hell-basket-case/embed/#

Read More

2026-01-10 02:10