3 Most Painful Horror Movie Failures I’ll Never Get Over

by

I’m a big horror fan, so I tend to have strong reactions to movies in established horror franchises – I either really enjoy them, or I’m very let down. The following three films definitely fall into the latter category. They had promising ideas and could have been great, but ultimately they didn’t deliver on their potential. While they weren’t expected to be flawless, they had elements that could have really resonated with viewers if the movies had been executed better.

These shows sometimes followed big successes, sometimes featured a popular actor, and occasionally relied on a unique twist. Some had a mix of these things. But no matter what, they didn’t live up to expectations – and you likely felt the same way.

3) A Nightmare on Elm Street (2010)

Wes Craven’s *A Nightmare on Elm Street* was a truly original and unforgettable movie of the 1980s. While several sequels followed, only *A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors* came anywhere near matching its quality. The others weren’t nearly as good.

The 2010 remake of *A Nightmare on Elm Street* was particularly disappointing. It looked like a low-budget music video from the early 2000s, with uninspired acting and weak special effects. The effects were so poor that even Freddy Krueger himself didn’t look scary—he resembled a wrinkled, computer-generated fish. I had hoped for more, as Jackie Earle Haley is a talented actor and Platinum Dunes’ *Friday the 13th* remake was surprisingly good. However, Haley was given terrible lines, and this film relied too heavily on repeating scenes from the original, which never works. Unfortunately, that’s exactly what happened here.

Stream A Nightmare on Elm Street (2010) on HBO Max.

2) Jaws 3

Most people agree that the *Jaws* series likely should have stopped after the first movie. While *Jaws 2* is generally considered good, the subsequent films are difficult to enjoy, even for big fans of the original.

Both *Jaws 3-D* and *Jaws: The Revenge* had potential, but ultimately didn’t deliver. *Jaws 3-D* had a fun idea – a shark loose in SeaWorld and even some cheesy 80s 3-D effects aimed at the audience – but the execution fell flat. The shark barely attacked anyone, and the 3-D effects weren’t scary, just silly. As for *Jaws: The Revenge*, a movie about a shark that supposedly communicates telepathically shouldn’t be so incredibly dull.

Stream Jaws 3 on Netflix.

1) Scream 3

Okay, so I’ll be honest, I’ve been a little let down by three of the *Scream* movies. I remember seeing *Scream 4* in theaters when I was a freshman in college – the experience itself was fun, but I didn’t really dig how polished and bright it looked. *Scream VI* was…fine, honestly. I went in expecting a lot, and it just didn’t quite deliver. But I genuinely loved the 2022 *Scream*! I thought it was a smart move to introduce a new cast and bring Ghostface to a big city setting. Plus, I’m a huge Samara Weaving fan, and I was thrilled to see her join a major slasher franchise, even though I had a feeling she wouldn’t last long – and I was right! Overall, it’s a good movie, but it doesn’t really stick with me after I’ve watched it.

Despite its strengths, *Scream 3* remains the weakest film in the series, and it’s easy to see why. Ideally, the movie should have been postponed until original writer Kevin Williamson could have returned. More significantly, the film’s tone was changed following the Columbine High School tragedy. While a fearful response to such a terrible event was understandable, it led to a final installment that felt hesitant and restrained. The identity of the killer is also quite obvious halfway through, and this is confirmed when that character, Roman Bridger, is killed off-screen. Parker Posey delivers a great performance, but she’s really the only highlight of the film.

Stream Scream 3 on Hulu.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/screams-best-sequel-hid-one-of-the-worst-scenes-in-the-entire-30-year-franchise/embed/#

Read More

2025-10-18 22:13