3 Times the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants Were Better Heroes Than the X-Men

The Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, often called simply the Brotherhood, is a group of mutants who have consistently opposed the X-Men since the beginning. Unlike Xavier’s students, they believe humanity is the core of the world’s problems. Originally formed by Magneto, the Brotherhood aimed for world dominance and a solution to what they saw as the ‘human problem.’ Over time, the Brotherhood has had several different lineups, but they all share the belief that humans are a threat.

Even though they started as villains, the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants has surprisingly done a lot of good, sometimes even more than the X-Men. This proves that a group originally formed with destructive intentions can evolve and become a force for good, benefiting both mutants and humans. The Brotherhood demonstrates that even those labeled as villains are capable of kindness and can occasionally surpass the heroes traditionally tasked with saving the world.

Saved Xavier

I’ve always been so impressed by Professor Charles Xavier – he’s really the heart and soul of the X-Men, having guided and taught every single one of them. There was this one storyline that really got me – Professor X was actually kidnapped! It was heartbreaking to see the team scrambling to find him. But things got even more complicated because Cerebro, his powerful machine, started thinking for itself, making the search so much harder for them. It was a really tense and emotional arc, seeing the X-Men trying to rescue their mentor against such a strange obstacle.

The Brotherhood of Mutants rescued Xavier from whoever was holding him captive, succeeding where the X-Men had failed. Xavier then took on a leadership role within the Brotherhood, and they began assisting the X-Men. This rescue was a turning point for the Brotherhood, helping them gain a reputation as heroes.

Freedom Force

As a longtime fan, I’ve always found Mystique fascinating. She’s such a chameleon, and sometimes she’ll even take charge of the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, totally changing how they operate. The most interesting time was when she reformed them into the Freedom Force, a group that actually tried to be heroes! It didn’t really pan out for them, but I always appreciated that attempt. We see the X-Men constantly fighting for what’s right and being selfless, and it was cool to see Mystique’s crew try that, even if it was a bit twisted.

The Freedom Force is effective because the Brotherhood of Mutants, despite their flaws, genuinely tries to do what’s right. While their efforts haven’t gone as planned, they are at least attempting to be heroes.

Havok Tricks Dark Beast

Havok once assembled a team called the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, though he simply referred to it as the Brotherhood. Surprisingly, this wasn’t about *doing* evil; it was a clever plan to catch a dangerous villain. Havok was determined to stop Dark Beast, who was causing a lot of problems, and formed the group as a way to lure him in.

The hero surprisingly used the villainous group to achieve justice, transforming the Brotherhood into a force for good. This demonstrates that the Brotherhood of Mutants is capable of positive change and doesn’t have to be defined by evil.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-greatest-x-men-villains-magneto-apocalypse-mystique-sabretooth/embed/#

Read More

2025-10-16 00:42