4 Great Games That Had Very Divisive Endings (One Had to Be Completely Redone)

by

Many amazing gaming adventures are unfortunately spoiled by disappointing endings that leave players feeling let down. All the time spent discovering the game world, connecting with characters, and making choices that shape the story can be completely undermined by a frustrating final act. When a game fails to deliver a satisfying conclusion after everything, it can turn a favorite title into a source of real disappointment. This frustration is even worse when you’ve invested months, or even years, following the story closely, only to be met with an ending that feels unearned. Endings are crucial, and a failed ending can have a lasting negative impact, extending far beyond the game’s credits or any review score.

Even highly praised games can stumble when it comes to their endings. If the finale doesn’t live up to the experience of playing, it can ruin everything that happened before, leaving fans wondering if it was worth their time. Some players might try to find reasons to accept the ending or search for deeper meaning, but they often remain disappointed. It’s a truly frustrating feeling, and it can take a long time to get over a disappointing ending to a story you loved. A well-built story can be completely undermined by a weak conclusion, and these games perfectly illustrate just how damaging that can be.

4. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3’s ending sparked widespread frustration among gamers. After investing years in Commander Shepard’s journey and influencing the galaxy’s destiny, the final decisions felt unsatisfying. Despite everything players had accomplished, the ending remained largely the same, diminishing the importance of all the choices and connections made throughout the three games. Many fans felt that the detailed story and well-developed characters were ignored, creating a sense of disappointment from BioWare, a studio famous for delivering satisfying conclusions. The issue wasn’t simply the ending itself, but how it diminished the value of the entire trilogy.

BioWare attempted to address the negative reaction with the Extended Cut DLC, offering more background and choices. Although this provided some explanation, it couldn’t fully overcome the disappointment many felt. A lot of players believed the ending didn’t acknowledge the time and emotional connection they had invested, ultimately turning a much-loved trilogy into an example of how to *not* end a story. The very need for an “Extended Cut” was particularly frustrating, suggesting the original conclusion hadn’t been carefully considered. Even with the extra content and clarifications, the finale didn’t live up to the high stakes and impactful consequences established throughout the series. Mass Effect 3’s ending continues to be a prime example of a controversial finale, and it still generates debate today.

3. Outriders

Outriders was a thrilling game to play, offering quick, action-packed battles and a fascinating world to discover. However, the storyline often didn’t live up to the excitement of the gameplay, and the ending felt rushed. It seemed less like a satisfying conclusion and more like the beginning of another story, with many characters and plot threads left hanging. A lot of players were left asking why the narrative felt like it was building to something that never actually happened. The game’s world had a lot of promise and mystery, but the story didn’t quite fulfill that potential, and it likely won’t at this stage.

The abrupt ending only made players more frustrated. The game hinted at intriguing secrets and much bigger problems, but none of these were resolved properly. The conclusion expands the world in a promising way, making it feel like the adventure is just beginning, but then the credits suddenly roll. Understandably, players were left with unanswered questions and the feeling that their time was not well spent. The ending created a disappointing feeling that stayed with them even after they stopped playing. Outriders shows how crucial a fulfilling story conclusion is, regardless of how well the gameplay works.

2. Final Fantasy XVI

Final Fantasy XVI delivered a story that was both gritty and emotionally charged, brimming with political schemes and characters facing difficult personal battles. The initial parts of the game expertly built a complex world of nations, partnerships, and power plays, hinting at a story centered around human desires and clashes. Unfortunately, as the narrative unfolded, it increasingly emphasized gods and mythical creatures – a pattern often seen in the Final Fantasy series. This change diminished the impact of the promising political setup, leaving many players feeling let down that the story they’d become invested in was replaced with standard fantasy elements. The ending felt hurried, and key emotional scenes didn’t quite resonate, which was a letdown for fans who had followed Clive’s story and the destiny of Valisthea.

The ending felt even more disappointing because it strayed so far from the compelling political and personal stories that started the game. The early demo led players to believe Final Fantasy XVI would explore the everyday lives and struggles of people, instead of focusing on grand, cosmic events. Sadly, that turned out to be untrue. Although some appreciated the bold storytelling choices, many felt the ending didn’t live up to the promising start and rich character development, leaving fans frustrated that a game with so much potential faltered at the very end. The unsatisfying conclusion and sudden shift to a conflict with “God” continue to fuel discussions about Final Fantasy XVI, even well after its release.

1. The Last of Us Part II

The Last of Us Part II dared to tell a very risky story, centering on themes of revenge and difficult moral choices. However, the ending proved divisive, leaving many players disappointed, especially considering how much they’d connected with Ellie in the first game. After investing hours in the characters’ journeys, the finale presented consequences that felt harsh instead of rewarding. Ellie endured significant suffering caused by Abby, the game’s main antagonist, and was ultimately given the chance to fully retaliate. Yet, at the very end, Ellie decides that seeking revenge would only perpetuate the cycle of violence, and she lets Abby go. This happened despite Abby having already taken everything Ellie held dear. While the message was positive, it didn’t resonate with most fans, who felt the emotional impact of the story was lessened by the conclusion. The ending sparked intense discussion and disagreement, making it one of the most memorable and debated finales in recent gaming history.

As a fan, the biggest takeaway for me was how tricky it is to walk the line between a really bold story and actually frustrating your audience. The game definitely made me *feel* things, but honestly, the ending just didn’t feel earned after everything we went through. A lot of people felt betrayed, like the story didn’t give us the resolution we’d been building towards – that seems to be the main issue with the narrative. It’s still a huge topic of conversation, which just shows that even games everyone loves can stumble if the ending doesn’t live up to the time and effort we put in, and our expectations.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

Read More

2025-10-04 00:15