4 Reasons Robert Pattinson’s Batman Shouldn’t Team-Up With the DCU’s Superman

by

With the arrival of James Gunn’s Superman and the beginning of the new DC Universe, many fans are curious if David Corenswet’s Superman will ever meet Robert Pattinson’s Batman. Pattinson’s Batman, first seen in Matt Reeves’s The Batman (2022), exists in its own separate world, distinct from both the new DCU and the previous DC Extended Universe. Although Robert Pattinson doesn’t appear in the TV series The Penguin (2024), he is scheduled to return as Bruce Wayne in The Batman Part II (2027). At the same time, Superman and other upcoming DC projects like Supergirl, Clayface, and Lanterns are building Gunn’s new cinematic universe, which will also include its own version of Batman. While Gunn has stated Pattinson’s Batman won’t be part of the DCU, some fans are still eager to see these two worlds come together.

Both Pattinson and Corenswet deliver excellent performances in their respective roles; however, bringing their characters together on screen isn’t necessarily a good plan. Here are four reasons why a crossover featuring Pattinson’s Batman and Corenswet’s Superman in the DCU would be a mistake.

4) The DC Universe Needs to Feel New

Superman marks a successful start to the DCU, offering a fresh beginning after a long period of underwhelming films from the DCEU. The story is full of warmth and optimism, and Superman eagerly explores its setting, showcasing both the relatable, human side of Clark Kent and his extraordinary heroism. From the bustling city of Metropolis to the iconic Fortress of Solitude, the DCU’s debut film skillfully builds a world that feels authentic and believable.

As a huge DC fan, I really think every future installment in the DCU needs to build on the incredible momentum of this fresh start. I’d love to see them really expand the world, and I think a totally new take on Gotham City – something different from what we’ve seen in The Batman and The Penguin – would be fantastic. Bringing in Pattinson’s Batman feels like it could really take away from the excitement and originality of Gunn’s vision for a connected universe. While adding Gunn’s Peacemaker series to the DCU isn’t perfect, crossing it over with The Batman would just create even more confusion, honestly.

3) The Batman Universe Is Brilliant As Is

Compared to previous Batman movies, The Batman really emphasizes the harshness of Gotham City and how skilled Batman is at solving mysteries. After just one film and an eight-episode TV series, this new universe feels detailed and full of interesting people, such as Selina Kyle/Catwoman (Zoë Kravitz), Oz Cobb/Penguin (Colin Farrell), and Sofia Falcone (Cristin Milioti). A major strength of both The Batman and The Penguin is how realistic and captivating Gotham City seems. Whether Batman is around or not, the streets are full of both danger and everyday life. Beyond their stunning visuals, The Batman and its spin-off series offer compelling stories, boosted by impressive action sequences, strong character dynamics, and unexpected turns.

These stories go far beyond simple tales of heroes and villains. They deeply explore characters who aren’t clearly good or bad, and how the difficult environment of Gotham City has affected them. The Batman and The Penguin create a powerful combination, and their success suggests exciting possibilities for The Batman Part II and future installments. It’s best not to disrupt what’s working by combining Reeves’s world with the DCU, which could jeopardize The Batman’s quality. Instead, DC should focus on further developing its characters and adding new Batman-related figures within its current storyline. By keeping The Batman separate, DC can build on its established strengths without rushing into a Superman crossover and potentially damaging everything.

2) The Tonal Disparity Between The Batman and Superman Is Too Great

The Batman and Superman are very different. The Batman is dark and serious, while Superman is generally more upbeat and fun. James Gunn’s movie does have genuine moments, so combining it with the world of The Batman isn’t out of the question. However, bringing Robert Pattinson’s Batman and David Corenswet’s Superman together could dilute what makes each of their universes special. It would be a challenge to blend The Batman‘s somber mood and intense action with Superman‘s lightheartedness and comedic style.

While some viewers might enjoy the chaotic mix this concept could create, combining such different creative approaches isn’t a good idea. Not every project and hero in the DCU needs to have the same comedic style as Superman, but they should still feel connected enough to realistically exist in the same world. The Batman just doesn’t fit that requirement.

1) Giving Into Fans’ Wishes Wouldn’t Bode Well for the DCU

As a fan, I’ve been hearing a lot about whether Robert Pattinson’s Batman will join James Gunn’s new DCU. Gunn has been pretty direct about it, though. He said there’s always a small chance, but it’s really not likely. He told Rolling Stone back in June that it wasn’t something he was planning. Even with all the buzz after Superman came out, and fans hoping to see Pattinson’s Batman included, I don’t think it’ll change Gunn’s plans. Honestly, I’d be a little worried if he *did* change course just because of fan requests. A good franchise needs to stick to its vision and focus on being creative and delivering quality, and constantly giving fans exactly what they ask for rarely leads to something truly great.

Recently, the Guardians of the Galaxy director is collaborating with a writer to create a new version of Batman, distinct from the Dark Knight seen in The Batman. While this new DCU Batman may face a challenge in comparison to Robert Pattinson’s performance, that won’t be a problem if the DCU as a whole is successful. The key to maintaining the strong identity of both universes is to continue with the current plan of keeping them separate.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/superman-actors-ranked-worst-best-live-action/embed/#

Read More

2025-10-03 23:53