5 Best Shows to Binge on Peacock in September 2025

by

In a sea of streaming services, Peacock shines brightly as a treasure among many. Emerging in the midst of the ongoing streaming battlefield in 2020, Peacock offers its subscribers an expansive library boasting over 80,000 hours of movies and TV episodes from NBCUniversal’s vast collection, including shows from Bravo and Telemundo. It also features new and classic films, live sports, and a plethora of other content to keep viewers entertained. With new titles added monthly, Peacock’s catalog continues to grow, offering numerous must-see additions each month. As we move into September 2025, we have handpicked the crème de la crème of TV shows to keep you hooked on Peacock.

In September 2025, I’m excited to say that Peacock is set to blend the familiar with the new, as some beloved series return and fresh titles make their grand entrance. Ranging from a sizzling reality show to a classic game show, along with the revival of one of NBC’s most iconic shows – these shows will undoubtedly captivate you, leaving you eagerly waiting for the “next episode.” Here are my top five must-watch TV shows streaming on Peacock in September 2025.

5) Brilliant Minds

If you’re craving a medical drama other than Grey’s Anatomy, fear not! Peacock has got you covered with the return of Brilliant Minds, starring Zachary Quinto, coming back for its second season next month on September 23, 2025. The Season 2 premiere will be streaming on Peacock a day after it airs on television. Further episodes will roll out weekly, and fans can catch up with all of Season 1 on Peacock before the show’s comeback. This innovative medical drama is loosely based on Oliver Sacks’ books The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat and An Anthropologist on Mars. The series revolves around Dr. Oliver Wolf, a groundbreaking neurologist who heads a team of brilliant young interns as they delve into the mysteries of the human mind.

Last year, “Brilliant Minds” made a significant impact when it first aired on NBC, standing out as their most-watched new show during the 2024-25 TV season with over 28 million viewers tuning in. The series follows the familiar “case-of-the-week” format and distinguishes itself among other medical dramas by exploring intricate mental health issues and human brain functions. This results in compelling narratives that are both intellectually stimulating and deeply character-driven.

4) Jeopardy!

Prepare to test your trivia skills as Jeopardy! kicks off its new season! For the very first time, this classic and beloved game show will release fresh episodes five days a week on Peacock starting September 9, 2025. Excitingly, fans can start streaming these episodes from that date, with additional viewing options becoming available for the next seven days after each episode’s premiere.

For over six decades, Jeopardy! has captivated audiences with its trivia questions, challenging viewers to answer before the contestants do. One of the longest-running and most-watched game shows on American television, Jeopardy! is enjoyed by people of all ages. With Ken Jennings returning as host in Season 42, which began in 2021 following Alex Trebek’s passing, the show continues to entertain and intrigue fans.

3) Love Island Games

In September, one of the hottest indulgent television series makes its comeback: “Love Island Games”! This intriguing show will debut on Peacock for Season 2 on September 16, 2025, and fans can catch up on all the excitement from Season 1 beforehand since it’s currently streaming. It’s a spin-off of the popular reality dating series “Love Island” that brings back former contestants to a tropical villa for another shot at love and competing for a $100,000 prize money. The contestants for Season 2 are yet to be revealed, but Ariana Madix will reprise her role as host alongside Iain Stirling as the narrator.

The Love Island Games might be considered a indulgent, entertaining choice for television viewing. This program skillfully blends captivating aspects from various reality TV categories, such as the tension-filled dynamics of dating shows and the thrilling, pressure-cooker atmosphere of competition series. With minimal effort required from viewers, it offers a laid-back escape – an experience that often leads to lively discussions with friends about the show’s events.

2) Law & Order: SVU

Olivia Benson, the cherished detective from Law & Order: SVU, is once again tackling cases. The long-running show, created by Dick Wolf, returns for its 27th season this coming September on NBC and Peacock. The series focuses on Benson and the NYPD’s Special Victims Unit, who delve into crimes involving sexual misconduct. The new season, featuring Mariska Hargitay, Ice-T, Peter Scanavino, Kevin Kane, and Kelli Giddish, will be available on Peacock starting September 26, 2025, with fresh episodes being released every week.

The TV show “Law & Order: SVU” is legendary, maintaining its long-lasting popularity through a talented cast, gripping episodes that seamlessly combine police investigation and courtroom drama, and trailblazing treatment of sensitive subjects. This series is highly re-watchable, and before the Season 27 debut, fans can stream all 26 seasons on Peacock.

1) The Paper

22 years on from wrapping up “The Office,” this beloved mockumentary sitcom is getting a reboot! On September 4, 2025, Peacock will debut its much-anticipated spinoff, “The Paper.” All ten episodes of this series, created by Greg Daniels and Michael Koman, will be available to stream on that day. The new show follows the documentary crew from Dunder Mifflin’s Scranton branch in “The Office” as they now focus on a struggling Midwestern newspaper, the Toledo Truth-Teller, and the publisher’s efforts to revive it. As a film enthusiast, I can hardly wait!

Following The Office, one of television’s most iconic sitcoms, comes a new series called The Paper. The original show was a huge success during its NBC run and is fondly remembered for its relatable characters, distinct mockumentary style, and compelling character-driven plots. Now, people are curious to see if The Paper will measure up to the legendary series. By focusing on journalism, the new show promises a modernized and more relevant take on the beloved formula. Although most of the cast is new, Oscar Nuñez returns as Oscar Martinez.

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/peacock-highest-rated-tv-shows-rotten-tomatoes/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-31 17:16