5 Biggest Plot Twists in Video Game History

by

As a gamer, one thing that truly etches a game into my mind is when its storyline takes unexpected turns. The most engaging narrative-driven games have a knack for hooking you in, and once they’ve got you, they blast you with a shocking revelation. Could be the demise of a character or an unanticipated betrayal – those sudden, out-of-nowhere changes are what leave an indelible mark on my gaming experience.

This list showcases gaming experiences primarily centered around storylines, where they often include shocking surprises known as plot twists. While some might be less stunning or memorable compared to others, this compilation solely highlights those games that delivered the most unanticipated narrative swerves. To avoid revealing any secrets, this is a guide for those who prefer to be spoiler-free, offering instead some of the most jaw-dropping plot twists found within the realm of video games.

5) James Finds The Truth About Mary – Silent Hill 2

In the video game titled “Silent Hill 2“, protagonist James encounters a letter that appears to be from his deceased wife, Mary. The letter invites him to Silent Hill where she supposedly awaits him. However, considering Mary has been deceased for quite some time, it’s doubtful she could have sent this message. Yet, due to the similarity in her handwriting and because of James’ curiosity, he decides to venture into the eerie town of Silent Hill. As the story unfolds, James faces hordes of monstrous creatures while his mind keeps questioning how Mary could be present in this haunted place.

The situation continued in much the same manner until toward the end of the game, when James discovered the truth about everything in a shocking revelation. It turned out that Mary had been deceased all along, and it was James who had taken her life. Due to her illness and slow demise, Mary was suffering greatly. Overwhelmed by this burden, and also motivated by mercy, James ended Mary’s life. However, the guilt he felt afterward caused him to suppress these memories until he returned to the town, at which point they resurfaced.

In simpler terms, the monsters in Silent Hill 2 are reflections of James’ inner demons. As he battles the final enemy at the end, his personal journey concludes. The game’s story is known for its incredibly dark and unexpected turns, making it an excellent example of how to effectively use plot twists to create a compelling narrative.

4) Odin Impersonating Tyr – God of War: Ragnarok

In the God of War series, there have been numerous unexpected turns of events, but none as massive as what transpired in Ragnarok. Following the chain of events sparked by Ragnarok, Kratos and Atreus embark on a mission to locate and free Tyr. It was whispered that Odin had locked Tyr away in Svartalfheim. Upon rescuing him, they brought Tyr back to Sindri’s abode and implored his assistance in thwarting Odin.

As a gamer, I’d put it like this: At first, everything seemed peachy during our journey with Kratos and Atreus. But little by little, Tyr started acting shifty, making me think he was trying to hold us back. Things got real intense when we reached Sindri’s place, and guess what? Turned out the Tyr there wasn’t even the real deal! It was none other than Odin himself, posing as Tyr all along. Then, in a shocking twist, Odin stabs Brok right before our eyes, and just like that, he’s gone. That revelation left me speechless and it’s safe to say that this plot twist will go down as one of the biggest surprises in God of War series history.

3) Joel’s Death – The Last of Us Part 2

Contemplate the disappointment experienced by fans who’ve eagerly anticipated a seven-year wait for the second installment of their beloved game, only to find Joel, the main character, brutally murdered at the start. The depth and complexity of Joel’s character in The Last of Us, particularly his heartwarming relationship with Ellie, his protective fatherly role, and his selfless assistance towards others, made him a standout figure in the game. Therefore, the shock waves that echoed around when he was killed off in the opening act of The Last of Us Part 2, were profound.

At the beginning of “The Last of Us Part 2”, Joel unexpectedly crosses paths with a band of survivors. Among them is Abby, who was on a mission to seek retribution for her father’s death – a man Joel had unknowingly killed. The two characters finally meet, and in a shocking turn of events, Abby brutally kills Joel using a club. This plot twist caught everyone off guard, as few predicted that Naughty Dog would eliminate such a cherished character as Joel from the game’s narrative.

The impact of the plot twist in “The Last of Us Part 2” was immense, leading many to express their feelings – whether positive or negative – on Metacritic. Some found the plot itself abhorrent, whereas others applauded Naughty Dog for having the audacity to endearingly terminate a cherished character. The emotion stirred by this twist has been indescribable for many fans; remarkably, some may still harbor resentment towards Naughty Dog over it.

2) The Origami Killer’s Identity – Heavy Rain

In the intriguing narrative of “Heavy Rain,” the enigma lies in discovering the true persona behind the Origami Killer. This elusive figure is responsible for a distinctive method of murder, ensnaring victims within limited spaces and allowing rainwater to accumulate, eventually drowning them. As you navigate through various characters during gameplay, each is on a quest to uncover the killer’s identity. However, when the truth is ultimately disclosed, it leaves an indelible mark as one of the most shocking plot twists in “Heavy Rain.

It turns out that Scott Shelby, one of the characters you can control in the game, is actually the notorious Origami Killer! What makes this revelation surprising is that Shelby was previously a detective and later became a private investigator. At first, when you play as him, he presents himself as a private investigator hired by the families of the Origami Killer’s victims.

Initially, players might believe that Shelby is an honest individual due to his initial claim at the game’s start. However, it later comes to light that he had been deceitful all along. He merely feigned working for the families of the victims as a ruse to get closer to them and eliminate any trace of evidence against him. This situation underscores the dangers of jumping to conclusions without proper verification.

1) Gustave’s Death – Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

Clair Obscur: Expedition 33

The adventure begins with players assuming command over the character Gustave, who gazes off into the horizon. Subsequently, Gustave interacts with other characters using his jovial demeanor. As Expedition 33 embarks on its quest to vanquish The Paintress, control is gradually bestowed upon additional characters. However, despite their capabilities, it’s always Gustave who leads the team and exhibits unselfish behavior. Over time, you will undoubtedly grow fond of him. And when this emotional bond is formed, prepare yourself for Clair Obscur‘s most shocking plot twist.

Suddenly, without warning, the villain strikes and takes the life of Gustave. His untimely death occurred at a crucial juncture, as the team was preparing to set sail for a fresh island. At that very instant, Gustave and Maelle were unexpectedly attacked by their foes. However, unlike Gustave, Maelle managed to escape unharmed. Left with a fatal wound, Gustave fought valiantly but ultimately succumbed to his injuries. This particular shocking event in Clair Obscur resonated deeply among the team members.

https://comicbook.com/gaming/news/best-games-like-clair-obscur-expedition-33/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-05 21:18