5 DC Heroes Who Are Terrible Leaders

by

DC Comics boasts a variety of superhero groups, with the Justice League and Teen Titans often taking the spotlight. Yet, not every incarnation of these squads has thrived, and unfortunately, not every team head has proven to be an efficient leader. Although certain heroes excel as strategic commanders, capable of guiding any team to triumph over adversaries, it doesn’t necessarily mean they possess the necessary empathy to lead people effectively. In some instances, leaders can become too intense and alienate themselves from their teammates. In others, the leaders are simply too myopic and struggle to rally people ready to fight alongside them. Lastly, there are those leaders who care little for their teams and view them as disposable assets sent into battle.

As a passionate cinephile delving into the vast universe of DC Comics, I must say that some characters’ portrayals as leaders leave much to be desired. From individuals who seemingly revel in their team members’ peril, to those plagued by self-centeredness or insecurity, these DC Comics leaders often fall short when it comes to effective leadership. Here are a few of the most questionable commanders in the DC pantheon.

5) Damian Wayne

When Damian Wayne proclaimed himself as the new head of the Teen Titans, events took an unfavorable turn. Initially, he expected others to join his team and abide by his commands without question, seemingly oblivious to how this approach repelled potential allies. Though Damian is driven by ambition and believes his leadership is impeccable when guiding the team in action, he often disregards the thoughts and emotions of his teammates, leading several heroes to reject collaborating with him further. Damian’s downfall lies in his arrogance and conviction that his method is the sole solution, making him a poor choice as a leader within the DC Comics universe.

4) John Constantine

Damian Wayne’s overbearing pride makes him a more combative leader, which over time leads his team to distance themselves from him. On the other hand, John Constantine couldn’t care less about leadership. Throughout his life, he’s been a trickster and manipulator, always looking out for himself. When he assumed leadership of the Justice League Dark, he was arguably the least suitable candidate. Even those teammates who somewhat appreciate him, like Zatanna, acknowledge that he isn’t fit to lead. He is formidable in combat and an asset to have, but when it comes to leading the team, there were definitely better choices available.

3) Guy Gardner

Upon assuming the financial leadership of Justice League International, Maxwell Lord introduced some intriguing changes. One such alteration was the elevation of Booster Gold to a significant role, even positioning him as a potential leader. Yet, there existed another member who unwaveringly believed himself to be the undisputed leader – Guy Gardner. In the eyes of JLI, no one stood above him. He constantly asserted his leadership claims and expected everyone to recognize him as such.

Unfortunately, Guy’s behavior was far from ideal for a leader. His tendency to belittle fellow team members was appalling, and he frequently ridiculed those who challenged his views. Worse still, under his guidance, the team often found themselves embroiled in one crisis after another. Even Superman’s return barely silenced Guy, and he only restrained himself when the Man of Steel was present.

Although Guy has shown improvement within the Green Lantern Corps, his impulsiveness and anger issues continue to prevent him from becoming an exceptional leader.

2) Amanda Waller

In my perspective as a follower, I’d have to say that Amanda Waller, in the world of DC Comics, might stand out among the least compassionate leaders. Her cold disregard for anyone under her command, be it Suicide Squad members or government employees, is quite striking. She seemed indifferent about who lived or died, even going so far as to eliminate squad members to instill fear and obedience.

Waller has a tendency to abandon her team once they’ve served their purpose, leaving them in dire circumstances. And she doesn’t hesitate to throw her team into hopeless situations for personal gain. She masquerades as a hero but in reality, is a villain who wields power through fear rather than respect.

1) Batman

Although Batman never intentionally leads individuals to their demise like Amanda Waller, it’s important to note that throughout his career, he has consistently placed children in peril by appointing them as Robin and exposing them to danger. This even resulted in one of their deaths. Furthermore, when these youngsters assert themselves, Batman tends to criticize and berate them. Moreover, it is arguable that there is no Justice League leader less trustworthy than Batman. He harbors mistrust towards his teammates, even before they provided him with any reason not to trust them (Identity Crisis). His Contingency plan to eliminate the entire Justice League is well-known, and his reluctance to trust others to follow his lead is renowned. Batman’s leadership style is flawed because he refuses to delegate authority to others within the JLA, and it would be beneficial for him to allow someone else to take charge at times.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/superman-clark-kent-regular-jobs-dc-comics/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-12 15:11