5 Marvel Characters Who Were Better In Comics Than The MCU

by

For nearly twenty years, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has delivered amazing films and memorable characters. However, the on-screen versions don’t always perfectly match their comic book origins. Thankfully, some casting choices have been brilliant. Chris Hemsworth embodies Thor, and many believe Chris Evans and Robert Downey Jr. were ideal as Captain America and Iron Man, respectively. In fact, a few actors have even improved upon their comic book counterparts – Dave Bautista’s Drax is a prime example, and Michael B. Jordan’s portrayal of Killmonger surpassed his comic book origins.

Despite many successful adaptations, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has also introduced characters who don’t live up to their comic book counterparts.

5) Quicksilver

The movie Avengers: Age of Ultron brought Quicksilver and the Scarlet Witch into the Marvel Cinematic Universe. While Elizabeth Olsen was a fantastic choice to play Wanda Maximoff and has become a key figure in the MCU, many fans felt Aaron Taylor-Johnson wasn’t right for the role of her brother, Pietro. Beyond the casting, the character of Quicksilver simply didn’t translate well from the comics to the screen.

The Quicksilver in the Marvel Cinematic Universe was a far cry from the confident character fans knew from the comics. He felt like a simple tool to move the plot forward, and his death lacked emotional weight, only serving to impact his sister’s storyline. This is especially disappointing considering Fox had their own Quicksilver, played by Evan Peters, who was a much more engaging and enjoyable character, even if he differed from the comic books. Ultimately, the MCU’s version of Quicksilver was easily forgettable.

4) Malekith

In Marvel comics, Malekith was a powerful and threatening villain who nearly took over the world. However, in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, he’s largely remembered as the antagonist from one of the franchise’s weakest and most forgettable films. Thor: The Dark World marked the first real stumble for the MCU, and its production was troubled – the original director, Patty Jenkins, was replaced by Alan Taylor, but the film didn’t improve much as a result.

The movie featured significant moments, like Loki beginning his shift towards being a hero and the death of Thor’s mother. However, the central villain, Malekith, King of the Dark Elves, played by Christopher Eccleston, wasn’t particularly memorable. He didn’t stand out from other early MCU villains, and the climactic battle was an indistinct flurry of effects. Ultimately, Malekith ended up being one of the MCU’s weakest villains.

3) Ultron

Ultron has been a major Marvel villain for many years. Originally, in the comics, he was created by Hank Pym to be a planetary savior. However, Ultron concluded that humanity itself was the biggest threat and tried to wipe people out to protect Earth. This concept was adapted for the Marvel Cinematic Universe, with one key change: Tony Stark, not Hank Pym, was the one who built Ultron.

The biggest problem with Ultron in the Marvel Cinematic Universe wasn’t his power, but how he was portrayed. Instead of being a cold, robotic villain, he spoke and acted like someone who’d spent too much time online, and he just didn’t feel menacing enough, despite being a clear danger. The What If…? version of Ultron was a much stronger and more effective depiction of the character, really highlighting how underwhelming the original Age of Ultron version was.

2) Taskmaster

The movie Black Widow significantly altered the Taskmaster character for a crucial reason. The storyline needed Taskmaster to be connected to the Red Room and to establish Dreykov (Ray Winstone) as a major villain. In the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Taskmaster is revealed to be Dreykov’s daughter, who was hurt in an explosion caused by Black Widow. Dreykov then trained her to become a highly skilled fighter dedicated to his goals.

For comic book fans, the biggest letdown with the Taskmaster in the Marvel Cinematic Universe is that the character wasn’t Tony Masters. In the comics, Tony Masters is a well-loved villain with the amazing ability to instantly copy anyone’s fighting style after seeing it just once. He’s also known for being funny and having a sharp, sarcastic wit. Many believe it would have been a better choice to use a different villain for the role of Dreykov’s daughter, as losing the opportunity to introduce Tony Masters as Taskmaster was a significant missed opportunity.

1) Adam Warlock

While Will Poulter is a talented actor, he wasn’t a good fit for the role of Adam Warlock in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3. This was a misstep for James Gunn, considering how well he handled the rest of the franchise. In the Marvel comics, Adam Warlock is incredibly powerful, a true match for villains like Thanos. But in the movie, he came across as an immature newcomer with no real defining characteristics.

The change from Silver Surfer to Shalla-Bal in Fantastic Four: First Steps felt logical within that story’s alternate reality and didn’t rule out the possibility of Silver Surfer appearing later. However, Will Poulter’s portrayal of Adam Warlock in Guardians of the Galaxy 3 was a major disappointment. It undermined a character with huge potential, turning him into a figure of ridicule instead of a powerful cosmic hero.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/movies/feature/6-years-ago-today-hbos-superhero-masterpiece-finally-fixed-1-of-zack-snyders-biggest-dc-controversies/embed/#

Read More

2025-11-18 22:44