Spider-Man is a long-time fan favorite, but that intense love can sometimes lead to strong dislike for the supporting characters in his stories. Fans become so attached to Spider-Man and Peter Parker that they often react negatively to anyone or anything that disrupts his life or the familiar world around him. Because Peter Parker’s personal life is so central to the comics, there are many opportunities for fans to find characters to dislike. This even extends to the writers and creators who make changes to Peter’s life, like in the controversial storyline “One More Day,” which remains a particularly hated moment for many Spider-Man fans.
Spider-Man has a rich history with many characters helping and hindering him over the last fifty years. Here’s a look at some of the most disliked supporting characters from Marvel Comics.
7) Ben Reilly
Ben Reilly is a compelling character, but he often receives a negative reaction from Marvel fans whenever he appears. This is unfortunate because Ben didn’t choose his circumstances – he genuinely believed he was the original Peter Parker for a long time, which is a major source of frustration, especially for longtime readers. He’s largely remembered as the central figure in “The Clone Saga,” a storyline widely considered one of the worst in Spider-Man history.
Fans disliked Ben Reilly because they initially thought he was Peter Parker. When Marvel revealed he was a different character, it felt like a waste of time and effort for those invested in Peter Parker’s story. Even now, Peter still resents Ben, despite Ben’s attempts to be a hero, and most fans tend to share Peter’s negative feelings, continuing to dislike Ben regardless of his actions.
6) Carlie Cooper
Initially, Carlie Cooper felt like an unwelcome addition to the Spider-Man story. Many fans disliked the storyline “One More Day,” where Peter Parker and Mary Jane Watson sacrificed their marriage and shared history to save Aunt May. This made it difficult to embrace the subsequent “Brand New Day” arc, and despite strong writing by Dan Slott, readers never fully accepted Carlie Cooper as a romantic partner for Peter Parker.
Fans overwhelmingly wanted Peter Parker and Mary Jane Watson to reunite, and they unfairly blamed Carlie for standing in the way. As the story continued, Carlie lacked a strong personality and didn’t contribute much, which only highlighted how well Peter and MJ fit together and fueled the desire to see her character removed. Once the intense dislike faded into indifference, it sealed Carlie’s fate.
5) Debra Whitman
Debra Whitman was involved in a problematic Spider-Man story where she suspected Peter Parker was Spider-Man. Instead of addressing her concerns responsibly, Spider-Man manipulated and intentionally drove her to mental instability, leaving her with significant psychological trauma. This is especially troubling considering Spider-Man is generally portrayed as a hero.
As a longtime fan, it was really frustrating to watch Debra’s character become so disliked. The writers just slowly made her unlikable, and honestly, most of us weren’t rooting for her and Peter to be together. It was even more shocking when fans actually cheered Spider-Man for manipulating her – that’s how much she’d lost our sympathy. And then, when she came back with that tell-all book about how Peter ‘ruined her life,’ it just cemented her as a villain in everyone’s eyes, even though, part of me thought Peter did treat her pretty badly.
4) Nick Katzenberg
I’ve been a Spider-Man fan for years, and honestly, J. Jonah Jameson is one of my favorite characters – even though he’s always giving Spider-Man a hard time! Everyone loves to dislike him, but he’s just so entertaining. There was another photographer at the Daily Bugle, Nick Katzenberg, who first showed up in Web of Spider-Man #50. He quickly became Jameson’s new go-to guy, but he just didn’t have the same appeal as J. Jonah. We all rooted against Jameson, but Katzenberg? He was just…forgettable.
He became disliked because he photographed Spider-Man seemingly committing crimes and constantly boasted about it to Peter Parker. This even damaged Peter’s friendship with Robbie Robertson. When he later returned, suffering from lung cancer, many fans didn’t sympathize with him, though his illness did motivate Mary Jane to quit smoking.
3) Ashley Kafka
Ashley Kafka is a character who’s appeared in many important Spider-Man stories, though she usually creates as much trouble as she fixes. First introduced in 1991 as a psychiatrist at the Ravenscroft Institute – a facility for supervillains with mental health issues – she dedicated herself to helping them recover, but rarely succeeded.
Okay, so there was a lot to unpack here. Initially, I really appreciated seeing a therapist portrayed in a genuinely positive light – it’s rare! But honestly, the more she justified her failures with these patients, especially the ones who went on to commit crimes, the harder it was to root for her. Things really went off the rails when one of her patients killed her and she came back as a clone. After that, she became incredibly unlikeable, and her turn as Queen Goblin? Just… insufferable. It was a frustrating arc, to say the least.
2) Michele Gonzales
Michele Gonzales, like Carlie Cooper before her, struggled because she was introduced as a potential love interest for Peter Parker when fans were already devoted to Mary Jane Watson. However, many viewers found Michele even more unlikeable than Carlie, due to her irritating personality and the consistently negative way she interacted with Peter.
Their one-night stand, even though they weren’t genuinely attracted to each other and both had been drinking, was considered inappropriate, and things quickly deteriorated. They eventually started dating, but the public didn’t believe in the relationship and many wished Michele would disappear. When they finally broke up, it was widely seen as a positive outcome.
1) Paul Rabin
This month marked the death of Paul Rabin, a Spider-Man supporting character widely disliked by fans. He was the man Mary Jane Watson fell in love with while stranded in another dimension (though it only felt like a few weeks to those on Earth). Fans resented Paul because he became Mary Jane’s new love interest, and he never managed to win them over.
Fans strongly disliked Paul Rabin for a number of reasons – his constant complaining, his questionable hairstyle, and most of all, his attempts to pursue Mary Jane Watson and become a father figure to Dylan Brock instead of Peter Parker and Eddie Brock, respectively. Even after his breakup with MJ, the negativity persisted. Surprisingly, even when he died a heroic death saving Dylan, many fans celebrated his demise at the hands of Torment. Paul Rabin remains the most disliked supporting character in the Spider-Man universe.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
https://comicbook.com/comics/list/the-7-best-sinister-six-storylines-in-spider-man-comics/embed/#
Read More
- What Song Is In The New Supergirl Trailer (& What It Means For The DC Movie)
- Why is Tech Jacket gender-swapped in Invincible season 4 and who voices her?
- Highly Anticipated Strategy RPG Finally Sets Release Date (And It’s Soon)
- TV legend Carol Kirkwood reveals the reasons why she decided to retire after 28 years with BBC
- Starfield PS5 Won’t Play Off Physical Disc without a Download
- The Super Mario Galaxy Movie: 50 Easter Eggs, References & Major Cameos Explained
- Crimson Desert – 15 Things I Wish I Knew Before Diving In
- Welcome to Demon School! Iruma-kun season 4 release schedule: When are new episodes on Crunchyroll?
- New Pokemon Go Event Gives Players A Shot At 11 Rare Shiny Pokemon (With Boosted Odds)
- NFL Heiress Gracie Hunt Engaged to Former Chiefs QB’s Son Derek Green
2026-04-07 00:19