7 Urban Fantasy TV Shows That Were Masterpieces From Beginning to End

Everyone enjoys a good fantasy story, and the genre remains incredibly popular. But what about urban fantasy – stories set in our world, but with magical or supernatural elements? While it’s fun to see fantasy in a familiar setting, it’s challenging for TV shows to pull off successfully. The show needs to be believable, fast-paced, and engaging. Many have tried urban fantasy, but some shows started well and then faltered due to weak storylines or characters, while others even changed their overall feel mid-season.

Everyone loves a great TV show that keeps you hooked from beginning to end, doesn’t it? That’s why we’ve chosen 7 urban fantasy series that are truly exceptional, maintaining their quality throughout every episode. While no show is perfect, these series consistently deliver on their initial promise and deserve a spot on this list.

7) Grimm

Even now, fans still love Grimm because it maintains a good quality throughout all of its seasons – something many shows struggle with. While a few storylines aren’t perfect, the show is remarkably consistent. The series follows Nick Burkhardt (David Giuntoli), a detective who discovers he’s a Grimm – a protector against mythical creatures living among us. This creates a format with self-contained “monster-of-the-week” stories, woven together with larger, ongoing plots about different Wesen families, which helps keep the show focused and engaging.

I’ve always been fascinated by Grimm. It wasn’t hailed as the greatest show ever made, but it also didn’t have any major collapses. What really struck me was how consistently good it was – the world-building felt really solid, the atmosphere stayed dark and exciting, and even when an episode wasn’t perfect, you knew you’d get that blend of suspense, action, and supernatural thrills set in our world. Honestly, that’s what makes it special – it consistently delivered on its promise. It never failed to entertain, and it found ways to keep things fresh. To me, that’s what elevates it to a truly great series.

6) Lucifer

Some people might question whether Lucifer deserves to be included, likely because it doesn’t appeal to all viewers. What makes the show so good is that it doesn’t try to be overly original; it successfully combines supernatural elements – angels and demons – with the familiar structure of a police procedural, all driven by sheer charm. The show centers around the Devil himself (played by Tom Ellis), who lives in Los Angeles, assists the police, and grapples with his own personal struggles, and honestly, that compelling premise is a huge part of what makes it work.

Despite dealing with weekly mysteries and plenty of interpersonal conflict, the show maintains a lighthearted tone, often feeling like a supernatural sitcom. It also manages to weave together longer, more complex storylines about family, love, and forgiveness in a way that really works. Ultimately, Lucifer strikes a great balance between comedy, drama, and even bending its own rules. It doesn’t take itself too seriously, so your enjoyment will depend on what you’re looking for. However, the strong cast and how well they play off each other make it consistently entertaining from beginning to end.

5) Penny Dreadful

If you’re a fan of horror that’s also smart and well-developed, Penny Dreadful is a hidden gem. This Victorian-era urban fantasy series brings together iconic characters like vampires, Frankenstein’s monster, and Dorian Gray in a fascinating way. It sounds like a risky combination, but it truly works. The story centers on Vanessa Ives (played by Eva Green), a spiritualist, and her work with Sir Malcolm (Timothy Dalton) as they search for his missing daughter, all while Vanessa battles her own inner and supernatural struggles.

As a fan, I can honestly say that Penny Dreadful is incredible. It perfectly balances being scary with having really deep, well-developed characters – everyone feels real, with their own understandable motivations and past hurts. What I loved most is that the show never loses sight of what makes it great; the horror, the psychological depth, and the overall dark mood are consistently strong throughout the entire series. It’s a smart and cohesive show, and I struggled to find anything that truly detracted from the experience. It’s just a really well-made, immersive story.

4) Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Let me tell you, if you haven’t seen Buffy the Vampire Slayer, you’re missing out. It’s a cornerstone of the fantasy genre, and honestly, it grabbed me from the very first season. The premise – Sarah Michelle Gellar as Buffy Summers, the chosen vampire hunter in Sunnydale – sounds pretty straightforward, right? A teen girl battling the undead while navigating high school drama? It is, but that’s where the magic happens. Buffy isn’t just about monsters; it brilliantly uses the supernatural to explore real-life issues in a way that feels incredibly relatable. And trust me, once you start, you won’t be able to stop watching – especially with a reboot on the horizon!

Despite its long run, Buffy the Vampire Slayer remains remarkably consistent. While not every episode is perfect, the show consistently maintains strong character development and a cohesive mythology. It expertly blends self-contained stories with overarching season-long plots, allowing characters to grow organically. Ultimately, the series feels meticulously planned, with every element contributing to a larger, understandable narrative.

3) Good Omens

Compared to the book it’s based on, the series Good Omens takes some liberties, which might bother purists. However, as a standalone show, it’s remarkably well-done, especially considering its relatively short run. It perfectly delivers on its promise of fun, witty urban fantasy, maintaining a consistent and engaging tone. The series centers around the unlikely partnership between angel Aziraphale (Michael Sheen) and demon Crowley (David Tennant) as they work to prevent the Apocalypse, and it’s a genuinely enjoyable watch, blending humor with insightful social observations.

The story is intentionally straightforward and uncomplicated, even a little strange, and that’s perfectly fine. What really makes it special is how well it’s done. Each episode is full of clever humor, characters you care about, and a smooth, engaging pace. Good Omens is a truly delightful and well-made series that knows exactly what it’s doing – it’s a complete success.

2) Pushing Daisies

As a huge movie and TV fan, I still stumble across people online upset that Pushing Daisies got canceled, and honestly, it’s totally understandable. The show is just unbelievably imaginative – I always wonder how anyone dreamed up such a unique concept and managed to pull it off for as long as it lasted. It centers around Ned, played by Lee Pace, a pie-maker with the amazing ability to bring people back to life, but there’s a catch – touch them twice and they’re gone for good. He ends up working with a private investigator, and then he revives his childhood sweetheart, Chuck (Anna Friel). You can probably imagine the direction it takes – a mix of mystery, romance, and episodes that genuinely feel like modern-day fairy tales.

The TV show Pushing Daisies is remarkably consistent – the visuals, story, and characters all blend together seamlessly, making it a joy to watch. Throughout its two seasons, it maintains a unique energy and creativity, which explains its dedicated fanbase. It’s a lighthearted and funny show with excellent timing, and it treats its viewers with respect. While the premise is unusual, the show never asks you to ignore plot holes – everything makes sense within its own quirky world. It’s a truly worthwhile show to watch.

1) What We Do in the Shadows

If you enjoy comedy, fantasy, or mockumentaries, you’ll love What We Do in the Shadows. The show centers around three vampires living in Staten Island and their struggles with everyday life and the human world. While the premise might seem silly, it’s a surprisingly hilarious and consistently funny series. It’s rare to find a show this reliably entertaining, offering a genuinely funny take on vampires trying to navigate modern problems – even something as mundane as doing chores!

What truly stands out is that the show consistently stays funny and original – it never gets stale. Despite being a comedy, it’s surprisingly deep, with each season cleverly building on what came before, developing the characters and storylines while staying true to its unique spirit. The witty dialogue alone is reason enough to watch, and it’s incredibly addictive – once you start, you’ll likely find yourself watching the whole series in one sitting.

Enjoying any of these shows? Share your thoughts in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/list/the-10-best-fantasy-shows-of-the-2020s-so-far/embed/#

2026-02-20 00:43