7 Worst Horror Movie Sequels Ever, Ranked

Horror movies are a consistently profitable part of Hollywood because they don’t require huge budgets to make a lot of money. While big-budget blockbusters need hundreds of millions of dollars for production and advertising, horror films often succeed with smaller budgets by focusing on creative practical effects and building suspense. This efficiency, combined with a loyal fanbase that consistently goes to the theater, means even moderately successful horror films can be very profitable. As a result, horror remains a stable and reliable investment for studios looking to balance risk and reward.

Horror movies often have a clear path to making money, which can lead studios to rush production of sequels instead of focusing on a good story. When a successful horror film comes out, studios quickly try to turn it into a franchise. This often means hurried production and weak scripts. The desire to profit from a popular brand can water down the original idea, as filmmakers struggle to recreate what made the first movie special while meeting tight deadlines. As a result, many horror sequels disappoint fans by relying on clichés and illogical storylines instead of delivering genuine scares.

7) Hellraiser: Revelations

The ninth Hellraiser movie was made primarily to maintain the studio’s ownership of the franchise. Dimension Films needed to release a new film quickly to avoid losing the rights to the original creator. This led to a very low budget of just $300,000 and an incredibly fast, under-two-week filming schedule. As a result, a new actor, Stephan Smith Collins, took on the role of Pinhead after Doug Bradley, who famously played the character, refused to participate due to the script’s poor quality and the rushed production.

Hellraiser: Revelations centers around two friends who find a mysterious puzzle box while in Mexico. However, the film suffers from a lack of mood and noticeably low-budget special effects, making it feel more like a student film than a proper sequel. It was so poorly received, in fact, that Clive Barker—the original creator of Hellraiser—publicly distanced himself from it, stating it didn’t align with his creative intentions.

6) American Psycho 2

Initially developed as a separate thriller called The Girl Who Wouldn’t Die, American Psycho 2 was later connected to the American Psycho franchise during filming to help boost sales. The story centers on Rachael Newman (Mila Kunis), a criminology student who survived a childhood encounter with Patrick Bateman and later develops a dangerous obsession with murder as she tries to become an FBI agent.

The studio tried to connect the film to a well-respected satirical movie, but this created a confusing experience that didn’t match the original’s style or message. Even with a cameo by William Shatner as Professor Robert Starkman, the movie was criticized for relying on typical slasher clichés and having a weak, disjointed story. Kunis, the lead actress, has said she regrets being in the film, explaining she didn’t realize it was being sold as a sequel to American Psycho until after it was finished. As a result, American Psycho 2 is largely forgotten and almost universally disliked, remaining a low point in horror cinema.

5) Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday

After New Line Cinema acquired the rights to the Friday the 13th series, they tried a radical new approach with Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday. Instead of the typical slasher film, the movie featured a supernatural storyline where Jason Voorhees’s spirit possessed different people after his body was destroyed early on. This meant fans didn’t see Jason’s signature hockey mask for most of the film, which disappointed many who were expecting a classic Crystal Lake killing spree.

Okay, let’s talk about Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday. Honestly, it felt like they threw everything at the wall to see what stuck. They introduced this whole complicated backstory with a magic dagger and the idea that Jason needed a family member to come back – which completely ignored everything we’d seen in the previous ten films. And while seeing Freddy Krueger’s glove at the end was a fun little tease, the movie itself just didn’t feel like a Friday the 13th film. It lacked the core elements that made the series work, and it’s no surprise that most fans consider it a real low point.

4) Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation

Kim Henkel, who helped write the original Texas Chainsaw Massacre, tried a new approach with The Next Generation, aiming for a darkly comedic and conspiratorial tone. The film centers on Jenny (Renée Zellweger) and her friends as they cross paths with a new iteration of the Sawyer family, this time led by Vilmer (Matthew McConaughey), who has a cybernetic leg. The plot gets complicated when it introduces a secret organization, similar to the Illuminati, that uses the Sawyers to create intense, terrifying experiences for its members.

Despite being filmed in 1994, Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation wasn’t widely released until years later, after its stars had become famous. While Matthew McConaughey’s energetic performance is a highlight, the film’s script strayed too far from the raw, realistic feel of the original 1974 movie, creating a jarring experience. Though it’s gained a following among fans of unusual films, most viewers didn’t connect with the story’s added element of a secret society, which felt confusing and out of place within the Leatherface universe.

3) Halloween: Resurrection

Following the satisfying conclusion of Halloween H20, which seemed to end the decades-long conflict between Laurie Strode and Michael Myers, Halloween: Resurrection quickly undid all of that in pursuit of profit. The film ignored the previous ending by revealing that the killer had secretly swapped places with a paramedic, allowing him to kill Laurie at the very beginning. This instantly upset fans, and the rest of the movie follows a tired reality TV concept: contestants exploring the infamous Myers house for an online show.

Halloween: Resurrection tried to update the series with elements like webcam footage and internet trends, but it ended up feeling old-fashioned and lacked excitement. The film is best remembered for a bizarre fight scene where Busta Rhymes’ character battles Michael Myers using martial arts, which diminished the villain’s scary reputation. By turning the iconic antagonist into a joke and sidelining the main character, the movie unfortunately put the Halloween franchise on hold for several years.

2) Exorcist II: The Heretic

John Boorman’s attempt to follow up The Exorcist with Exorcist II: The Heretic aimed for a thought-provoking sequel, but it’s widely considered a failure. The film, set four years after the original, centers on Father Lamont (Richard Burton) who uses a special machine to explore the lingering trauma of Regan MacNeil (Linda Blair). Unlike the frightening, shocking horror of the first film, Boorman filled this sequel with surreal dream sequences featuring locusts and ancient African folklore, leaving audiences confused and disappointed.

The making of Exorcist II: The Heretic was filled with problems. The director got sick with a rare illness, stopping production for weeks. When the movie came out, audiences hated it so much they threw things at the screen during test showings, which led to the studio re-editing it several times. Even with a famous cast and a score by Ennio Morricone, Exorcist II: The Heretic is a prime example of a filmmaker missing what made the first Exorcist movie so popular.

1) Jaws: The Revenge

Often considered the worst sequel ever made, Jaws: The Revenge is famously poorly rated on Rotten Tomatoes, currently at just two percent. The film completely disregards logic and quality, presenting a story where a great white shark seems to hold a personal grudge against Ellen Brody (Lorraine Gary) and her family, relentlessly pursuing them from the waters of Amity Island all the way to the Bahamas. Adding to the issues, the movie was made incredibly quickly – from initial idea to release in just nine months to make a summer deadline.

The quick production of Jaws: The Revenge led to obvious mistakes, like seeing the shark’s mechanical track and hearing it roar like a lion during the final scene. It’s also well-known that Michael Caine skipped the Academy Awards to film this movie in the Caribbean – a real shame, because Jaws: The Revenge isn’t just a terrible horror sequel, it’s widely considered one of the worst films ever made.

What’s the worst horror movie sequel, in your opinion? Share your thoughts in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/horror-movie-sequels-evil-dead-2-smile-2-dawn-of-the-dead/embed/#

2026-02-04 21:17