Batman has remained a popular figure since his first appearance in 1939. To keep the character interesting for new audiences, writers and artists regularly reimagine him, delving into the many layers of his personality. This experimentation has resulted in some of the most famous and well-loved stories in comic books, often exploring Batman’s inner struggles, strong sense of right and wrong, and complicated connections with friends and foes. However, not all of these attempts to update the character have been successful.
Batman’s history includes several creative choices that fans have strongly disagreed with, or even disliked. These often happen when the character’s fundamental traits are misunderstood, or when story decisions seem designed for attention rather than genuine character growth.
7) The Death of a Damian
The arrival of Damian Wayne, Bruce Wayne’s son with Talia al Ghul, dramatically changed the Batman story. He started as a boastful and aggressive child trained as an assassin, but his journey to become Robin was captivating as he slowly learned to follow his father’s principles and become part of the Batman family. His relationship with Dick Grayson, who was Batman at the time, was especially interesting, reversing the typical hero-sidekick roles. That’s why his death was so surprising and caused a lot of debate. In the 2013 comic Batman Incorporated #8, Damian died in a fierce fight against a large clone of himself called the Heretic. Although his death was shown as a brave sacrifice, many fans felt it was too soon for a character who was just starting to develop. The decision sparked a lot of discussion, with some readers disappointed that such a compelling new character had been cut short.
6) Breaking the Code for KGBeast
Batman is famously known for his unwavering rule against killing. However, a recent issue of the Batman comic, #57, tested that rule like never before. Driven by rage after Nightwing was shot, Batman tracked down the villain KGBeast for revenge. Their fight was incredibly violent, ending with Batman breaking KGBeast’s neck with his grappling hook, leaving him paralyzed. Instead of helping, Batman simply left KGBeast to die in the snow. This decision sparked a huge debate among fans. Although later issues hinted Batman believed help was nearby, the scene clearly showed him abandoning an enemy to certain death. Many felt this was a shocking violation of Batman’s core principles, portraying a level of cold fury that didn’t seem true to his character.
5) The Black Label Controversy
In 2018, DC Comics introduced Black Label, a series of comics aimed at adult readers. The first comic released was a horror story called Batman: Damned, but it quickly became famous for something else entirely: a panel showing Batman completely nude. The image immediately spread online, becoming a popular topic of conversation and prompting DC Comics to quickly remove it from digital copies and future printings. Although the creators felt the nudity was a deliberate artistic decision, a DC co-publisher later admitted they regretted the controversy, as it overshadowed the story itself. Many people viewed the moment as a strange attempt to generate publicity.
4) The New 52 Reboot
In 2011, DC Comics launched “New 52,” a major overhaul of its entire comic line aimed at simplifying the stories and attracting new fans. While Batman’s history wasn’t completely erased – key events like The Killing Joke and Jason Todd’s death still happened – the timeline was significantly shortened, establishing he’d only been active for about six years. This caused problems because it squeezed four different Robins and a Batgirl into that timeframe, disrupting established relationships and years of character growth. Characters like Stephanie Brown and Cassandra Cain essentially had their histories wiped out. Many longtime readers disliked the reboot, feeling it sacrificed meaningful stories for a confusing and ineffective marketing tactic.
3) The Catwoman Wedding That Wasn’t
The romance between Batman and Catwoman culminated in a highly publicized wedding storyline that was a major event for DC Comics. For many issues, the story built up their complex relationship, leading to Batman #50 – the supposed wedding issue. However, fans were shocked when Catwoman left Batman at the altar, believing that a happy Bruce Wayne wouldn’t be the Batman Gotham needed. The fact that the villain Bane had secretly influenced her decision didn’t ease the disappointment. This unexpected turn of events was widely criticized as a frustrating and unsatisfying conclusion to a story that had promised significant character development, but ultimately went nowhere.
2) “A Death in the Family”
The death of Jason Todd, the second Robin, is famous—and infamous—in comic book history, not just for what happened in the story, but how it happened. By 1988, readers weren’t connecting with the character, so DC Comics created a storyline where the Joker savagely attacked him, leaving him to die in an explosion. Uniquely, DC then let fans vote on Jason’s fate by calling special phone numbers. The vote was incredibly close—only 72 votes separated life and death—and readers ultimately chose for Jason to die. This decision to let fans decide a character’s death was a questionable move in publishing. While the event significantly impacted Batman, the way DC handled it remains a controversial part of the company’s history.
1) The “Goddamn Batman”
Frank Miller’s All-Star Batman & Robin, the Boy Wonder is widely considered a terrible and deeply problematic take on the Batman story. Though set in the same world as his acclaimed The Dark Knight Returns, this series presents a Batman who is brutal, unstable, and shockingly abusive. A prime example is how he treats Dick Grayson after Grayson’s parents are killed. Batman essentially abducts the boy, brings him to the Batcave, insults him relentlessly, and even forces him to eat rats to survive. This extreme portrayal was so over-the-top that it felt like a satire, turning the usually heroic Batman into a violent and disturbed character. As a result, the series was almost universally disliked by both fans and critics, who felt it completely missed the mark in depicting the relationship between Batman and his young protégé.
What Batman decisions haven’t quite worked for you? Share your thoughts in the comments and join the discussion in the ComicBook Forum!
https://comicbook.com/comics/list/10-great-batman-comics-that-are-terrible-for-dc-beginners/embed/#
Read More
- Deadlock The Doorman Guide: Big Tips & Tricks
- Kunitsu-Gami: Path of the Goddess ‘Mazo Talisman: Yashichi Waves’ update launches in July
- Steam RPG From 2023 Being Removed Next Month and PC Users Aren’t Happy: “Huge Potential Wasted”
- Yakuza Maker’s Next PS5 Game Gets a Brief Behind-the-Scenes Video
- ‘My Name Is Jeff’: Channing Tatum Played Another Jeff In Roofman, And Is Considering Legally Changing His Name
- Gears of War: Reloaded is Now Available
- ‘LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight’ Reveals Its 7 Main Batsuits
- Alabaster Dawn Demo is Now Available on PC
- Preview: Teamwork Is the True Terror of Little Nightmares 3
- No Upgrade Path for the Belated PS5 Version of Yakuza 0 Director’s Cut
2025-10-28 21:16