7 X-Men Villains Who Should Have Won

The X-Men, among Marvel’s superhero teams, often face the toughest challenges. They constantly combat dangers to our world, a place that often despises and fears them, while simultaneously safeguarding the survival of mutants as a species. Throughout their journey in the Marvel Universe, they have been thrust into some of the most grueling battles, fighting foes intent on destroying them, the mutant community, and the world itself – not always in that particular order. The X-Men encounter some of the most formidable villains in comics, yet time and again, their unity has thwarted these evil plots. Over the years, they’ve managed to triumph over seemingly insurmountable odds, vanquishing adversaries whose plans threatened everything they hold dear. These victories are often against all odds, as their enemies typically outmatch the X-men in every conceivable way.

Although it often seemed that the X-Men’s adversaries had the upper hand during their battles, there were instances where the X-Men managed to emerge victorious despite overwhelming odds. On several occasions, the antagonists appeared poised for victory, yet the X-Men somehow defied the circumstances and triumphed, thus thwarting their wicked schemes and safeguarding the world from impending doom.

7) Magneto

As a devoted X-Men fan, I’ve often found myself pondering over Magneto’s moral complexities – so much so that it feels like entire generations of us have wished he had triumphed long ago. Yet, when it comes to specific instances, two stories stand out in my mind: “X-Men” Volume 2 issues #1-3 and the “Fatal Attractions” saga.

In the former, Magneto had the X-Men cornered, their defeat was certain. Instead of eliminating them brutally, he chose to imprison them aboard Asteroid M. He then resorted to hostage-taking – taking Professor Xavier and Moira MacTaggert as prisoners to coerce Moira into altering the X-Men’s minds. This was all after learning about the manipulation of his mind by Xavier and Moira, but it seemed a foolish move on Magneto’s part since he could have claimed victory over the X-Men if he hadn’t acted as he did.

In “Fatal Attractions”, Magneto presented the X-Men with an opportunity – giving them a chance to join him rather than attacking them mercilessly with his full power and new Acolytes. Had he so chosen, he could have annihilated all the mutant superheroes in one swift strike during Illyana Rasputin’s funeral. There are other instances where Magneto could have defeated the X-Men, but these two instances, in my opinion, were among the most questionable decisions he made.

6) Cassandra Nova

The groundbreaking series New X-Men launched with the debut of a new X-Men antagonist: Cassandra Nova, a formidable adversary who is also the twin sister of Charles Xavier, whom he unintentionally killed in the womb. Surviving as a collection of cells, she crafted her own body and vowed revenge against both her brother and his X-Men students.

Cassandra Nova manipulated events to set the wild Master Mold into motion, resulting in the creation of the Wild Sentinels. She also unleashed the Mega-Sentinels on Genosha, duped Wolverine and Cyclops into capturing her, and brought her to the X-Mansion. Once there, she orchestrated attacks from within, even managing to swap bodies with Xavier, leaving him in a ruined shell of her creation.

In control of Beast via Beak, Cassandra Nova then moved on to the Shi’Ar Empire, where her actions led to the destruction of the empire due to Xavier’s connections with Empress Lilandra. However, had she remained on Earth and focused on eliminating the X-Men stealthily, one by one, she may have succeeded in accomplishing her goal of ruining her brother’s life entirely.

Alas, her thirst for revenge prematurely unraveled her plans; if she had been more patient and strategically employed her immense power, she might have triumphed in her quest to annihilate her brother’s existence completely.

5) Enigma

The Victorian scientist, Nathaniel Essex, delved into genetics and found himself entangled with Apocalypse, mastering the art of cloning. Later, he discovered the concept of a Dominion – an entity beyond space and time that is godlike in nature. He anticipated the emergence of artificial life forms and created four clones of himself and an AI form to understand how to transform into such a Dominion. Eventually, Essex managed to become Enigma, initiating a series of events against the X-Men. The X-Men eventually uncovered his existence and, utilizing the Phoenix Force, they defeated him. However, this was not as it should have been. Enigma transcended time; he could observe any potential past, present, or future. It was within his capabilities to annihilate the X-Men long before they even became the X-Men (which he attempted once against Hope Summers but was thwarted by Jean Grey’s insight). Enigma possessed power that few Marvel villains have ever wielded; he should have effortlessly been able to eliminate the X-Men from existence.

4) Dark Phoenix

The Dark Phoenix Saga” is a legendary story within the X-Men series, which explores the lengths the team would go to save a friend. Jean Grey, succumbing to the Phoenix Force, transformed into the Dark Phoenix, consuming an entire solar system before the X-Men could bring out her good side. Yet, it’s questionable whether they should have been able to confront her power at that point. Even though Jean Grey maintained some control over the Phoenix Force, it seems unlikely that the team could have withstood her might. Known for its cosmic scale, “The Dark Phoenix Saga” also highlights the extent the X-Men will go for a friend. However, the Dark Phoenix should have effortlessly defeated the X-Men given her power level. In fact, it’s puzzling that the Phoenix Force didn’t simply devour the Sun instead of traveling to the D’Bari system to feed. Essentially, it seems like the only reason the X-Men prevailed is because they are central characters in the story.

3) Madelyne Pryor

Madelyne Pryor is a pivotal character in the X-Men series, significantly influencing the team’s history. Crafted by Mister Sinister for romantic manipulation of Cyclops from Jean Grey’s DNA, she established a family with Scott Summers and bore a child. However, Jean Grey’s resurrection dismantled her family, and matters worsened when Mister Sinister focused his attention on her. Furthermore, learning she was a clone added to her psychological turmoil, eventually leading her to ally with the demons of Limbo. This alliance resulted in an invasion of Earth, as depicted in the storyline “Inferno”. Despite numerous mutant teams and heroes from New York City managing to repel the invasion, they were arguably lucky to do so. With a multitude of demonic forces under her command, Madelyne Pryor seemingly had enough power to overrun the entire city. Moreover, Limbo granted her the ability to manipulate time, which she could have exploited for devastating effects against her adversaries. Not only that, but an echo of the Phoenix Force was within her grasp, a factor that should have contributed to her victory in “Inferno”, making it apparent that she had the potential to emerge victorious with all the advantages she possessed.

2) Apocalypse

In my view, “The Twelve” stands as an underappreciated tale within the X-Men universe, dating back to late 1999. The story centers on the villain Apocalypse’s attempt to seize power by capturing a group of mutants known as the Twelve. If successful, this would have granted him divine power and enabled him to dominate the world. Yet, the X-Men managed to uncover his scheme – thanks in part to the Skrulls who served Apocalypse – and ultimately emerged victorious.

However, it’s worth noting that Apocalypse had some formidable members of the Twelve on his side: Wolverine as his Horseman of Death, and X-Man, a counterpart from an alternate reality who possessed godlike mental abilities. Given this powerful lineup, Apocalypse seemed poised to defeat the X-Men. But surprisingly, he lost because he formed a bond with Cyclops. Instead of utilizing the power he had amassed to its full potential, this connection proved costly for him.

1) Onlslaught

As a devoted cinema enthusiast, I’d rephrase it like this:

In the cinematic universe, Onslaught emerged when Professor X performed a mind-wipe on Magneto, unleashing his dark intentions within Xavier. This psychic parasite, born of their combined powers, aimed to annihilate humanity. Initially, traces of Xavier’s affection for his X-Men students prevented Onslaught from eliminating them instantly.

However, during its second phase, Onslaught harnessed the power of X-Man and Franklin Richards. With this newfound might, he purged Xavier as a conscious entity, leaving only his psychic energy as a mere power source. Now controlling two of Earth’s most potent telepaths and its strongest reality warper, Onslaught could have eradicated every Marvel hero with a single thought. The absence of Professor X, the moral compass, was no longer there to impede him. It seemed like Onslaught was merely playing with us all for amusement before ultimately meeting his demise.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-best-x-men-stories-20s-marvel-comics/embed/#

2025-09-01 17:12