8 Controversial Single Issues of Comics That Caused Real-World Outrage

When searching for contentious comic book releases throughout history, you’ll find a rich variety to delve into. While many of these debates were initially confined to comic enthusiasts, some escalated to broader discussions. For instance, Neal Adams’ collaborations with Green Arrow and Green Lantern tackled subjects usually shunned in comics, such as drug abuse and racism. The Spider-Man series has also been marred by decisions that Marvel still hasn’t fully recovered from today. Similarly, the death of Robin at Batman’s hands during “A Death in the Family” caused quite a stir in the ’80s, especially with the use of a call-in hotline to decide Robin’s fate. These instances are just the tip of the iceberg; there’s much more to discover if you dive deeper into the world of controversial comic book moments.

Various comic issues have sparked enough public backlash to be pulled off the stands. Sometimes this can be attributed to printing errors, but often it’s due to creative choices made by writers or artists that left readers stunned or provoked debate. The most controversial instances even led to new ideas, discussions, and speculations, while also ending up destroyed.

1) New Teen Titans #34 – Deathstroke and Terra’s Relationship Revealed

Among DC Comics collections, ‘The Judas Contract’ stands out as a must-have for many comic enthusiasts. This storyline sets up an intense confrontation between the well-known superhero squad and Deathstroke the Terminator, following the arrival of a new recruit named Terra. She harbors a significant secret, one that could shatter the feelings of Beast Boy once he grows fond of her.

The cause of the uproar lies in the alliance between Terra and Slade Wilson. Not only are they working together, but they’re also romantically involved, which is causing quite a stir. This illicit relationship, involving a villain and a 16-year-old, is the source of controversy. Terra was depicted as mentally unstable in this story, serving to further emphasize her evil nature. Interestingly, Terra is actually younger at the start of the narrative, celebrating her birthday with the Teen Titans within the storyline. Years later, DC Comics would revise and address this relationship, but it continues to be a contentious issue in the iconic tale.

2) X-Statix #13 – Princess Di Joins the Team?

In July 2001, Marvel took a playful approach with the X-Force series, bringing aboard writer Peter Milligan and popular indie artist Mike Allred. They rebranded the team as X-Statix, replacing the original X-Force title. The revamped team lasted for 26 issues before Allred and Milligan made the bold decision to end the lives of the entire team – marking their second major death in the series.

The title’s central controversy with the UK Royal Family stemmed partly from its reference to Princess Diana, depicted on the cover of X-Statix #13. Beyond just the cover, plans included her resurrection as a mutant superhero within the team. However, Marvel ultimately decided to replace Diana with a fictional pop star named Henrietta Hunter in the storyline.

3) Amazing Spider-Man #512 – Gwen Stacy and Norman Osborn Affair

Absolutely! It’s often said that “One More Day” stands out among recent Spider-Man storylines as one of the less favorable decisions made. However, it’s not unique in this regard, and there may be even more questionable moves if they decide to resurrect Uncle Ben as Venom.

J. Michael Straczynski wrote a story that was published before “One More Day” significantly altered Spider-Man’s history. The controversial aspect of this comic lies in the surprising disclosure – Mary Jane revealing to Peter about Gwen Stacy’s twins, implying that Norman Osborn, not Parker, is their father. This revelation foreshadows future interference in Spider-Man’s life and revisits the sensitive topic of Gwen Stacy’s death by suggesting Osborn targeted her due to her pregnancy and her intentions to be with Parker. To add insult to injury, this shocking disclosure is accompanied by unsettling artwork that seems to depict Osborn preying on Stacy.

4) Avengers #200 – Ms. Marvel’s Unexpected Pregnancy

In our review of poor Avengers narratives, this particular issue implies that Carol Danvers, against her will, is on the verge of giving birth to Marcus, the man who assaulted her and fathered the child. What makes it even more distressing is that Marvel portrays the Avengers as cooperating with this situation and supporting Danvers in keeping the baby. Remarkably, she consents, choosing to stand by the villain, who turns out to be the son of Immortus – a character often associated with Kang the Conqueror’s alternate identities. To keep Ms. Marvel away from the team, Thor then sends the pair to Limbo, and for more than a year, she is absent before losing her powers to Rogue and joining the X-Men to regain her strength.

Looking back, the entire narrative seems utterly dreadful, and this sentiment was shared by Jim Shooter, a former Marvel editor and writer, in a 2011 blog post.

In simpler terms, “Shooter admitted his mistake and apologized for it. He regrets having approved the book, calling it a disgrace. He accepts full responsibility for any shortcomings in judgment or attentiveness, and refers to ‘Avengers’ #200 as a catastrophe.

5) Elseworlds 80-Page Giant – Letitia Lerner, Superman’s Babysitter

The unconventional and peculiar story penned by Kyle Baker and Liz Glass, titled “Letitia Lerner: The Babysitter of Young Superman,” revolves around Letitia, who was entrusted with the care of baby Clark Kent, future superhero. This narrative, marked by a challenging night for Letitia as she struggled to keep up with her young charge, stirred up debate due to its climax in which baby Clark crawled into a microwave.

Initially, this narrative surfaced within the June 1999 issue of the Elseworlds 80-Page Giant. However, it faced obstacles when DC Vice-President Paul Levitz reviewed it and demanded its withdrawal from sale, essentially prohibiting it at that moment. In a sense, this situation resembled the Streisand Effect, leading to the story’s subsequent appearance in the 2003 Bizarro Comics anthology without any alterations.

6) Green Lantern #54 – Alexandra DeWitt’s Women in Refrigerators Moment

In 1999, Gail Simone shed light on a troubling trend in comic book storytelling: the use of female characters as mere plot devices for advancing male protagonists’ stories. This practice can be traced back to a particular Green Lantern issue where Kyle Rayner’s girlfriend, Alexandra DeWitt, met an unfortunate end at the hands of Major Force and was left in a refrigerator. As it turns out, she was created with this fate in mind, aiming to make her death resonate with readers. I, for one, find this trend deeply disappointing, as it devalues the importance and complexity of female characters in comic books.

Marz explained that he put a great deal of thought into developing the character, aiming to make her appealing and her demise impactful to readers. The purpose of her death was to convey to Kyle, the Green Lantern, that being a superhero wasn’t merely entertaining; it was a serious responsibility. Furthermore, her death was intended to symbolize his separation from his past and set the stage for his relocation to New York. Lastly, he wanted her death to be striking, serving as a reminder of just how wicked Major Force truly was. Essentially, she was placed in the “fridge.

7) Spidey: A Universe X Special – Called out former Marvel EIC Bob Harras

As a passionate fan of cinema and comics, I’d put it this way: The Earth X series by Marvel Comics mirrors the epic storyline of Kingdom Come, crafted by Jim Krueger and Alex Ross. This narrative saga eventually branched off into two sequels – Universe X and Paradise X. The heart of the tale unfolds in the middle installment, sparking a flurry of spin-off one-shots like Spidey: A Universe X Special, which showcased the diverse Spider-Men hailing from Earth X. However, beneath the surface of this comic, a contentious issue surfaced, stirring up some uncomfortable feelings.

As an ardent admirer, I’m sharing that artist Al Milgrom seized the chance to air out some personal grievances, subtly criticizing ex-Marvel editor-in-chief Bob Harras through a secretly embedded message within his artwork.

Message: Bob Harras. Laugh, Laugh. He’s Departed. Farewell to Troublesome Trash. He was a harsh Individual,” reads the text. It seems difficult to trace exactly when the problems arose, but they were eventually addressed and resolved, causing the content to be pulled from further publications. This message was subsequently omitted from subsequent editions.

8) League of Extraordinary Gentlemen #5 – Marvel Douche Advert

One decision by DC Comics executive Paul Levitz contributed to the departure of the fifth issue of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen Vol. 1 from comic book stores, creating a minor controversy that adds an amusing twist to the history between DC, Marvel, and Alan Moore.

In this situation, Moore adds an authentic advertisement for a product named Amaze Whirling Spray Syringe to the storyline, which has sparked controversy due to possible legal issues with Marvel Comics. This has led to the removal of the Marvel name and its replacement with “Amaze.” Moore seems to anticipate the potential consequences, humorously addressing it in a panel from his comic series Top 10. This is just another installment in his ongoing disputes with both Marvel and DC Comics.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/james-tynion-iv-tiny-onion-humble-bundle-5-publishers/embed/#

2025-07-21 20:17