8 Greatest Western Shows of the 21st Century

Westerns have become popular on TV again in the 21st century, with shows like Yellowstone and Justified offering modern takes on the genre. But viewers often miss out on series that are actually set in the Old West, bringing that rugged frontier era to life. These authentic Westerns deserve more recognition, as they often feature high-quality production, compelling stories, and immersive experiences.

While shows like Longmire and The Mandalorian have popularized a modern take on the Western genre, classic Westerns still have a dedicated following. This list highlights the best Western series of the 21st century, from shows based on the lives of famous lawmen to compelling fictional stories, offering fans a return to the days of the American frontier.

The English Doesn’t Get Enough Recognition

The story begins with Lady Cornelia Locke, a wealthy Englishwoman, traveling to the American West seeking revenge for her son’s death. Her journey leads her to Eli Whipp, a Pawnee war veteran who is heading to Nebraska to start a new life.

This miniseries portrays a powerful connection between characters, forged through hardship in a harsh Western setting. It captures the essence of the West with a unique style, feeling authentic without being overly dramatic. Beautifully filmed and paced, it doesn’t shy away from the grim realities of the time, aiming to deliver a realistic depiction of the Old West.

“The English” isn’t so much an exciting adventure as a somber exploration of past wrongs. The show really shines because of the compelling connection between the characters Whipp and Locke – their chemistry is as good as you’ll find in top-tier dramas.

Hell On Wheels Is a Modern-Day Outlaw Josey Wales

The series Hell On Wheels is set right after the American Civil War. It centers on Cullen Bohannon, a former Confederate soldier who seeks revenge for the murder of his family. Fueled by anger, he hunts down Union soldiers along the expanding railroad lines, determined to avenge his wife and son.

Over time, he finds work with the railroads and becomes a key player in the struggle to dominate business and trade in the West. The show’s atmosphere shifts between the epic feel of films like Once Upon a Time in the West and the gritty realism of The Outlaw Josey Wales, ultimately focusing on the end of the traditional “Wild West” era.

As a Western fan, I always appreciated this show – even though it’s a fictional story, it really captured the spirit of how the railroads changed the frontier, and it didn’t shy away from showing the shady dealings between the powerful landowners of the time. Plus, five seasons is a huge accomplishment for a classic Western – it maintained its quality throughout its entire run, which is something I always look for.

Peacemakers Is a Procedural In the Wild West

Featuring Tom Berenger, Peacemakers is set in Silver City, Colorado. The story follows Jared Stone, a deputy marshal, as he teams up with a private detective to keep the peace. They often rely on Katie Owen, the town mortician, who uses basic forensic skills to help solve local murder mysteries.

This team works like the Wild West version of a crime scene investigation unit. The show, Peacemakers, initially seems like it might not be very good, but viewers will be happily surprised. It successfully brings the familiar procedural format to an Old West setting.

Peacemakers stands out from typical crime shows. Its unique use of forensic science combined with a compelling Western setting gives it a special appeal.

Broken Trail Is an Epic Cowboy Adventure

Broken Trail tells the story of Prent, an older cowboy, and his nephew Tom as they lead a horse drive across the American West. During their journey, they come across a man who is illegally holding five Chinese women captive. Prent and Tom free the women and decide to bring them along on the drive.

Throughout their journey, the characters encounter increasing challenges of the wild west, deepening their involvement in the unfolding events. The action sequences aren’t just for show; they propel the narrative and contribute to a compelling character study. This second installment of Robert Duvall’s excellent work, Broken Trail, expands on themes found in films like Open Range.

This is a classic cowboy story, but it moves beyond typical tales of sheriffs and gunfights to tell a grander, more intimate story. It’s a sweeping Western adventure that honestly portrays a difficult period in history, all while remaining a heartwarming family drama.

Lawman Bass Reeves Explores the Life of a Legendary Gunslinger

I’ve been following the story of Bass Reeves, and it’s incredible. It starts during the Civil War, when he was enslaved and realized he had to take his own freedom – it wouldn’t just be handed to him. He faced some really tough times, including hardship and living with Native American tribes, but eventually, he set out to find his wife and create a life for himself and his family. It’s a powerful beginning to his journey.

Facing hardship, he becomes a lawman, bringing his skills and a sense of fairness to the Wild West. Created by Taylor Sheridan, Lawman: Bass Reeves tells the story of Bass Reeves, a true hero of the Old West, and is based on the incredible details of his life, delivering an exciting action-adventure.

Although not entirely accurate, the series offers a compelling portrayal of a lawman in the Old West, blending the feel of the film True Grit with historical elements. However, it didn’t attract as much of an audience as 1923, possibly because it featured a Black lead or didn’t fit the typical style of shows like Yellowstone.

Into the West Juxtaposes the Settler and Native Experiences

Into the West is a fresh take on the classic John Wayne movie, following the Wheeler family’s westward adventure. Their travels bring them face-to-face with a heartbreaking chapter in American history – the struggles and destiny of Native Americans.

The story alternates between the viewpoints of Jacob Wheeler, the head of the Wheeler family, and Loved By the Buffalo, a Native American man fighting to protect his people and their way of life from encroaching settlers. Into the West was unique for its time – and remains so for many Westerns – because it centered the experiences and perspectives of Native Americans within its narrative.

Many historical dramas don’t fully represent the experiences and viewpoints of Native Americans when portraying westward expansion and settlement. This powerful, yet often forgotten, miniseries – created by Steven Spielberg – is a sweeping story that stands alongside the best films and TV shows, and encourages viewers to consider a different side of American history.

1883 Is a Cinematic Frontier Miniseries

Following the success of his show Yellowstone, Taylor Sheridan created the miniseries 1883 to tell the story of how the Dutton family first came to own their land. The show centers on a wagon train led by a Civil War veteran as they journey across the dangerous American frontier. Along the way to Montana, James Dutton, the founder of the Yellowstone Ranch, must keep his family safe from disease, attacks, and the harsh conditions of the wilderness.

The new show, while attempting to build a legacy, often feels overly promotional. The earlier installments, however, more effectively captured the genre’s complex and sometimes grim elements.

Watching these shows feels like witnessing history unfold, and 1883 is particularly remarkable for its authentic portrayal of frontier life. With stronger acting, writing, and directing than most Westerns, it’s easily the best limited series of the 2020s so far.

Deadwood Is the Definitive 21st Century Western

The show Deadwood is set in the rough-and-tumble town of Deadwood during the Old West era. Lawman Seth Bullock attempts to bring order to the chaotic settlement, but his efforts are constantly challenged by Al Swearengen, a ruthless and powerful criminal who controls much of the town.

While Al struggles to hold onto power, the show offers a remarkably realistic portrayal of frontier life. This groundbreaking HBO series revitalized the Western genre, boasting an exceptional cast for its time. With performances that became career highlights and Ian McShane delivering a truly unforgettable villain, the show quickly established itself as a modern classic.

Despite being canceled too soon, Deadwood is unanimously recognized as a modern Western masterpiece.

Quiz

5 Questions

The Forgotten Frontier: 21st Century Westerns Quiz

Your Top Score

—

Attempts

—

Report Error

Found an error? Send it so it can be corrected.

2026-05-11 20:43