Star Trek Finally Delivers The Iconic Sci-Fi Crossover That Combines 120 Years of Lore

by

Delving into the realm of science fiction television, two legendary series that have been captivating audiences for decades – Star Trek and Doctor Who – finally intersected explicitly in 2025. As an avid fan, I’ve always marveled at their striking similarities. Both series originated in the 1960s, both weave intricate lore and vast universes, and both have fostered passionate, multi-generational fandoms. So resonant are they in tone and theme that fans have often pondered if they might be set within the same universe. And what a thrilling thought it was to imagine the day when the paths of a Starfleet Captain and a certain enigmatic traveler with a box would cross!

Difficult, shmifficult. Let me share with you a tale about the time I interacted with the time-traveling Doctor I once knew.” Since Pelia is a Lanthanite and has lived for centuries, her mentioned encounter is the most overt indication yet of a connection that’s been suggested for many years.

Going further than that comparison, there’s a deep weave of folklore connecting the two series, and what stands out most is the strong yearning for their stories to intersect. However, one might wonder if such an event could ever truly materialize?

The History of Star Trek & Doctor Who’s Links

The concept of the Doctor joining the Starship Enterprise isn’t something freshly conceived; it’s been entertained by fans for some time. As early as 2005, when Doctor Who was reborn under Russell T Davies, Star Trek: Enterprise was still airing. Davies even confessed in his book The Writer’s Tale that he had seriously considered proposing a crossover, yearning to see the Doctor disrupting Starfleet’s pompous demeanor with his unique Doctor persona. It’s an intriguing notion, and we can only imagine the dynamic clash if David Tennant’s 10th Doctor or Matt Smith’s slightly unhinged 11th Doctor were to square off against Captain Kirk’s determined leadership style, potentially causing chaos within Starfleet’s strict rules and regulations. However, it’s also possible that they might get along splendidly.

Discussions were said to have taken place between BBC producers and Paramount during the final season of “Enterprise” about the potential for a merger, but unfortunate cancellation of the show halted these plans before they could begin. Later on, Davies thought about modifying the idea for the Doctor Who Easter special “Planet of the Dead,” however, he determined that if he couldn’t use the actual Starship Enterprise, it wasn’t worth attempting a mock version.

Prior to its departure, the Enterprise team orchestrated a type of crossover reminiscent of Doctor Who. In an episode titled “Future Tense”, they stumbled upon a time vessel – alas, not in the iconic shape of a police phone booth (a point of contention within the Star Trek writers’ room). Yet, it possessed a similar characteristic: being “larger on the inside than on the outside”.

Fans who have been eagerly anticipating a possible crossover between these shows for years are finding it extremely aggravating when the two series seem to continually elude each other. It appears that as one show experiences a comeback, the other appears to be declining unfortunately. In 2024, during the much-discussed “Space Babies” episode, companion Ruby mentioned Star Trek, and Ncuti Gatwa’s Fifteenth Doctor playfully suggested they ought to drop by the Enterprise crew some time.

This remark from the 15th Doctor subtly raised some intriguing questions about how ‘Star Trek’ could coexist as a real TV show within the ‘Doctor Who’ universe. Despite this, it ignited new optimism among fans. With Doctor Who securing a flashy new deal with Disney, potentially boosting its budget and influence over Paramount, and numerous new Star Trek projects in progress or upcoming, it seemed like the perfect opportunity for these universes to merge spectacularly. However, sadly, it did not happen.

Easter Eggs Across Time and Space

For quite some time, even before their official merger, the two franchises have subtly hinted at a potential connection. They’ve occasionally flirted with this idea in various ways, such as alluding to shared galaxies and planets, or the 12th Doctor (played by Peter Capaldi) quoting part of Star Trek’s iconic opening monologue in an episode. This playful interchange between the shows, spanning across different dimensions, has been quite frequent.

In simpler terms, it’s been hinted that some version of the TV show “Star Trek” exists within the universe of “Doctor Who” since at least 2005. Characters like Rose Tyler have made references to Star Trek in episodes such as “The Empty Child”. In a later episode, “The Impossible Astronaut”, Amy Pond mistakes an alien for someone wearing a “Star Trek” mask. This suggests that even within the fictional world of “Doctor Who”, people might be familiar with “Star Trek”.

In a nod to the original series, “Star Trek” often incorporates subtle homages. For instance, in the “Star Trek: The Next Generation” episode titled “The Neutral Zone,” you might notice that the names of the first six doctors are displayed on a console readout. Additionally, in the episode “The Naked Now,” First Officer Will Riker (Jonathan Frakes) asks for a “sonic driver,” which is a reference to a tool used by Dr. McCoy in the original series.

These moments are enjoyable, but in reality, they don’t contribute much beyond creating confusion about whether they’re tribute or genuine elements. The appearance of a floating police box could be the most obvious allusion yet, but is this TARDIS reference just a nod to fans, or does it suggest that the Doctor exists within the Star Trek universe?

In this context, “TARDIS” refers to the time and space machine from the British TV series “Doctor Who,” and “Easter egg” is a term for hidden messages or references in media for dedicated fans to find. The “Doctor” is the main character of Doctor Who, an alien Time Lord with multiple regenerations throughout the show’s history. “Star Trek” is another popular science fiction series.

Could A Real Star Trek & Doctor Who Crossover Work?

Couldn’t it be more appropriate to contemplate whether such a crossover, not just a casual mention, would truly be feasible? Following the lessons from “Jurassic Park”, doing something is not always the same as it being wise to do so. Both franchises seem to share fundamental principles – exploration, compassion, inquisitiveness, and faith that wisdom can triumph over violence, despite Starfleet sometimes displaying a propensity for quick trigger fingers…

As a fervent advocate for both the Doctor and Starfleet, I must acknowledge that, on paper, their shared ideals could make them natural allies. However, after some initial clashes over the question of whether it’s acceptable to bear arms, there are distinct differences that set them apart.

In essence, Star Trek can be viewed as a captivating drama revolving around highly skilled professionals executing duties and adhering to protocols. On the other hand, Doctor Who is an exhilarating tale about a rule-breaking maverick who often operates beyond the laws of his own kind, thriving on defying conventions, as he once famously stated: “Keep out signs are more like suggestions than actual orders.”

Given that Starfleet’s Prime Directive is centered around non-interference, it might just induce cardiac arrest among commanding officers to witness the Doctor’s penchant for interfering whenever and wherever he feels compelled.

Despite some concerns, it’s clear that many fans are eager for this crossover due to the potential cultural conflicts. Think about Captain Pike grappling with a first-contact predicament, only to have the Doctor mischievously disregard his directives. Or consider Spock attempting to comprehend the Doctor’s technobabble using his classic Vulcan reasoning. These disparities could lead not only to hilarious exchanges but also insightful discussions on how to approach universal exploration and protection – a shared objective for both entities, albeit in different ways. However, maintaining continuity might prove challenging.

As a movie enthusiast, I find an intriguing parallel between “Star Trek” and “Doctor Who,” two iconic science fiction series that, despite hailing from different universes, share striking similarities. Both universes are governed by their own well-established, yet distinct, rules, not unlike two neighboring galaxies with overlapping territories but unique identities.

While “Star Trek” boasts the United Federation of Planets, “Doctor Who” presents the ‘Galactic Federation.’ Similarly, Starfleet from “Star Trek” can be likened to the ‘Shadow Proclamation’ in “Doctor Who,” a celestial law enforcement body that The Doctor describes as the ‘cosmic police force.’

Moreover, both shows are populated with their fair share of adversaries. “Star Trek” introduces us to the Romulans and the Borg, while “Doctor Who” offers up the Daleks and Cybermen – it seems the list is endless. It’s a bit like comparing two rival football teams from different towns: similar in spirit, yet fiercely competitive.

Lastly, let’s not forget the intricate timelines that both shows weave. Each has its own chronology of events, a historical narrative that shapes the future of humanity as it ventures into the cosmos. While these timelines often contradict one another, they serve to fuel the imagination and keep us enthralled.

In simpler terms, the question arises as to why the Doctor, who seems particularly interested in humanity and often appears during critical times for the crew of the Enterprise, wasn’t present when the Enterprise encountered difficulties. Given that we now know the Doctor exists in the same universe, his absence raises questions about his whereabouts during those times.

When it comes to a potential crossover between Doctor Who and Star Trek, it’s important to consider whether these two universes truly overlap or if there’s another explanation for their existence. With the multiverse being a popular concept in storytelling today, the answer could potentially be adjusted (retconned) to fit this scenario, but care would need to be taken in its execution.

In 2012, IDW Comics came up with an intricate “universe merging” narrative as a solution to blend the distinctive worlds of “Star Trek” and “Doctor Who” when they published what is considered the only genuine crossover between the two. The limited series, titled “Star Trek: The Next Generation/Doctor Who – Assimilation²“, featured Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor joining forces with Captain Jean-Luc Picard and the crew of the Enterprise-D to combat a formidable alliance between the Borg and the Cybermen. Despite being an entertaining read, the series showcased the challenges involved in harmonizing two large franchises, each with its unique style and tone.

So Could A Star Trek/Doctor Who Crossover Really Happen?

The main challenge isn’t strictly creative; it’s a corporate one. Shows like “Doctor Who,” which is made by the BBC and distributed globally by Disney+, and “Star Trek,” still owned by Paramount, present a unique situation. A genuine crossover would necessitate an unprecedented joint agreement between two massive media corporations that don’t always cooperate amicably on such matters.

As a fervent movie enthusiast, I can’t help but express my anticipation regarding an intriguing possibility that surfaced at San Diego Comic-Con 2024. During a joint panel, the masterminds behind “Doctor Who,” Russell T Davies, and “Star Trek” producer Alex Kurtzman shared their collective excitement about a potential collaboration.

In a thrilling exchange, Davies asserted emphatically, “It simply must happen!”, to which Kurtzman enthusiastically nodded in agreement. If the fanbase’s demand continues to swell, it might just persuade Disney and Paramount to seize the opportunity to unite two prestigious franchises for a singular television or cinematic spectacle. Fingers crossed!

In the current age of streaming, where blendings and interconnected storylines are becoming more frequent, the circumstances have never been more advantageous. Given the ambiguity about its future, it seems that Doctor Who might be actively seeking grand, noteworthy concepts to establish itself on Disney+ (such as the surprising decision to bring back Billie Piper). Meanwhile, Star Trek is keen on extending its influence further. A crossover between these two franchises could potentially create a culturally significant event that will be remembered for years to come.

In simpler terms, the brief appearance of the TARDIS in “Strange New Worlds” and the hint of a time-traveling Doctor could be seen as subtle jokes, but if used appropriately, they might serve as the initial clues leading to something more significant. Even though a full-fledged crossover may not happen, it’s clear that the creative teams on both shows are open to hinting at the potential connection and even subtly acknowledging the possibility.

At present, enthusiasts can amuse themselves contemplating potential scenarios should the Doctor actually board the Enterprise: exchanging quick-witted dialogue with Spock, or perhaps imparting knowledge about space-time vessels with expandable interiors to Scotty. In such a vast cosmos, it’s not unimaginable that bizarre events like this could transpire!

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/every-doctor-who-actor-who-appeared-in-star-trek/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-11 01:44