10 DC Villains Who Had a Point (Even If Their Crimes Were Unforgivable)

As a devoted fan, I’ve always admired how DC Comics has evolved over the years. Initially, it was known for its fantastical and childlike tales, but as Marvel pioneered complex superhero narratives during the Silver Age, DC surpassed them in many intelligent ways. This evolution significantly impacted their villains, initially perceived as jokes, transforming into intricate characters whose objectives became less absurd and more relatable. I found myself better comprehending their outlandish goals because they started to resonate with a sense of logic.

In DC Comics, there’s no shortage of ruthless villains, but many of them also present valid arguments that challenge our perspectives. Though we may not condone their violent tactics, it’s difficult to deny the validity in their motivations. Over time, some of these villains have become particularly captivating due to the truth they embody, despite their horrific methods. Here are ten such DC villains whose viewpoints, though brutally expressed, hold a compelling argument.

10) Pariah

In my view, the comic series “Dark Crisis on Infinite Earths” is significantly undervalued, largely due to its villain Pariah. Originally a scientist from one of the doomed Earths during the “Crisis on Infinite Earths“, he was cursed for his discovery of the Anti-Monitor and Monitor. As the universe collapsed around him, Pariah jumped from world to world. Eventually, he joined forces with the heroes and played a crucial role in saving the Multiverse. Tragically, he was killed before “Infinite Crisis“, only to return when the DC Multiverse was rebooted.

Pariah’s sanity had been shattered by the horrific sights he witnessed, leading him to believe that he must recreate the old multiverse in order to find his lost home. This goal, on the surface, is not inherently wrong; the original “Crisis” resulted in the death of countless beings, so Pariah’s desire for their resurrection could be seen as compassionate. However, things took a sinister turn when Pariah decided to harness the Great Darkness as his tool and sought to use the energy of the greatest heroes to recreate the multiverse. If he had approached the heroes with a request for assistance instead, he likely would have succeeded because his intent was justifiable.

9) The Crime Syndicate

Earth-2,” they resisted being saved by the Justice League because they believed the JLA was mistaken in trying to help them. Interestingly, the Crime Syndicate’s altruism was exploited by Brainiac, almost leading to their world’s destruction before they returned. In more recent appearances (New 52), they migrated to Prime Earth due to their home being destroyed by the Anti-Monitor and sought a new place to live. While deserving of a home, they should not rule it.

8) Vandal Savage

In simpler terms, Vandal Savage is one of the Justice League’s most formidable adversaries, a being who has been around since the dawn of humanity. Throughout his 100,000 years of existence, his guiding principle has been to fulfill his desires, much like all living beings strive to survive, reproduce, and ensure their species’ continuity. While this instinct is natural, it’s Vandal Savage’s relentless pursuit and excessive accumulation that make his actions cruel. Essentially, he embodies the survival of the fittest, a concept inherent in nature. However, it’s his insatiable greed that sets him apart as evil. In essence, Vandal Savage is just trying to survive and acquire what he wants, which is, at its core, a common goal for all living beings.

7) Amanda Waller

Amanda Waller, a character in the DC Universe, often appears as an adversary, yet her reasons for doing so are tough to dispute. Waller maintains that metahumans pose a threat and necessitate some form of governance. Given the havoc wreaked by evil metahumans on Earth – with millions of lives lost even before considering Crisis events that have reshaped reality numerous times – her perspective seems valid. The project titled Absolute Power was Waller’s latest attempt to manage metahumanity, albeit through questionable methods. However, anyone who doubts the need for Waller’s stance should consider the kind of world we would inhabit if metahumans were present without restrictions.

6) Ra’s al Ghul

Ra’s al Ghul, another immortal character from DC Comics, has a more compelling motivation compared to Vandal Savage. Over centuries, he has observed humanity and seen how they negatively impact the world, similar to a cancerous growth. His goal is to ensure the Earth’s survival, as he believes that unchecked human population growth and overreliance on technology will ultimately destroy our planet. To achieve this, Ra’s al Ghul intends to take drastic measures, aiming to reduce the human population significantly. While his methods are questionable, the underlying message – that humanity is recklessly damaging the Earth for the benefit of a few – holds merit. However, eliminating 90% of the human race is an extremely extreme solution, and one that would be morally wrong.

5) Sinestro

Originally, Sinestro was the most distinguished Green Lantern among all. Unlike many others, Sinestro harbors a strong disdain for the disorder brought about by evil and strives to maintain order for the greater good. However, his method of achieving this order is questionable as he seeks to instill fear within those he protects, thereby controlling them to uphold his definition of order. Such an approach mirrors that of fascists. Sinestro views those who don’t conform to his perspective as misguided and in need of correction.

While it is true that chaos can be detrimental to society, and order essential for prosperity, Sinestro’s use of fear to ensure compliance borders on tyranny, which is why he is often considered a villain.

4) Alexander Luthor

The epic tale known as “Infinite Crisis” significantly shaped DC’s multiverse by reintroducing elements from the original “Crisis on Infinite Earths.” This narrative features Alexander Luthor and Superboy-Prime, who were dissatisfied with the current dark state of the DC Universe. They envisioned a utopian Earth where happiness prevails, free from any misfortune.

Indeed, their assessment was correct; the universe had grown significantly darker than its previous incarnation. Heroes had become tainted, and villains transformed into insatiable monsters that consumed everything in their path. Akin to Pariah later, if Alexander Luthor had sought assistance from the heroes, they likely would have collaborated with him to create this ideal Earth.

However, Luthor chose a self-guided approach, leading to catastrophic consequences across the universe. Millions of lives were lost in his quest for an outcome whose success was uncertain.

3) Two-Face

Initially, Harvey Dent was an advocate for justice in Gotham City, striving to make it better. Yet, beneath Two-Face’s facade lurked a sinister side that would stop at nothing to safeguard itself. This dark aspect emerged when Dent was assaulted in the courtroom, leaving him with severe burns on one side of his face. This traumatic event shifted his perspective on life, causing him to perceive it as a simple battle between right and wrong.

However, it’s not incorrect to say that Two-Face is correct. There are individuals who perform good deeds while also committing evil acts, believing they are doing what’s right. While actions can have various nuances, the world generally operates on the basis of contrasts – light versus dark, good versus bad, abundance and scarcity.

But this realization doesn’t mean giving up on society or accepting this duality as a fact; rather, it offers a different perspective that’s worth considering.

2) The Joker

In simpler terms, the Joker may be insane, but even the most mentally unstable individuals can have valid perspectives. In the comic “The Killing Joke,” though the Joker misinterpreted the outcome, he wasn’t entirely off-base with his assertion that one bad day can significantly alter a person’s life. Just as one terrible day transformed Bruce Wayne into Batman, many other people have undergone transformation following a single catastrophic event – yet not all of them became villains like the Joker. Life often brings about change, and while it may seem daunting, these changes aren’t always negative; they can lead to personal growth and even transformation into something better.

In the case of Commissioner Jim Gordon in “The Killing Joke,” his one bad day had a profound impact on him, but instead of breaking him, it strengthened his commitment to justice. The Joker was right about change being an inevitable part of life, but he erred in thinking that such changes inexorably lead to villainy.

1) Lex Luthor

Among villains, Lex Luthor stands out for his extraordinary intelligence; however, his ego is even more formidable and has led him astray on several occasions. Interestingly enough, one area where Lex Luthor’s insights prove valid is in regard to Superman’s influence on society. Lex Luthor often discusses the societal impact of Superman, arguing that he acts like a super-powered caretaker who fosters an overreliance on him. This perspective offers a keen observation. Throughout history, humans have been known to seize any opportunities for shortcuts, allowing their problem-solving skills to deteriorate. With Superman present, people don’t feel the necessity to think of solutions; instead, they wait for Superman to handle the situation. Lex Luthor might be wrong about many aspects that fuel his disdain for Superman, but it cannot be denied that his idea of Superman as a super-nanny who ultimately undermines humanity’s abilities resonates with real-life situations we witness frequently.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-most-underrated-dc-stories/embed/#

2025-09-14 02:14