The X-Men originated as a team dedicated to defending mutants and working towards a peaceful coexistence between humans and mutants. Over the years, they’ve achieved incredible feats for the mutant community. It’s highly likely that without the X-Men, the mutant race would have faced extinction on numerous occasions. They’ve provided mutants with a safe haven and support, striving to help them control their abilities and consistently risking their own safety in the process. The X-Men committed themselves to building a better world, though not every action they took for mutants was necessarily perfect.
As a longtime movie buff, I’ve noticed something over the years: the X-Men, despite their best efforts, have *really* let down the mutant community more than once. They often find themselves in no-win scenarios, and honestly, there have been times they’ve just flat-out failed mutants. Here are ten instances where the X-Men completely dropped the ball, leading to some truly awful consequences for the mutant race. It’s tough to watch, but it’s a pattern I’ve definitely spotted. It’s a complicated history, to say the least. They mean well, but sometimes good intentions aren’t enough.
10. “Onslaught”
The “Onslaught” storyline featured Xavier turning villainous and nearly wiping out the world. He unintentionally created the Onslaught persona through a mindwipe of Magneto, and then devised a scheme to allow Onslaught to destroy humanity. This presented a huge challenge for the X-Men, who didn’t even know who Onslaught was. The initial fight against Onslaught began, but the X-Men were unable to contain him. They knew he was coming, but surprisingly, they didn’t seek assistance from other hero teams. Onslaught’s attack on New York City, and the apparent “death” of the Avengers and Fantastic Four caused by mutants, fueled global hatred toward mutants, ultimately leading to Operation: Zero Tolerance, a campaign targeting them. Had the X-Men been more proactive, it’s likely this entire crisis could have been avoided.
9. Trusting Mister Sinister in the Krakoa Era
I’ve always been fascinated by Mister Sinister, but also deeply wary of him. He’s definitely one of the X-Men’s biggest enemies, driven by this intense focus on genetics that constantly puts him at odds with the team. What really bothers me is how untrustworthy he is, and that makes his involvement in the Krakoa Era so troubling. He did contribute a lot – his collection of mutant DNA was essential for making Krakoan resurrection a reality – but honestly, if there was *any* villain who shouldn’t have been on the Quiet Council, it was him. Looking back, his schemes throughout this period just made things harder for mutants. He was always only looking out for himself, and his plans nearly led to global destruction! I truly believe things could have turned out differently for Krakoa if they’d kept a tighter rein on him.
8. General Public Relations
This might seem strange, but consider this: if the X-Men had a better relationship with the public, life would be much easier for mutants. The X-Men have a long history of heroic deeds, and while they’ve saved the world countless times, they aren’t as popular with ordinary people as other superhero teams. Every group of heroes in the Marvel Universe has stumbled in their public image at some point, but the X-Men consistently struggle the most. If they’d invested in public relations – perhaps by hiring a PR professional or simply making a greater effort to win over the public – mutants would likely be in a far better position today. It’s a simple idea with potentially huge consequences.
7. Avengers vs. X-Men
Avengers vs. X-Men was a really damaging event for the X-Men and had serious consequences for all mutants. Basically, the Avengers attacked the X-Men because of the return of the Phoenix Force. Cyclops believed he could use the Phoenix Force to revitalize the mutant population, but Wolverine didn’t agree and sided with the Avengers. The key point is that if Cyclops had simply explained his plans to the leaders of the superhero community himself, this whole conflict might have been avoided. He could have collaborated with the smartest minds in the Marvel Universe to control the Phoenix Force and ensure the survival of mutantkind. Ultimately, this situation made mutants appear even more negatively to the public, and it was a completely preventable disaster.
6. House of M
House of M is famous for being the story where mutants lost their powers. While it’s difficult to pinpoint who’s at fault, I believe the primary responsibility lies with Wanda Maximoff. The X-Men sought assistance from the Avengers regarding Wanda, but some members (most notably Wolverine, though he wasn’t the only one) advocated for killing her. Quicksilver overheard this discussion and alerted Wanda and Magneto. Had everyone remained calmer initially, particularly the X-Men, the situation could have been avoided, and the mutant population wouldn’t have been depowered.
5. “Days of Future Past”
“Days of Future Past” dramatically altered the course of mutant history. It was the first story to depict a bleak future dominated by Sentinels. This future essentially became *the* standard for what could happen to mutants, and it all stemmed from the actions of the X-Men. These awful timelines where mutants are defeated by humans, machines, or a combination of both, are consistently tied to failures by the X-Men. They haven’t been able to prevent conflict between humans and mutants, and the outcome is always the same: the complete annihilation of mutantkind by their adversaries.
4. Cyclops’s Revolutionary X-Men
Following the events of Avengers vs. X-Men, Cyclops was imprisoned due to his actions involving the Dark Phoenix. However, Magneto, Magik, and Emma Frost orchestrated a breakout, which led Cyclops to form a new X-Men team with the goal of directly fighting for mutant rights against humanity. They aimed to be a revolutionary force, but ultimately failed. While the team started with good intentions, they quickly became involved in conflicts that didn’t contribute to improving the lives of mutants. Cyclops’s team accomplished nothing for mutantkind, and surprisingly, Cyclops then claimed they had succeeded. The entire endeavor was illogical and offered no benefit to mutants.
3. X-Men: Schism
X-Men: Schism marked a major conflict between Cyclops and Wolverine, stemming from their differing beliefs. At this time, around 200 mutants lived together for a key reason: strength in numbers. Being united made them more difficult to defeat. However, X-Men: Schism resulted in a division within the mutant community based on these opposing ideologies. This split created animosity between the two sides, ultimately weakening mutants as a group. They already faced challenges from humanity, and now had to contend with internal conflict as well. The long-standing feud between Cyclops and Wolverine proved costly for mutants, contributing to years of errors that put them in danger.
2. Not Destroying Graymalkin Prison
As a longtime X-Men fan, I’m really disturbed by what’s happened with the X-Mansion during the Krakoa Era. It’s heartbreaking that they abandoned it, and even worse that the government took it over after Krakoa fell and turned it into a mutant prison! I just don’t understand why the X-Men haven’t done more. Instead of trying to free those held at Graymalkin, or even fighting for their rights in court – seriously, there are superpowered law firms in the Marvel Universe! – they’re just letting this happen. It’s their former home! To see mutants being experimented on and their lives taken within those walls is awful, and it feels like a huge symbol of how powerless mutantkind has become. The worst part, to me, is that the X-Men haven’t actively tried to shut Graymalkin down, and have even worked with the jailers at times. It’s incredibly damaging to everything the X-Men stand for.
1. The Fall of Krakoa
The Krakoa Era fundamentally reshaped the lives of mutants. The X-Men established a haven for mutantkind, funded by unique medicines they alone could produce. For the first time, mutants experienced both security and influence. They had a choice: join a team and defend Krakoa, or simply relax and socialize with other mutants. It was a golden age for mutants, but the X-Men ultimately weren’t able to maintain it. Had the X-Men been more strategic in establishing the mutant nation, things could have been much improved, providing mutants with a safe place to live, free from the hostility of humans.
https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-best-x-men-stories-20s-marvel-comics/embed/#
Read More
- Eve Teschmacher’s Secret: How She REALLY Saved Superman!
- EUR CLP PREDICTION
- Gold Rate Forecast
- Dying Light: The Beast’s Ending Leaves Big Clues for Dying Light 3
- How to get double jump in Hollow Knight: Silksong explained
- Demon Slayer Dub Ruined One Key Moment & It Took 5 Years to Resolve It
- I Can’t Believe Marvel Just Broke 1 Avenger’s Power Rules For The 3rd Time
- BREAKING: Paramount Prepares Bid to Acquire Warner Bros. Discovery in Massive Media Earthquake
- Marvel’s 10 Greatest Cosmic-Level Crossover Events (Including Imperial)
- Hand-drawn black-and-white dungeon RPG The Secret of Weepstone announced for PC
2025-10-02 14:18